- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PVCast forecasts the joint distribution of power from multiple PV systems. It generates possible cloud trajectories with transport and source-sink dynamics, and uses them to predict system-level power quantiles and couple the samples across sites and time. Experiments on UKPV, MMSP and PVOD evaluate individual power forecasts, aggregate power and sequences of power changes.
Critical strengths
-
The use of shared cloud trajectories makes sense for this problem: a moving cloud can affect several PV systems at different times. I particularly like that the sampling construction in Section 3.4 couples the outputs without changing their conditional marginal distributions. This also makes the dependence ablation in Table 3 easier to interpret.
-
The aggregate forecasting results are encouraging. In Table 1, UKPV CRPS-sum falls from 0.0165 for MTGNN to 0.0119 for PVCast, and PVCast also has the lowest CRPS-sum on MMSP and PVOD. In Table 2, the full cloud-evolution model performs better on aggregate forecasting than either the advection-only or source-sink-only variant.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is what Table 3 establishes about cloud conditioning. Removing spatial or temporal probability-level coupling makes the corresponding scores worse, but this does not show whether the loadings need to depend on the predicted clouds. In Appendix E.1, even independent sampling retains the shared cloud trajectories and conditional quantiles, so it does not remove all cloud-induced dependence. The no-cloud experiment in Table 2 also changes the marginal forecasts. I would like to see an ablation that keeps the cloud trajectories and conditional quantiles fixed, but replaces the cloud-conditioned loadings with learned, cloud-independent ones.
-
Some details needed to reproduce the second training stage are missing. Section 3.5 gives three loss terms for fitting the dependence parameters, but I could not find their weights or how those weights were selected. Table 4 specifies the number of cloud trajectories S, but not the number of conditional samples R per trajectory.
Questions for authors
-
How does PVCast compare with learned, cloud-independent spatial loadings when the cloud trajectories, conditional quantiles, fitting objective, sampling budget and temporal correlation settings are kept the same?
-
Could you give the three second-stage loss weights, their selection procedure and R? I read the two-stage formulation as keeping the cloud and quantile model fixed while fitting dependence. Please confirm this and clarify which split is used to fit those parameters.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The clarified sampling controls and matched cloud-independent baseline have alleviated some of my concerns and strengthened the empirical evidence. However, I still consider the methodological contribution incremental, primarily extending established dependence modeling through cloud conditioning. The additional results have not sufficiently changed my assessment of its novelty. I therefore maintain my original score.