- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes WeatherBridge, a pre-processing module to transform operational NWP initial states into ERA5 reference states. Experiments show that WeatherBridge can significantly improve the RMSE and ACC of FuXi forecasts initialized with GFS and CMA data, and can be transferred to the FengWu model without further training, bringing improvements.
Critical strengths
WeatherBridge shows strong performance in improving the FuXi model’s forecasts with GFS and CMA initial states, which demonstrates that this work has practical value.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is the novelty. Even within AI-based weather forecasting, a very similar approach has already been used in FuXi-DA [1]. In that work, the baseline EXP_CORR is described as follows: ``a DL model is employed to correct the error between the background field and ERA5, yielding the corrected background field.'' The only major difference from WeatherBridge appears to be whether the background field is a previous forecast result or an initial state from a different NWP source. In addition, FuXi-DA uses the training loss , and the FuXi model remains frozen during training. The ORA loss in this paper appears to correspond to replacing with RMSE and setting . Even though I acknowledge the value of the source conditioning mechanism, I do not think the contributions of this paper meet ICLR's requirements.
[1] Xu, X., Sun, X., Han, W. et al. FuXi-DA: a generalized deep learning data assimilation framework for assimilating satellite observations. npj Clim Atmos Sci 8, 156 (2025).
Questions for authors
- Swin-UNet is a common CV backbone. Have authors made any specific design changes to adapt it from CV to AI-based weather forecasting?
- Why do the validation and test sets not cover a full year of data? Weather patterns should differ to some extent at different times of the year, and not covering a full year may make the evaluation insufficient.
- In the FuXi forecasting experiments, using raw GFS initial states gives worse results than using raw CMA data. However, why does GFS WeatherBridge perform slightly better than CMA WeatherBridge after preprocessing?
- In the second row of Figure 3, there seems to be a light blue line in plots (a relatively clear example is at in the T850 RMSE plot). What data does this line represent?
I acknowledge that this work has practical value, but frankly, my current position is between clear reject and weak reject. I may adjust my score based on the authors' response.