- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an intervention-based identification framework—supported by rigorous mathematical derivation—to address the challenge traditional system identification methods face in reconstructing a complete dynamic system when state-space coverage is insufficient. The theoretical approach offers a degree of novelty, and experimental results provide preliminary validation.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses the issue of system identifiability when the baseline state fails to cover the entire source space, noting that simply increasing the number of trials or sensors does not necessarily eliminate structural unidentifiability; the research motivation is well-founded.
- The authors construct a rank-one matrix based on the response difference between the intervention and baseline conditions; they identify the intervention target and calibrate the response history using the known lead-field, subsequently recovering the state transition matrix by exploiting shift relationships within the observation matrix. The entire process rests on a clear mathematical foundation rather than relying solely on black-box neural networks.
- The paper establishes sufficient conditions for identifiability, separately discussing source space coverage, intervention exposure, anatomical distinguishability, and temporal observability; it also provides bounds on conditional stability, aiding the understanding of the factors contributing to the method's success or failure.
Critical weaknesses
- The real-world EEG experiments primarily validate the transferability and reproducibility of spatial responses but do not actually reconstruct the neural source dynamics matrix F, consequently, they are insufficient to demonstrate that the method can achieve the core functions proposed in the paper within a real neural system.
- The method is relatively sensitive to non-local interventions and forward model mismatches, and its identification performance depends on the extent of intervention coverage and the numerical conditioning of the response history. Its reliability in larger-scale scenarios, under real-world noise, and in complex intervention environments remains to be verified.
Questions for authors
- The most significant theoretical results in this paper rely on a specific intervention mechanism. The authors represent the system as shown in Equation 1, implying that the intervention alters only a single row of the state transition matrix—meaning it changes the input-reception rule for just one neural source—and that this change persists for only one time step before the system immediately reverts to its original dynamics. While this assumption is reasonable for theoretical derivation, a clear gap remains between it and actual neural stimulation processes. Real-world electrical stimulation, optogenetic stimulation, or other neural interventions may simultaneously affect multiple neural sources, introduce direct external inputs, and induce sustained physiological changes. In such cases, observed response differences cannot necessarily be attributed to a change in a single input-reception row, nor does the rank-one structure necessarily hold. (1) In existing neural intervention experiments, which specific stimulation mechanisms can be reasonably approximated as a single-step change in the input-reception rule of a single neural source? (2) Do the existing identification theorems still hold when an intervention affects multiple neural sources simultaneously or when the intervention effects persist over multiple time steps? (3) Is it possible to establish a more systematic quantitative relationship between the degree of non-locality of the intervention and the error in dynamic recovery, and to clearly define the boundaries where the method fails?
- The primary contribution of this paper is the use of unknown local interventions to recover neurally derived dynamic relationships that are unidentifiable from baseline data. However, the paper's analysis of real EEG data focuses primarily on the transferability of spatial response patterns across different stimulus intensities and the impact of trial averaging on the reproducibility of dipole fitting. The authors explicitly acknowledge that these analyses neither recover the true neurodynamic matrix F nor validate the accuracy of the initial state mapping K. The authors should more clearly distinguish between what is validated by the real EEG experiments and the capabilities claimed by the theoretical method, avoiding the conflation of spatial response validation with the validation of neurodynamic identification.
2 comments
Thank you for addressing my questions—best of luck to you!
Response to Reviewer CxT2
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and for questions that sharpen the scope of the paper. Section numbers refer to the revised PDF, where new text is in blue.
W1/Q2. What the real recordings establish. We agree. Each claim of the paper rests on a different kind of evidence:
The recorded direction is measured on injected-current responses, that is on the stimulation artifact and not on neural responses. Its repeatability is the spatial prerequisite for calibration and for artifact correction. Recovery of the dynamics rests on the theory and the simulations.
Q1(1). Which stimulation mechanisms fit the model? The identification result needs less than Eq. 1 suggests: a rank-one contrast with a source-specific response history. A brief focal additive pulse with unknown target and amplitude gives the same structure, so labeling, calibration, column completion and the shift solve are unchanged (§4.1, Appendix A.7). At matched contrast SNR, Direct without any change recovers 26/32 and 32/32 systems at 4,608 and 18,432 episodes, against 24/32 and 32/32 for receiving-row changes (Appendix B.9). When both mechanisms act together, reversing the sign of the initialization separates them exactly (Appendix F). The closest existing schedule is a paired-pulse design: a conditioning stimulus sets the initial state, a brief focal test stimulus perturbs one source, and matched episodes omit the test stimulus. It exists noninvasively (paired-pulse TMS-EEG) and with intracerebral stimulation and scalp EEG, where the stimulated contact is known (323 sessions in 36 patients). Whole-brain models observed through a leadfield have been fitted to these recordings and to TMS-evoked EEG (Momi et al., 2023, 2025). Dynamic clamp gives direct control of a state-dependent current, and J.3 lists what such an experiment has to establish.
Q1(2). Multiple sources or persistent effects. Persistent effects are covered through a different contrast: comparing durations that differ by one transition, at equal elapsed time, gives a rank-one contrast with the same response history, OT((F+De)ℓ+1−F(F+De)ℓ)Rs=(OTej)(ve⊤(F+De)ℓRs). Recovery is exact without noise for durations up to three transitions, and with noise longer durations need more trials (Appendix A.7, Proposition 7). A change in a second source makes the contrast rank two and falls outside the theorem. The data reveal this case before it affects recovery (next point).
Q1(3), W2. Non-locality against recovery, and where the method stops. We varied the coefficient of a second, neighbouring row relative to the primary one (80 systems, 98,304 trial equivalents). A test on the data compares each contrast's second singular value with a noise replicate built from two halves of the same trials (Appendix B.6).
The effect is a bias: a fourfold budget changes one count (67 to 68). The method tolerates a second row of up to 5% of the primary coefficient, recovery degrades from 10%, and every violation that harms recovery is detected.
W2. Forward-model mismatch, noise, scale and reliability.
We would be glad to run any further check and to hear what else would strengthen the paper.