- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The CANDLE study estimates individual cortical source activity from EEG. The model constructs a forward matrix L using the individual T1 MRI, then denoises it with the network f_θ, and recovers the observable components with L^† f_θ (X), and supplements the zero-space components with (I - L^† L) g_γ (L^† f_θ (X)). The training loss includes source reconstruction, sensor denoising, and zero-space error (page 3, §2.1, Equations (1)–(3)). The training simulator combines 1,113 individual geometries, 994 cortical regions of the Jansen–Rit neural population model, and 800 source configurations obtained from 26,273 statistical brain maps. The authors report the simulation tests divided by individuals, the localization of 291 stimulation records from 32 patients, and the reference positioning of the resection areas of 22 patients with good postoperative outcomes.
Critical strengths
The combination of physical observation operators and learning priors has clear technical reasons. The individual L directly determines the projection and the analytical inverse, and the network does not need to redefine the output dimension for each new subject; denoising before inversion also addresses the problem of pseudo-inverse amplifying noise. The entire method does not mistakenly attribute the zero-space unobservability to the absence of a priori knowledge for the unique recovery. This provides a reasonable inductive bias for cross-individual applications.
The tests cover both controlled true values and two actual positioning scenarios simultaneously, and the simulation results have meaningful amplitudes. The simulation adopts a subject-wise division, with the Dice of CANDLE being 0.48, while the best control is 0.33, and the HD95 is also the lowest. The real stimulation results are first aggregated within the subjects, reducing the risk of treating the same patient as multiple independent patients; the authors also publicly explain that the overall difference in the stimulation task relative to sLORETA/GBF is not significant, and the significance of the EZ task only covers part of the controls. These results support further research on this scheme and cannot be simply classified as only having simulation verification.
Critical weaknesses
Currently, the contribution of "individualized zero-space design" compared to general learning models has not been fully recognized. When g_γ is removed in Figure 6, the entire learning source prior is also removed, making it impossible to distinguish the effects of zero-space projection and non-restricted source correction with the same capacity. On the other hand, fixing the fsaverage simulator reduces the stimulus peak distance from 32.9 to 33.6 mm; randomly selecting ROIs increases it to 33.4 mm, while improving EZ HD95 from 61.7 to 59.0 mm. The related simulator ablation report does not show a significant advantage (pages 8-9, Figure 6, §3.4). Moreover, the main text and appendix do not specify whether ConvDip/DeepSIF uses the same anatomical simulation training set, budget, and individual source mapping; only stating that all three use simulation data is not sufficient to confirm this (pages 5, 15). Therefore, the existing results prove the effectiveness of the entire system, but it is still difficult to determine whether the gain comes from the geometric/zero-space constraints emphasized in this paper, or the training distribution or backbone differences. This is a lack of key distinguishing evidence, not because the cited general zero-space methods cannot be used for new problems.
The key processing of real data entering the fixed model is not explained, affecting the verifiability of the geometric constraints and zero-sample results. The model is fixed at BioSemi 64 channels, 500 Hz, 1 second length; pre-processing only includes downsampling, filtering, average reference, and z-score (page 15, B.2). However, the original EZ data provides 257/204 channels, different lengths of average discharge, and the cleaned version is usually 250 Hz, [2] while the manuscript does not explain the channel selection or interpolation, short sequence processing, and whether these transformations are applied synchronously to L. The z-score axis and scale used, as well as how the target is denoised and the L target, are also not explained. If the input/noise reduction target is scaled channel by channel while L maintains another set of units, the analytical part of equation (2) cannot be directly interpreted as an inversion in the same physical coordinates; the current materials cannot determine if the authors have correctly handled it. Additionally, the stimulation evaluation focuses on the ±5 ms window, but does not explain whether the original current pseudotrajectory is retained, deleted, or interpolated in this window. These are unclarified information, not an already confirmed implementation error, but directly affects how the main real data evidence should be interpreted.
Please provide the complete mapping of two real datasets to 64 channels, 500 sampling points, and the reference, scale, region direction, and L processing; also explain the de-noising status of the ±5 ms window, the inclusion rules for 22 EZ patients. If there is a script, please explain the results as to whether they do indeed correspond to the observed model of equation (2) in the processing sequence and necessary formulas. This is mainly to clarify the existing experiments. In the saved predictions, supplementing the peak to the closest distance to the resection cavity is also helpful in judging whether the existing HD95/mass center conclusions depend on the cavity size; no new patient data collection is required.
Questions for authors
see Weaknesses
4 comments
W2 & W3: Details for real-data preprocessing
We describe the detailed evaluation settings for empirical data in the order the points were raised below. For brevity, we refer to the intracranial stimulation localization task as SPES and to the epileptogenic zone estimation task as EZ. Clarifications below have been added to Appendix B.2 of the revised manuscript.
Channel selection (EZ/SPES): The datasets used for the EZ and SPES evaluations include subjects recorded with either 257 or 204 channels. For each recording, we kept only the electrodes whose labels match those of the BioSemi 64-channel montage [5], which is CANDLE’s default montage (Appendix B.2), and used these channels for evaluation.
Variable segment lengths and sampling rate (EZ): As described in Appendix B.2, CANDLE takes as input a 1-s segment sampled at 500 Hz. The EZ data, however, vary in length and were sampled at a lower rate of 250 Hz. We therefore first upsampled the data to 500 Hz. Segments longer than 500 samples were center-cropped and shorter ones were zero-padded to 500 samples. Estimates for the zero-padded intervals were left out of the evaluation.
Unit consistency between the EEG and the lead-field matrix : In all experiments, we applied the same preprocessing to as to the EEG (e.g., common average referencing), so and the EEG remain in consistent units. Please see our response to Reviewer sBb5 (Q3) for details.
Treatment of the ±5 ms window (SPES): Following prior ESI work [6], we applied no preprocessing or artifact removal to this window beyond what is described in Appendix B.2.
Source orientation (EZ/SPES): Throughout this study, we assume that source activity is oriented perpendicular to the cortical surface in each region.
Inclusion criteria for the 22 EZ patients: As stated in Subsection 3.3, we included patients with a favorable outcome 12 months after surgery, defined as ILAE [7] class 1 or 2.
Implementation of the EZ evaluation: The EZ evaluation is implemented in CANDLE/src/datasets/vorderwullbecke_2025/evaluate.py in the supplementary material.
Implementation of Equation (2): Equation (2) is implemented in CANDLE/src/model/CANDLE.py in the supplementary material.
Dependence of the EZ evaluation on resection-cavity size: The centroid distance in the current manuscript is the distance between the centroid of the resection cavity and the centroid of the estimated source activity. It therefore does not depend on the size of the resection cavity.
References
[1] Lukas Hecker, Rebekka Rupprecht, Ludger Tebartz Van Elst, and J ̈urgen Kornmeier. ConvDip: A convolutional neural network for better EEG source imaging. Front. Neurosci., 15:569918, 2021.
[2] Rui Sun, Abbas Sohrabpour, Gregory A Worrell, and Bin He. Deep neural networks constrained by neural mass models improve electrophysiological source imaging of spatiotemporal brain dynamics. PNAS, 119(31):e2201128119, 2022.
[3] Patric Hagmann, Leila Cammoun, Xavier Gigandet, Reto Meuli, Christopher J Honey, Van J Wedeen, and Olaf Sporns. Mapping the structural core of human cerebral cortex. PLoS biology, 6(7):e159, 2008.
[4] Bruce Fischl. FreeSurfer. NeuroImage, 62(2):774–781, 2012.
[5] Robert Oostenveld et al. The five percent electrode system for high-resolution EEG and ERP measurements. Clin. Neurophysiol., 112(4):713–719, 2001.
[6] Song Wang, Kexin Lou, Chen Wei, Zhiyuan Sheng, Jiahao Tang, Kaining Peng, Xinke Shen, Shuhao Mei, Liang Chen, Dongfeng Gu, et al. A geometry aware framework enhances noninvasive mapping of whole human brain dynamics. Nat. Biomed. Eng., 2026.
[7] HG Wieser, WT Blume, D Fish, E Goldensohn, A Hufnagel, D King, MR Sperling, and H Luders. Proposal for a new classification of outcome with respect to epileptic seizures following epilepsy surgery. Epilepsia, 42(2):282–286, 2001.
The authors have responded to each of my points and narrowed the claims to what the experiments actually support. I confirm that there are no remaining issues, and I have raised my score. Best of luck.
We sincerely appreciate your continued engagement and reassessment. While you confirmed that there are no remaining issues, your rating is still "Weak Rejection." Does this mean that you still have some concerns about our work? If so, we would greatly appreciate any additional feedback you could provide to help us further improve our work.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thorough reading of our manuscript. In response, we have added an ablation isolating the null-space constraint and clarified the baseline training configuration and the full preprocessing pipeline for the empirical datasets. All revisions are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript; below, W denotes Weaknesses.
We also noticed that the reviewer set "Flag For Ethics Review" to "Yes". To our understanding, neither the review nor the "Details Of Ethics Concerns" field mentions an ethical issue. Our study uses only simulated data and secondary analyses of publicly available datasets, in accordance with their data-use terms and the ethical approvals reported in the original studies (see the Ethics Statement). We would therefore greatly appreciate it if the reviewer could share the specific concern behind the flag, so that we can address it and further improve the transparency of our work.
W1-(i): Disentangling the contribution of the null-space constraint from the learned source prior
To disentangle the advantage of restricting learning to the null space from that of conditioning on subject-specific cortical geometry in CANDLE, we conducted an additional ablation study with Model (b-iii) (see the table below; SPES: intracranial stimulation localization task; EZ: epileptogenic zone estimation task). Model (b-iii) removes the null-space projection Ln applied to gγ in Equation (2), yielding Y^=L†Xdenoise+gγ(L†Xd). Model (b-iii) shares the same architecture, number of parameters, and training configuration as CANDLE (Model (a)). Consequently, any difference between Models (a) and (b-iii) is attributable solely to whether learning is restricted to the null space.
As shown in the table, Model (b-iii) underperformed Model (a) on all four metrics on real data. The degradation was particularly pronounced for EZ estimation, where HD95 and centroid distance increased by 3.75 mm and 2.86 mm, respectively. Without the null-space projection in Model (b-iii), the output of gγ may leak into the observable range-space component, potentially producing estimates that are inconsistent with the measurements (i.e., LY^=Xdenoise). The null-space constraint prevents this by confining the learned prior to components that are not determined by the observations, which contributes to the improved estimation accuracy. These additional results have been incorporated into Section 3.4 of the revised manuscript.
W1-(ii): Marginal gains from simulator design
As reported in Subsection 3.4 and Figure 6, our simulator ablations show that both (d-i) fixing the head model to fsaverage and (d-ii) randomly selecting ROIs degrade performance relative to the full CANDLE model (a), on four and three of the four empirical metrics, respectively. Although these differences are not statistically significant, they exhibit a consistent trend of degradation across two fundamentally different empirical tasks: intracranial stimulation localization and epileptogenic zone estimation. We therefore suppose that both the diversity of cortical geometries and the realistic ROI definitions in our simulator contribute meaningfully, rather than marginally, to the effective training of CANDLE.
W1-(iii): Configuration of the ConvDip and DeepSIF Baselines
ConvDip [1] and DeepSIF [2] were trained on the same simulated data as CANDLE, using identical preprocessing procedures, training/validation/test splits, and model selection criteria, as detailed in Appendix B.2. Regarding source-space mapping, all learning-based ESI methods predict source activity across 994 cortical regions defined by the Hagmann–Lausanne parcellation [3]. As these regions are defined on each subject's FreeSurfer-reconstructed white-matter surface [4], the predictions are mapped to subject-specific source spaces through atlas label correspondence. However, unlike CANDLE, ConvDip and DeepSIF cannot account for subject-specific cortical geometry, and thus inter-individual variations in regional locations and shapes are not reflected in their estimates. We have clarified these details in L296 and Appendix C.1 of the revised manuscript.