- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper is motivated by the idea that source-label association can be a learning shortcut in EEG adaptation, especially when the association changes. They conjecture that removing this association entirely will also remove relevant biological features useful for prediction. Hence, they propose limited artifact (device, setup, reference) removal to preserve device-population factors, which should be meaningful predictive features. They provide limited evaluation to simulate device changes, showing that MGPA detaches irrelevant device-label information and makes the classifier more robust to changes in device-label association without degrading performance.
Critical strengths
-
Interesting idea of separating setup-relevant factors and biological factors from source-label association.
-
Well-motivated approach to create an editable space to update representation without affecting fixed representation component .
-
The theoretical analysis part (Sec.5) to explain anchoring source-label association to the conditional mean seems rigorous, although I mark that I cannot verify this analysis as it is beyond my scope.
Critical weaknesses
-
Concerns about the measurement gate: MGPA rests on the assumption that calibration contrasts identify directions for editing acquisition effects. However, I do not see clear evidence that content contribution is additive, so we can separate the preserved component from the editable component by current contrast calibration. The authors should provide further evidence for this, especially for complex, unseen measurement shifts.
-
Limited external validity: MGPA addresses a real problem of source-label association; however, the current experiments remain unconvincing. Cross-task reuse (Sec. 6.4) is implemented on only same device pair (Neuroscan-Flex), same setups. This does not truly reflect adaptation across diverse source-label associations, as the paper states. The authors should evaluate the method on the same downstream task under various unseen acquisition conditions, as this is the main claim.
-
The paper suffers from poor writing and a lack of clarity in its presentation. The paper introduces several key concepts and notations before defining them, making the arguments hard to follow (e.g., is introduced in line 151 and explained in line 165, making Sec. 3 hard to follow). Even the abstract and contribution sections are confusing and require effort to understand. The authors should improve organization and ensure that all definitions and notations are clearly introduced, and that all terms and jargon are well explained before use.
Minor concern: MGPA is proposed as a general framework for correcting frozen EEG representations, but its experiments rely solely on EEGPT (using a summary token). Extra evaluation with other architectures using full-token representation (such as CBraMod[1] or CSBrain[2]) would be necessary and useful.
[1] Jiquan Wang, Sha Zhao, Zhiling Luo, Yangxuan Zhou, Haiteng Jiang, Shijian Li, Tao Li, and Gang Pan. Cbramod: A criss-cross brain foundation model for EEG decoding. In International conference on learning representations, volume 2025, pp. 75310–75346, 2025.
[2] Juchen Zhou, Jiamin Wu, Zichen Ren, Zhouheng Yao, Weiheng Lu, Kunyu Peng, Qihao Zheng, Chunfeng Song, Wanli Ouyang, and Chao Gou. Csbrain: A cross-scale spatiotemporal brain foundation model for EEG decoding. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 38:87150–87195, 2026.
Questions for authors
Weaknesses above.
-
In which scenario does the additive context assumption hold?
-
What does in Fig.1 mean, does it differ from in line 151?
-
Editable rank seems sensitive across tasks and setups: 328 for recorded SSVEP, 8 for P300/N170/MMN reuse. Could the authors explain this choice in more detail? Is this based on a mechanism, or is it treated as a hyperparameter? If so, does it affect the robustness of reuse?
-
In Eq.2, chain rule mutual information is proposed, and second-term measure source information beyond Q that remains in the refined representation. This term seems to be minimized to exclude irrelevant device-related information. However, MGPA does not directly minimize it; instead, it updates the representation using the conditional mean. This lacks a clear link; more explanation would be useful