- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CGM features are often varies across different cohorts, devices or sampling rate. When measurements changes dues to different conditions, such invariance will move with the model. Unlike previous method may neglect learning of useful signals, this paper aims to predefine the protocol to add on the existing glucose foundation model to solve the cross-domain generalization problem. Then the paper evaluated this mechanism across serveral cross-dataset transfer settings and demonstrate the performance of propose GlucoPRISM.
Critical strengths
The control experiments and evaluations across datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed mechanism and other experiments of reporting within-cohort the negative results also provide useful insights for the community.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation and research gap is not clearly defined and supported. In line 43-44, although the paper propose these glucose measurement varies, but how exactly such 'moves with the mode' corresponds to specific learning problem or lead to any problems such as final prediction performance degradation or problem or learnt representation?
- The three bands, trait, state and sensor, are they well-defined or established protocols in the field? and does these selection of protocols mainly based on authors observation or chosen by authors themselves, the intuition of using these as supervision is also lack of support and validation.
- The protocol reads like a add-up supervision component for all glucoseFM, but the paper only choose one backbone and does not show the generalization of the protocol supervision.
- The training framework and process can be framed better, for example, clearly state the backbone and added components are trained jointly during pertaining.
Questions for authors
My questions are listed above.
5 comments
Dear Reviewer 3vDQ,
Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback, particularly your concerns regarding the motivation, the definition of the bands and the training procedure. As the discussion period draws to a close, we would greatly appreciate it if you could revisit our responses and let us know whether any concerns remain unresolved.
In our responses, we have linked sensor-related features directly to prediction degradation in cross-cohort transfer, positioned our fixed filter against fitted erasure and domain-adversarial training, and explained how the Trait, State and Sensor bands are defined, motivated and validated. We also report new matched controls that isolate the contribution of the protocol supervision on the GlucoFM , and we clarified that the backbone and all added components are trained jointly in one pretraining stage. All of these analyses will be included in the revised paper.
We hope our responses and the additional evidence have adequately addressed your concerns. We would be happy to answer any further questions.
Thank you again for your time.
Followup on Rebuttal
Dear Reviewer 3vDQ,
Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback, particularly your concerns regarding the motivation, the definition of the bands and the training procedure. As the discussion period draws to a close, we would greatly appreciate it if you could revisit our responses and let us know whether any concerns remain unresolved.
In our responses, we have linked sensor-related features directly to prediction degradation in cross-cohort transfer, positioned our fixed filter against fitted erasure and domain-adversarial training, and explained how the Trait, State and Sensor bands are defined, motivated and validated. We also report new matched controls that isolate the contribution of the protocol supervision on the GlucoFM , and we clarified that the backbone and all added components are trained jointly in one pretraining stage. All of these analyses will be included in the revised paper.
We hope our responses and the additional evidence have adequately addressed your concerns. We would be happy to answer any further questions.
Thank you again for your time.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the cross-dataset controls and the value of reporting negative results. We will clarify the learning problem, the status of the bands, the scope of generalization, and the joint training procedure.
W1. Motivation and research gap.
The learning problem is that sensor–cohort confounding can encourage source-fitted clinical probes to exploit sensor-related features that fail to transfer. The observation mask alone predicts device identity at 100 AUROC (Appendix T). More directly, with the encoder fixed and each readout probed using the same source data and fitting procedure, removing Sensor increases transfer AUROC from 64.71 to 78.83 into CGMacros and from 68.75 to 73.57 overall; filtering is nearly neutral elsewhere (+0.17; Table 8). This connects the representation problem to prediction degradation.
The gap is how to learn a selectively removable sensor-related component during pretraining, avoiding post-hoc eraser estimation. INLP/LEACE fit device-labeled removal operators; domain adversaries suppress device predictability. In separate same-corpus retrains, our fixed filter reaches 73.14 transfer AUROC versus 69.20 for GlucoFM+LEACE and 67.19 for domain-adversarial GlucoFM (Tables 22–25). Erasure on GlucoPRISM itself gives similar performance; the distinction is that our removal operator is predefined. It requires no target-specific fitting, although the sensor-view generator uses CGMacros paired recordings for calibration; held-out-participant controls retain the filtering gain (Appendix G.1).
W2. Band definitions, motivation and validation.
Trait, State and Sensor are our operationally defined representation bands, with author-chosen widths (64/48/16), rather than established clinical protocols. They are motivated by person-specific glycemic patterns (Hall et al., 2018), within-person variability (Danne et al., 2017; Battelino et al., 2019), and sensor differences (Boscari et al., 2018). “Protocol” denotes acquisition settings—sensor, sampling rate and calibration. Table 1 specifies the intended responses: Trait should remain stable across days and sensors; State may vary across days while remaining sensor-stable; Sensor should respond to sensor changes. Simulated sensor views and repeated-day pairs supply this supervision.
The evidence tests both representation behavior and objective contributions. Across 44 paired HPP visits, median cosine similarity is 0.985/0.923/0.435 for Trait/State/Sensor (Table 39). In Appendix O’s separate 24-cell ablation, removing sensor-view alignment lowers retained transfer by 6.70 points (conditional participant-bootstrap 95% interval [4.14, 9.10]). Separation is incomplete: device identity remains decodable after filtering (Appendix K.2). The two-seed Sensor/State allocation sweep tests widths of 8/16/32 for Sensor with Trait fixed; it does not establish an optimal allocation (Table 26). We will state these assumptions and limits explicitly.
W3. Backbone scope and new controls.
We evaluate a GlucoFM-based foundation model; portability of the objectives to other backbones remains untested. GlucoFM was the strongest window-level baseline in our benchmark (65.9 AUROC versus 58.5–64.7; Table 2). To isolate supervision within this architecture, new controls use three seeds and the main 12-direction transfer protocol; the final row below is the main-model reference. All entries are AUROC (%).
Adding alignment raises full-readout transfer by 5.23 points [0.09, 11.63]. These alignment rows retain variance regularization; a separate control with alignment as the sole added objective still gains 4.65 [1.88, 8.17]. These new intervals resample directions and seeds. The complete objective also improves window AUROC from 66.17 to 68.01. This supports supervision’s contribution within GlucoFM; we will add the controls to Appendix O and explicitly limit backbone-generalization claims.
W4. Joint pretraining and deployment.
The online GlucoFM backbone, pooling, band projections, Sensor Gaussian channel and auxiliary prediction heads are optimized jointly from random initialization in one 300-epoch stage using Eq. 5; the target encoder follows exponential-moving-average updates (Appendices D/F). At inference, auxiliary prediction heads are discarded, while the learned representation projections are retained and Sensor uses its posterior mean. The encoder is frozen, and the fixed projection PTS=[I1120] retains Trait and State before fitting the downstream probe on source data. We will make these stages explicit in Section 3.3 and Figure 2.