- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes ViSTA for Domain-Shifted Generalised Category Discovery (DS-GCD). It’s a two-stage approach. Stage 1 constructs a textual semantic space by searching for unseen textual anchors from a WordNet noun pool, selecting the anchors whose induced target partitions are most compact and separated in the visual feature space. Stage 2 keeps the selected words fixed and adapts CLIP with LoRA to refine the target assignments. The proposed approach is evaluated on four openly available DS-GCD benchmark datasets.
Critical strengths
- The idea is sound: it separates the roles of the two modalities, with visual structure as evidence and text as category coordinates.
- Code is attached for reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
- The evaluation is not convincing enough. Most baselines were published between 2021 and 2023; only CROW (2024) and an adapted SpectralGCD (2026, VisDA only) are more recent. Given the fast-moving research, the authors should include more recent work.
- Very narrow design choice on the validation. All ablations and analyses (Tables 3–6, Figure 3) are on VisDA 6/6, which is too thin to support the claims.
- It’s unclear how much of the gain comes from the proposed search and how much from CLIP’s zero-shot knowledge of the target categories. The WordNet vocabulary contains the target class names.
Questions for authors
- How did the authors obtain the numbers for DANCE, OVANet, UniOT, GLC and CROW? If by re-running, please state and provide details.
- How are the initial anchors in Table 5 constructed? The other three variants improve the H-Score by 27 to 40 points over this V00 baseline.
- Can the authors compare the proposed approach against state-of-the-art approaches published in 2024–26, such as the DS-GCD methods cited in the introduction, for a comprehensive evaluation?