- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies simultaneous inference for proximal causal learning with weak proxies and proposes a procedure for constructing confidence bands in this setting. The authors motivate their approach through three challenges and establish asymptotically valid simultaneous confidence bands for counterfactual distributions and quantile treatment effects. The authors also present numerical experiments assessing their method's performance.
Critical strengths
The paper clearly describes three challenges: quantifying bridge estimation errors under weak proxies, keeping these errors small across treatment arms and outcome thresholds, and constructing reliable confidence bands with estimated bridges. It provides targeted solutions to each challenge and establishes theoretical guarantees through detailed derivations.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient evaluation in Table 1 and sensitivity to proxy strength. Table 1 demonstrates a coverage advantage over the selected baselines. However, the current results demonstrate conservative coverage but do not clearly strike a balance between efficiency and robustness. Furthermore, I would like to see Table 1 extended to show how both coverage and bandwidth change as proxies become progressively weaker.
-
Incomplete specification of the constructed baselines. The construction and parameter settings of the baselines are insufficiently documented. In particular, the Estimated-density delta method requires a more explicit description of its implementation.
-
Insufficient explanation of the theoretical results. The main text presents many equations but provides limited explanation, particularly for the main theorems. Clearer discussion of their meaning and implications would make the theoretical results easier to follow.
Questions for authors
The coverage rates in Table 1 reach 99.8%–100%, substantially exceeding the nominal 95% level. What accounts for this conservatism?
Thanks for the thoughtful response. The authors thoughtfully added substantial supplements and appendices, which effectively address my questions. Furthermore, the authors acknowledged my critique, and I will now carefully review these revisions to reach a final conclusion.
However, I still find the paper and rebuttal somhow AI-slope, which is one of the main concern, so I maintain a negative view, and the noverty is limited.