- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces an anchored diffusion model for point cloud recognition and unlike the previous works that complete missing parts from the point cloud, it uses pretrained generative point cloud backbone. Also, this method did not add any extra parameters. This method has two major modules one for the local geometry reconstructor and another one for the conditional flow denoiser. This work jointly trains two modules to get the classifier. This work mainly uses three datasets including ShapeNet, ModelNet-C and ScanObjectNN-C for the classification task. And this paper uses the mean corruption error to validate the corruption robustness.
Critical strengths
- I like how RAD only add a small thing. It is a clean method without adding more parameters.
- The gains are good and even compared to other baselines. (But see the below…)
Critical weaknesses
- Point-MaDi, which is the closest method, this work is cited but not benchmarked. Please specify the reason why this is discarded.
- Table 3, using only LGR already matches the performance in Scan-C with Diffusion+LGR. This weakens the contribution of the paper of “Diffusion + Reconstruction”. And it makes me think this method is very similar to Point-MaDi, which is cited and not benchmarked.
- I am not convinced about the “effective”. I wonder this method is better in pretraining wall-clock or FLOPs compared to PointDif.
- Figure 3, the error difference between PointDif and Rad is very small.
- The contribution of this paper is not backed up by the results. Per the paper’s contribution, the Drop-Local should be the largest gain in the table, but it is not the largest gain. For example, this is only a partial gain compared to the Jitter gain.
Questions for authors
I would like to see the response for #1 Weakness, missing related work and the baseline, and the #5 Weakness about the Drop-Local v.s. others.