- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how to calibrate soft tactile sensors when their electrical response depends on how they have been loaded. The authors learn four shared models covering static behavior, path dependence, temporal relaxation, and hysteresis; these models can then be reused at a new sensing location by fitting only their output weights and an offset from a few selected force references. Once calibrated, the system estimates force from incoming electrical readings, while its memory states continue to evolve. The evaluation covers fourteen sensing locations on three arrays excluded from training.
Critical strengths
-
Only five parameters are fitted at each sensing location, alongside 1,270 shared parameters, and I see practical value in keeping this local fitting step small. The experts cover both static behavior and effects of loading history, so the compact model still accounts for several aspects of the sensor response.
-
Testing on fourteen locations across three arrays excluded from training shows that the shared models can be reused on new arrays. The method achieves lower force errors using the same calibration references as the other methods that require force labels, with RMSE of 0.375 N compared with 0.652 N for CAVIA under the full window. The advantage over the comparison methods also holds with the shorter calibration window.
-
The regularized calibration gives a unique solution even with only three force references for five fitted parameters. This provides a sound basis for the local adaptation step, where the limited measurements alone would leave the expert weights and offset underdetermined.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method uses only three force values for fitting, but these are selected from a continuous force recording. Even when the reference times are fixed in advance, the experiment still uses that recording to synchronize and interpolate the measurements, so I’m not sure how much force data would need to be collected in practice, or how much calibration effort the method would save.
-
I’m not sure when fitting separate expert weights offers a practical advantage over the simpler alternatives. Under the full calibration window, equal weights with a fitted gain and offset already achieve 0.383 N RMSE, close to the 0.375 N obtained with local weight fitting, while proportions learned on the source data do slightly better.
-
Since the evaluation uses signals sampled at 5 Hz and defines the Rapid subset through force changes over one second, it is difficult to judge how well the method handles faster changes in loading. More context on the force ranges and loading speeds would help clarify what conditions the experiments cover and how large the reported errors are relative to the forces being measured.
Questions for authors
-
What would calibration require at a new location in practice? Could it work with only three acquired force measurements, or is a continuous reference trace still needed for synchronization or preprocessing?
-
Equal weights are already close to the fitted mixture (see Weakness 2). Are the small gains from fitting separate weights consistent across sensing locations, and are there particular loading conditions where this helps most?
-
What are the typical force ranges and loading speeds in the recordings? How large is the 0.375 N error relative to those forces, and what dynamic behavior is covered by the 5 Hz evaluation?
3 comments
Post Rebuttal Comment
Thanks for the clarifications and additional analysis. The explanation of the three-reference calibration and the timing tests help address my main concern. Please make sure the practical calibration requirments and the tested loading conditions are clear in the final version, including the limits of the 5 Hz evaluation. My overall assessment of the work and my score remains unchanged.
Thank you, glad it helped.
All three pts are in the revised paper.
- What calibration needs is in the experimental setup and Appendix D.3.
- The force ranges and loading speeds are in Appendix D.2 and Figure 6.
- What the 5 Hz evaluation covers is in Appendix D.2.
We have also made them easier to find from the main text, and this will be in the final version.
Thanks again for practical questions during the disscussion process.
Response to Reviewer dtin
Thank you for the review. Your question on what calibration requires in practice was especially useful. Answering it led us to test how accurate the three references need to be, and they do not need to be very accurate. We answer your three questions below, and the corresponding changes are in the revised paper.
Q1 (W1). What would calibration require at a new location in practice?
The short answer is that calibration needs three force readings, each with a time stamp accurate to about a second. A continuous force recording is not needed.
In our experiments we did record force continuously, and this may have caused the confusion. The recording was used for two other things. It is the ground truth against which we measure the error, and with force-based selection it is also used to detect contact and to choose the three references. Two results show that the calibration itself does not need it.
Result 1. This result is already in Table 1 in the paper, under time-based selection. We took the three references at fixed times, without looking at the force at all. Our method still works. Its RMSE is 0.415 N, compared with 0.597 N for CAVIA, the best baseline, with the same references. So a dense force recording is not needed to choose the references.
Result 2. In a new test, we deliberately made the three references inaccurate. A timing error of ±2 s increases the RMSE by at most 0.016 N, and force noise of 0.2 N by at most 0.007 N.
In practice, a hand-held force gauge read at three moments is enough. This saves a great deal of effort. A full force sweep takes about 14 minutes per taxel, which is about 11 hours per array. Three references take 30 s to 2 min per taxel, which is 24 minutes to 1.6 hours per array. This could be shortened further by pressing faster. The details are in Point 3 of the general response and in the new Appendix D.3.
Q2 (W2). Are the gains from fitting separate weights consistent, and where do they help most?
Yes, the gains are small but consistent. Fitted weights are better than equal weights at 11 of 14 locations under both windows. The gain in RMSE is 0.007 N with the full window and 0.004 N with the short window, and both confidence intervals exclude zero.
You also asked where fitted weights help most. With the full window they help most during unloading (0.012 N, at 11 of 14 locations) and less during loading (0.006 N, at 9 of 14 locations). With the short window they help most while the load is held (0.008 N, at 10 of 14 locations). On the final irregular segment with the full window, equal weights are slightly better, by 0.005 N.
You are right that equal weights are a reasonable simpler choice, and we looked into why they come so close. The four experts are mixed in almost the same proportions at every location, while the overall gain ranges from 1.3 to 3.5. In other words, locations differ mainly in how sensitive they are, and this sensitivity is exactly what calibration is meant to measure at each sensing location. The revised paper now explains this in Section 5.5. We keep the fitted weights because they cost nothing extra and give a small but real gain. Among the three options (fitted weights, equal weights, and weights learned on the source arrays), fitted weights are the only one that is never the worst under either window.
Q3 (W3). Force ranges, loading speeds, and what 5 Hz covers.
The new Appendix D.2 and the new Figure 6 in the revised paper describe the recordings. We summarize the main numbers here.