- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
LifelongTouch addresses generalization of vision-based tactile representations across sensor identities and changing sensor conditions, using a fixed model and a current no-contact reference. The authors also introduce a lifecycle simulation engine producing 870,400 observations across 100 virtual sensors. The experiment uses frozen representations for object classification, relative contact-position estimation, and dense force estimation, alongside qualitative surface reconstruction, demonstrating improved illumination robustness, strong cross-sensor pose performance under common linear probes, and promising force transfer.
Critical strengths
1.The main method innovation of this article lies in explicitly incorporating the sensor lifecycle state into the generalization problem, using the current reference graph for learning style feature modulation and interaction, and training a more robust representation of state changes through lifecycle simulation and local feature alignment. 2.The experimental results indicates that geometric information is transferable. The component ablation also supports the usefulness of reference adjustment. These results confirm that the proposed design goes beyond the scope of qualitative examples.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
None
Appreciation for Your Recognition
We sincerely thank you for your high regard for our work and your positive assessment of its motivation, methodological contributions, and experimental results.
We particularly appreciate your understanding of the challenges associated with real-world evaluation in vision-based tactile sensing. Unlike conventional visual tasks, ground-truth contact geometry, surface deformation, and force distributions are often difficult to measure directly with reliable pixel-level annotations. This challenge becomes even more pronounced as sensors undergo prolonged use, wear, and aging, making it difficult to continuously obtain accurate geometric and physical ground truth under real interaction conditions. Addressing these challenges is essential for establishing reliable tactile benchmarks.
These practical difficulties also motivate our approach of combining simulation-based training with real-world evaluation. Specifically, physical simulation provides controllable and diverse training data with accurate ground truth, while real tactile datasets allow us to validate generalization across different sensors and lifecycle states.
We are also grateful for your recognition of our core methodological contributions, particularly the explicit incorporation of sensor lifecycle states into the generalization problem, dynamic-reference-based feature modulation, and the combination of geometric supervision and local feature alignment for learning robust representations. Your recognition of the transferability of tactile geometric information and the effectiveness of reference adjustment is especially encouraging to us.
Once again, we sincerely appreciate your positive assessment and expert perspective. Your recognition not only affirms the methodological design and experimental efforts behind LifelongTouch but also further motivates our continued efforts toward developing reliable tactile perception systems with long-term adaptability and generalization.