- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes N-ring, a lightweight and shallow model for multivariate time-series forecasting. Instead of using deep monolithic architectures or temporal downsampling, it decomposes the time series into reusable, directed, and monotonic "rings" at the native resolution. The model routes these structured local components (which explicitly model length, direction, phase, and amplitude) to shared local shape experts, and it incorporates a periodic and short-window state auxiliary path for contextual calibration. With an extremely small footprint of only 3,249 to 7,244 parameters, N-ring demonstrates highly competitive MAE performance against state-of-the-art models across 8 datasets, though its MSE performance is less dominant due to its limited capacity for handling extreme outliers.
Critical strengths
-
The directed-ring decomposition is an innovative way to conceptualize time-series dynamics, preserving native resolution while effectively extracting local structured components like length, direction, and phase.
-
The model achieves highly competitive results with a remarkably small parameter footprint, significantly lowering deployment, inference, and storage costs for edge devices.
-
Extensive experiments across 32 configurations show that N-ring achieves Rank-1 in 20/32 and Rank-2 in 5/32 MAE comparisons, proving its high robustness and accuracy in absolute error terms.
-
The paper provides detailed ablations of the periodic, state, amplitude, and routing components. Furthermore, the authors transparently diagnose and explain the model's extremum error limitations regarding MSE, making the empirical claims highly credible.
Critical weaknesses
-
As acknowledged by the authors, the model struggles with MSE compared to deeper models (e.g., iTransformer, PatchTST) because it lacks dedicated mechanisms or deep residual corrections for high-amplitude, rare extremum events.
-
The hard-coded threshold for ring length () and the overlapping block subdivision for appear somewhat arbitrary. For datasets with long monotonic trends (e.g., Exchange), this clipped expert categorization becomes an approximation and may bottleneck the model's extrapolation capability.
-
The core ring-routing mechanism heavily relies on a separate periodic calibration and state auxiliary branch to provide global context. Removing these leads to performance degradation on periodic datasets, which makes the overall architecture feel slightly fragmented rather than unified.
-
While inference is fast, the two-stage training process (backbone then calibration) takes around 618.2 seconds on Electricity, which is comparable to or slower than some deep baselines (e.g., PatchTST takes 656.1s, iTransformer takes 175.8s). The computational advantage is mainly in inference/storage rather than training speed.
Questions for authors
-
Provide more justification for why was chosen as the cutoff. Is this primarily a computational constraint to keep the expert bank small, or does the empirical representation power naturally degrade beyond this length?
-
Could a lightweight robust loss function (e.g., Huber loss, or an asymmetric loss) or a very simple auxiliary extremum head help bridge the MSE gap without destroying the parameter efficiency?
-
Clarify the training process overhead. Since training takes comparable time to deeper models, can the two-stage training (backbone + calibration) be unified into a single end-to-end optimization step in future iterations to reduce training time?
-
Please elaborate on the detector smoothing process. How sensitive is the model's performance to the smoothing hyperparameter, and how exactly does high-frequency noise affect the ring decomposition step?
2 comments
Sorry for overlooking the response to the weakness in the review comments earlier. We have expanded the squared-error diagnostics, clarified the treatment of ring lengths, quantified the calibration components’ contributions, and reported training costs separately for both stages. The corresponding changes are detailed below.
RW1: Original Section 4 and Appendix A.7 discussed extremum and boundary errors using an Electricity diagnostic. Revised Section 4 and Appendix A.6, Table A3, extend this analysis to eight datasets: high-amplitude regions account for 21.92%–71.37% of squared error. Revised Section 2.2 specifies horizon-dependent routing and amplitude-aware periodic correction, while Section 3.4 and Table 4 quantify their combined contribution relative to the same backbone. Average relative MSE reductions across the four short-window configurations are 13.79% on Electricity, 12.67% on Traffic, and 8.18% on Weather; the remaining dataset-dependent behavior is discussed in Section 4.
RW2: Original Section 2.1 and Appendix A.4 described overlapping subdivision for long rings, while Section 4 acknowledged approximation from clipped expert categories. Revised Section 2.1 clarifies that the complete model retains natural observed-run lengths and separately uses forecasting strides from 2 to 18; Appendix A.4 specifies the subdivision rule used in the encoding-cap controls. Section 3.4 and Appendix B.3, Tables A6–A7, report three-seed controls on ETTh1 and Exchange. Within the feature-only control configuration, reducing the encoding cap from 18 to 8 changes mean relative MAE/MSE by −0.93%/−0.23%, with the allocated parameter count unchanged at 3,558. These results quantify sensitivity within the tested configuration.
RW3: Original Section 2.2 assigned repeated-pattern context to periodic calibration and short-history context to the state auxiliary branch, but their relationship to prediction could be explained more directly. Revised Section 2.2 presents horizon-dependent expert weighting, periodic references, and amplitude correction within the combined horizon_calib module; Appendix B.1 specifies its complete computation. Section 3.4 and Appendix B.4 quantify the components’ contributions: disabling periodic correction or future routing increases relative MSE by averages of 9.68% and 4.64%, respectively, across the two tested settings. These results support their complementary roles in the fitted forecasting pipeline.
RW4: Original Table 5 already reported the complete two-stage training time, including 618.2 seconds for Electricity, but the discussion needed a clearer separation of model size and training cost. Revised Section 2.4 specifies the backbone and frozen-backbone calibration stages, and Section 3.5 with Table 5 reports their measured times separately. For Electricity 96-to-96, the revised results average 302.3 seconds for backbone training and 331.9 seconds for calibration across three runs. Section 3.5 also reports calibration’s share of training-loop time, while Section 4 identifies matched-total-compute evaluation as further work.
Thank you for your valuable feedback In the past two months, we have been committed to improving the MSE performance of the model, and ultimately we have implemented a new calibration method, horizon_calib, To improve the MAE and MSE performance of the model. In the latest results, the model calibrated with horizon_calib has achieved the lowest average MAE and MSE rankings among multiple baselines. Although the MAE performance of the model is still better than MSE, the model has also gained considerable competitiveness in terms of MSE indicators. We have made four major changes based on the feedback from all experts. Firstly, in order to reduce MSE, we proposed horizon_calib to modify the Nring backbone, which slightly increases model parameters and computation time. Across the 32 configurations, 29 showed lower MAE and 24 showed lower MSE. Improvements in multivariate datasets such as electricity and transportation are substantial. Secondly, we added an appendix-only accuracy comparison with the official WPMixer implementation on eight 96-to-96 tasks using three seeds. N-ring achieves lower mean MAE on six datasets and lower mean MSE on four. We could not verify an official implementation of WaveletMixer and therefore do not report results for it. Thirdly, we reported the use of MASE, sMAPE, ND, and NRMSE as metric extensions in GIFT Eval. Fourthly, we added 72 complete test set evaluations and checkpoint level component interventions under clean and damaged inputs for Electricity 192 to 192 and Weather 192 to 96. New evidence suggests that the model is sensitive to recent continuous interruptions. We also clarified statistical uncertainty, sensitivity control, implementation details, and conclusion scope.The following are responses to specific questions:
RQ1: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. The maximum forecasting stride of 18 controls bank capacity, while the encoder retains natural observed-run lengths. We tested 34, 32, 24, and 16 experts with three seeds. Reducing 34 to 16 lowers parameters from 3,558 to 1,980 (44.35%); MAE changes range from a 3.95% improvement to a 2.28% degradation, and MSE from a 9.22% improvement to a 4.09% degradation. These results show a dataset-dependent capacity trade-off. Figure 2 now uses the actual unsmoothed detector, excluding constant runs and runs containing long flat intervals.
RQ2: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We specify the pointwise MAE, temporal SmoothL1, and first-stage length/direction objectives. Calibration reduces MSE in 24/32 settings, by 4.95% on average, while high-amplitude regions account for 21.92%–71.37% of squared error. The Discussion proposes controlled tests of amplitude-sensitive objectives and a compact extremum head under matched training conditions.
RQ3: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We report both training stages on eight 96-to-96 tasks. Calibration accounts for 18.69%–52.33% of total training-loop time, averaging 33.02% across datasets. Freezing the same backbone allows separate comparison of refinement methods. Joint end-to-end optimization can be evaluated for cost and convergence under matched conditions in future work.
RQ4: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. Input segmentation uses unsmoothed observations, and first-stage routing labels use fixed width-three smoothing. At 10% input noise, 28.25%–55.22% of interior boundary indicators change, while MSE increases by 1.88%–6.20%. The experiment measures broadband input-noise effects. Smoothing-width and isolated-frequency perturbations are further experiments.
Thank you again for your valuable suggestion. We are always committed to improving model performance from a structural perspective rather than parameter optimization. If you have any new ideas or suggestions for our model, you can also provide them, which may become our future research direction.