- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes StateComp, a compact long-term time-series forecasting framework that separates input-derived temporal state representation from the learned temporal transfer. The model constructs multi-width seasonal states and longer-cycle contrasts directly from each input window, transfers these states using coefficients shared across phases and variables, and adds a low-rank temporal correction to account for residual historical dependence. The central hypothesis is that temporal shapes can be highly detailed while their evolution can be governed by a small number of shared coefficients.
Critical strengths
s1: The experimental evaluation is comprehensive. The authors attempt to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model from multiple perspectives.
s2: StateComp achieves competitive performance with an extremely small number of learnable parameters, which is an impressive aspect of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
w1: The abstract states that “time-series shapes can be highly complex, while the dynamics governing their evolution may be relatively simple and consistent.” However, the paper does not provide sufficient justification for this assumption. In real-world time series, temporal patterns can be highly complex and dynamic, and they may be influenced by a variety of factors. Therefore, it is not necessarily true that the underlying evolution dynamics are simple or consistent. The authors should provide stronger theoretical or empirical evidence to support this assumption and clarify under what conditions it is expected to hold.
w2: From my understanding, StateComp appears to largely recombine and structurally redesign ideas that have already been explored in existing methods, particularly CycleNet. Therefore, the novelty of the proposed method is not sufficiently clear. The authors should explicitly clarify what the key innovations of StateComp are and how it fundamentally differs from CycleNet and other existing compact time-series forecasting methods. In particular, the paper should clearly identify which components or modeling principles are genuinely novel.
w3: The Related Work section does not sufficiently discuss several representative lightweight/simple time-series forecasting methods, such as SparseTSF, CycleNet, TimeBase, and MixLinear. Since the main motivation of StateComp is to achieve competitive forecasting performance with an extremely small number of learnable parameters, these methods are highly relevant to the positioning and novelty of the proposed approach. The authors should provide a more comprehensive discussion and comparison with these works.
w4: The experimental evaluation is mainly conducted on relatively small benchmark datasets. To better demonstrate the scalability and practical effectiveness of StateComp, I recommend evaluating the proposed method on larger-scale time-series datasets. Experiments on datasets with substantially more variables and/or longer time series would provide stronger evidence that the proposed extremely low-parameter design remains effective beyond the current benchmark settings.
Questions for authors
See the Weaknesses.