- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the problem of time-series forecasting trained on a source domain without requiring target-domain data and proposes the DynaFK model. A key contribution of the study is the revelation that, for a fixed forecasting horizon, DynaFK degenerates into a linear mapping with a specific phase; however, I do not understand why this is claimed as a contribution of the paper.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
I believe the paper's scientific contribution is insufficient. Its core theoretical result is quite intuitive: once the forecast horizon and model parameters are fixed, the encoder, linear recurrent module, and decoder can be collapsed into a single linear mapping. Although the derivation is correct, it essentially amounts to nothing more than substituting and rearranging finite summations. More concerningly, many of the subsequent experimental results undermine the rationale behind the proposed "spectral mechanism" itself. Sinkhorn alignment and L2 smoothing yielded no substantial improvements; the "global-spectrum" and "phase-linear" variants performed on par with DynaFK; and for longer forecast horizons, DynaFK significantly underperformed compared to the Linear or Koopa models. Consequently, beyond the realization that "a simpler linear model can explain most of DynaFK's performance over short horizons," it remains unclear to me what the paper's core scientific contribution actually is.
-
The paper fails to convincingly demonstrate the value of DynaFK as a novel method. DynaFK integrates a host of reasonable technical components—including seasonal naive forecasting, instance normalization, phase rearrangement, complex-valued encoders/decoders, diagonal spectral dynamics, smoothing, cross-sampling-rate interpolation, and history resampling—yet the paper does not clearly articulate why this specific combination is necessary. In fact, the authors' own experimental results show that a simple "phase-linear model" with only 397 parameters performs essentially on par with DynaFK, while standard baselines such as Linear and FITS often achieve higher forecasting accuracy. For instance, on the ETTh2 dataset, DynaFK achieves an MSE of 0.3124, whereas Linear/FITS achieves 0.2947; on the ECL dataset, DynaFK yields 0.2426, compared to 0.2260 for Linear. The model's sole advantage lies in the fact that its parameter count is independent of the prediction horizon length; however, even this aspect was not validated by using a single "frozen checkpoint" across different horizons. Figure 3(c) presents results from models trained separately for each horizon, and the paper itself characterizes this merely as "parameter-shape evidence." Consequently, it is difficult to understand why DynaFK—rather than the simpler baseline models—should be regarded as the paper's primary contribution.
Questions for authors
What novel method contributing scientifically to the field of time-series forecasting does the paper propose? Are the experimental datasets and baseline comparisons adequate? Do not submit AI-generated coursework as an academic paper to ICLR or any other publication platform; doing so wastes the reviewers' time and effort.