- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PRISM, a lightweight method for long-term time series forecasting. PRISM reshapes a one-dimensional time series into a two-dimensional, period-aligned representation based on a predefined period length. It separately models cross-period patterns and intra-period temporal dynamics using lightweight convolutional modules and a shared forecasting head.
Critical strengths
s1: Balancing forecasting accuracy and computational efficiency is an important objective for long-term time series forecasting.
s2: The period-aligned representation provides an intuitive way to separate cross-period dependencies from intra-period dynamics.
Critical weaknesses
w1: The central idea of PRISM is to reorganize a one-dimensional time series into a period-aligned representation and use lightweight convolutional modules to model patterns along the two dimensions. While intuitive, this design appears to be closer to a combination or structural adaptation of existing ideas in periodic modeling, temporal decomposition, and lightweight forecasting than a clearly differentiated methodological contribution. The paper does not sufficiently establish what fundamentally new modeling capability PRISM introduces.
w2: The paper evaluates PRISM on seven benchmark datasets and compares it with several baselines. However, the authors should provide a more detailed analysis across forecasting horizons, datasets, and different temporal characteristics, and explain the underlying reasons for performance variations.
w3: The period length and cross-period compression mechanism may jointly determine which temporal information is retained. Without sufficiently targeted ablations and analyses, it is difficult to determine whether the reported performance gains arise primarily from period alignment, the convolutional architecture, or other implementation choices.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses.
2 comments
Thank you for your detailed response and clarifications. While I appreciate the more explicit positioning of PRISM as a lightweight computational design, my main concern regarding its methodological novelty remains unresolved. Furthermore, the additional analyses do not sufficiently explain the performance variations across datasets or disentangle the contributions of period alignment, convolution, and compression, as the authors also acknowledge. Therefore, I will maintain my original rating.
Author Response to Reviewer
Thank you for the constructive review. We appreciate your recognition of the importance of accuracy--efficiency trade-offs and the intuitive separation of temporal structures. We revised the manuscript to clarify the methodological contribution, provide a more detailed interpretation of forecasting results, and explicitly discuss the limitations of our ablation analyses.
W1. Methodological novelty and distinction from prior work. We agree that period-aligned representations, convolution, and temporal compression are established techniques. PRISM's methodological contribution lies in the specific structured mapping that combines sparse, weight-shared cross-period compression with dimension-preserving intra-period mixing. This design explicitly reduces the forecasting-head dimension while preserving the intra-period axis, rather than introducing an entirely new primitive operation.
PRISM applies a shared dilated convolution to compress the cross-period dimension from N to N′ before forecasting, while a shared circular convolution mixes intra-period positions without reducing their dimension. This constrains the forecasting head to operate on a compact representation with N′M parameters. Unlike SparseTSF's shared cross-period forecasting, TimeBase's learned temporal bases, and MixLinear's time/frequency pathways, PRISM combines structured cross-period compression with dimension-preserving intra-period mixing.
We revised Sections 1 and 2.2 to distinguish PRISM from these approaches and additional period-aware methods, including TimesNet, PDF, and PhaseFormer. Sections 3.4--3.5 further characterize PRISM as a structured linear predictor with sparse, weight-shared cross-period mapping and circulant intra-period mixing. We therefore position the contribution as a lightweight computational design rather than claiming novelty for period alignment or its individual operations.
W2. Performance variations across datasets and forecasting horizons. We expanded the performance analysis in Section 4.2 using Table 1. PRISM achieves the lowest MSE across all four forecasting horizons on ETTh1 and lower MSE than MixLinear in 22 of 28 dataset--horizon settings. However, TimeBase and FITS consistently outperform PRISM on Weather, while PatchTST performs better on Traffic. PRISM's MSE also increases with the forecasting horizon across all seven datasets.
Section 4.4 provides additional evidence of dataset-dependent behavior. At H=720, removing period reorganization increases ETTh1 MSE from 0.417 to 0.514, whereas the reported MSE remains unchanged on Electricity and Traffic. This suggests that the predictive benefit of period-aligned modeling varies across datasets.
One possible explanation is that the effectiveness of PRISM's structured compression and linear mapping depends on dataset-specific temporal characteristics. Longer forecasting horizons also require predicting more distant observations from the same historical window. However, the current experiments do not isolate the underlying causes of these performance variations, and these interpretations remain hypotheses.
W3. Interaction between period alignment and cross-period compression. We agree that period length, compression strength, and architectural choices jointly influence the information retained for forecasting. We therefore expanded the sensitivity analysis in Appendix D.3 and added Table 8 to report the representation dimensions and parameter counts for each evaluated period length.
For Electricity and Traffic, changing P from 24 to 30 reduces the retained cross-period dimension N′ from 9 to 3 and the parameter count from 279 to 81. Consequently, the performance degradation at P=30 cannot be attributed to period misalignment alone.
Appendix D.1 further examines the accuracy--efficiency trade-off through dilation. On Electricity, increasing dilation from d=1 to d=7 reduces N′ from 27 to 9 and MACs from 8.11M to 2.70M while maintaining relatively stable MSE. More aggressive compression at d=9 increases forecasting error. Table 3 also shows that removing sequence summarization on Traffic increases MACs from 7.26M to 21.72M while slightly reducing MSE from 0.451 to 0.447.
These results clarify the trade-off between retained information and computational efficiency. However, changing P or dilation also changes representation dimensions or receptive fields, and component removal changes model complexity. We explicitly acknowledge in Sections 4.4--4.5 and Appendix D that these analyses do not independently isolate the causal contributions of period alignment, convolution, and compression.
We hope these clarifications address the main concerns while making the scope and limitations of our contribution more explicit.