- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
SSVT runs a Mamba block over each variable and feeds the last hidden states, one token per variable, to an iTransformer-style encoder. Optional physics penalties are added to the loss, with weights proposed by an LLM. On five public benchmarks and one boiler dataset, the paper claims the best results at H = 720 and an advantage that grows with the horizon.
Critical strengths
- The model is small (about parameters) and fast.
Critical weaknesses
-
Little is new, and the advertised extras are not in the main results. SSVT is a standard Mamba encoder per variable (Sec. 3.2 says the SSM is not redesigned) followed by an iTransformer encoder, and no Mamba-based forecaster is compared. The boiler results in Table 1 (0.102 at H = 96, 0.648 at H = 720) equal the unconstrained results in Sec. 4.4, so the physics penalties and the LLM search play no role. Where they are used, they raise the smoothness violation at H = 720 (0.0715 to 0.0945), and the unnamed LLM is worse than manual tuning (0.1001 vs 0.0984).
-
The setup cannot test the stated problem. The paper is about slow drift from equipment aging, but the input window is 96 steps (App. A.2): 8 minutes of history on the boiler data, which itself covers only five days (App. A.1). No experiment isolates drift.
-
The results contradict the claims and are not controlled. The advantage shrinks with the horizon: on ETTh1 the margin is 16% at H = 96 (0.306 vs 0.366) but 0.4% at H = 720 (0.457 vs 0.459). The H = 720 "wins on all six datasets" are 0.001 to 0.008 MSE from a single seed, and Table 1 mixes re-run and copied baseline numbers without marking them (App. B.3). In Table 2, three different variants give the same boiler error (0.780, 0.779, 0.779).
-
The code link breaks anonymity. The abstract links to a public GitHub repository under a named account. Even if it is currently an empty placeholder with no identifying information, such a link can reveal the authors at any time and should not appear in a double-blind submission. Anonymized links exist for this purpose.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.