- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This study is for the light field salient object detection. In particular, it takes pairwise slices and all-focus representation into consideration and proposes two main models, CFSA and RCSF. CFSA combines single-slice and pairwise again estimation to identify complementary focal evidence for focal selection and aggregation while RCSF takes cross-modal reations to determine the observation mappings and weights for joint state correction. Combinging CFSA and RCSF progressively fulfills saliency prediction.
Critical strengths
The strength of this work lies in the two collaborated modules. CFSA aims at selecting proper focus while RCSF aims at mapping and weighting for fusion with the all-focus features. They combined through different layers for final saliency prediction.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed method looks like a 'local+global' idea, with locally CFSA and globally RCSF. What are the key contributions of CFSA and RCSF? For CFSA, it relies on a pre-trained model to do the focus choice. For RCSF, it seems the state space is a copied idea of Longhorn.
- The progressive idea is not new, or even rather old, which makes the contribution weak again.
- The ablation is also rather rough. For example, CFSA takes several components, such as pariwise slices, all-focus features etc while RCSF having a joint target. It's better to have more indepth analyses on them.
- The motiviation shown in Figure 1 is not clear. Why do the top-K idea can better than weighted aggregation? The top-K still needs aggregation!
Questions for authors
The saliency detection is interesting, but the method proposed is not very attractive. The main reason is that the ideas inside are not very creative in my view. Please check the Weakness Section for my questions. In addition, the article is not easy to follow and it's better to polish again.