- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SACFusion is a two-stage framework for RGB–Event object detection. The first stage adapts event features to a pretrained RGB semantic space through temporal–polarity aggregation, local semantic alignment, and cross-path semantic preservation. The second stage uses RGB-guided asymmetric retrieval and a learned event retrieval prior to incorporate complementary event information. Experiments on DSEC-Det and PEOD report consistent improvements over the compared methods, supported by component ablations and feature visualizations.
Critical strengths
- The two-stage design is well motivated. Separating event representation adaptation from cross-modal fusion is a useful approach to modality imbalance. Local alignment accommodates small spatial mismatches, while RGB-guided retrieval provides a clear way to incorporate auxiliary event information without symmetric feature exchange.
- The improvements are substantial across both datasets. SACFusion exceeds the strongest reported baselines by 3.6 mAP points on DSEC-Det and 5.3 points on PEOD Overall, with a 4.0-point gain on PEOD Challenge. Its parameter count is also comparable to SPFD. These results provide good evidence for the effectiveness of the complete method.
Critical weaknesses
- The ablations do not isolate the main contributions. Table 2 evaluates SLSA and CP together and introduces asymmetric retrieval together with the learned prior. The final 0.73 AP gain therefore does not establish the prior’s individual contribution.
- There is also no comparison between one-stage and two-stage training using the same architecture and matched training budgets, despite the additional 30k iterations in Stage I. This leaves the benefit of the proposed training sequence insufficiently established.
- The claim of reducing interference from unreliable events needs more direct evidence. In Eq. (11), assigning the same low prior to all sampled candidates leaves the softmax weights unchanged. The prior therefore provides relative selection rather than directly controlling the amount of event information injected, consistent with its stated role. Figure 6 demonstrates spatial selectivity, but does not establish robustness when event observations are uniformly weak or noisy. Comparisons against RGB-only and prior-free retrieval under such conditions would better support this claim.
Questions for authors
- With the same architecture and a matched total training budget, how does one-stage joint training compare with the proposed two-stage schedule?
- How much does the Event Retrieval Prior contribute when the aligned features and RGB-to-event deformable retrieval are otherwise unchanged?
- When all sampled event candidates are weak or noisy, what limits their contribution? Can results grouped by event density or quality show whether the method avoids degrading the RGB-only baseline?
Response to Reviewer Comments on Training Strategy, Event Retrieval Prior, and Robustness Analysis
We thank the reviewer for the detailed assessment. We have added further experiments and clarified the training strategy and retrieval mechanism. We hope the following responses address your concerns.
Thank you again for your valuable comments and suggestions. If you have any further questions or concerns, please feel free to let us know. We would be happy to provide additional clarification.