- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BASFR-Net, a stagewise residual interaction framework for RGB-infrared oriented object detection in aerial remote sensing. The method consists of three core modules: BAFG for cross-modal response calibration at the backbone stage, SFAB for semantic-detail feature reconstruction at the neck stage, and CRAH for local feature routing at the prediction stage. Each module is designed to address the interaction requirements of a different stage, while residual connections preserve the original feature representations. Experiments on the DroneVehicle and VEDAI datasets demonstrate substantial performance improvements.
Critical strengths
1.Effective module design. The ablation studies show that each module independently improves detection performance, while their combination yields further gains, demonstrating the effectiveness and complementarity of the proposed modules.
2.Clear dataset visualizations. The qualitative results illustrate challenging scenarios involving densely packed vehicles, missed detections, and classification confusion. BASFR-Net reduces missed detections and classification errors, broadly consistent with the improvements observed in the quantitative results.
Critical weaknesses
- The experiments are conducted on only two datasets, making it difficult to establish the generalization capability of the proposed method. Additional evaluation is needed.
- The comparison with existing state-of-the-art methods is insufficient. Results for larger model variants, such as YOLO11s and YOLO11m, are also missing.
- The meanings of the symbols used in the loss functions are not adequately explained.
- The figures and writing have substantial shortcomings. (a) The overall framework diagram is overly simplified, and some symbols and labels are unclear. The core designs, methodological contributions, and residual paths are not clearly presented, reducing readability. (b) The contribution section claims that explicit paths are retained and updated at each stage, but it does not sufficiently explain what is updated or how the stages differ. The contributions are insufficiently connected to the methodological details. (c) The related-work section does not establish sufficiently clear connections between existing fusion and alignment methods and BASFR-Net’s stage-specific residual interactions for backbone response calibration, neck aggregation, and prediction-stage routing.
- The motivation and novelty of the method are unclear. Although the paper discusses multimodal fusion and small-object detection, the method section primarily describes the proposed modules without clearly explaining how they address the identified challenges. The claimed stagewise modeling strategy is mainly manifested as separate module designs for the backbone, neck, and head, without sufficiently demonstrating why different modules are specifically suited to their respective stages.
- For SFAB, the paper should clarify the differences between semantic and detail inputs, how these features are obtained, and the practical motivation for combining them. For CRAH, the five spatial priors require more detailed explanations, as does the allocation of routing weights across different feature scales. The illustration of how modality cues guide local evidence aggregation before oriented prediction is also overly simplistic.
- The ablation studies are insufficient. Some hyperparameter choices lack supporting experiments and quantitative justification.
Questions for authors
- Generalization: Additional datasets and cross-dataset generalization experiments are recommended.
- SOTA comparisons: More comparisons with state-of-the-art methods and additional necessary ablation studies are recommended.
- Methodological novelty: The motivation for stagewise interaction should be clarified, and its necessity should be validated through experiments comparing different module placements and combinations.
- Module mechanisms: The sources and roles of SFAB’s input features should be explained, along with the five spatial priors in CRAH and its multiscale routing mechanism.
- Figures and presentation: The overall architecture and module diagrams should be improved to clarify residual paths and symbol definitions. The explanations of mathematical notation and the paper’s formatting should also be revised.