acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Reconciling Process Supervision with Outcome-Based Credit in Agentic Policy Optimization

Abstract

For language-model agents, outcome-based reinforcement learning provides verified task feedback but assigns the same trajectory-level advantage to every intermediate decision, making it difficult to identify which actions contributed to success or failure. Process supervision can refine this credit, yet treating it as an independent auxiliary objective may encourage or discourage intermediate decisions independently of the trajectory’s outcome advantage. Self-distillation with privileged information provides finer-grained guidance through changes in response likelihood. However, these changes do not directly specify how to allocate outcome credit, and the guidance may depend on conditions absent from the target trajectory. We introduce TASPO, a framework for constrained credit redistribution. Outcome feedback sets the trajectory-level advantage; process supervision redistributes it across decisions while preserving its sign and mean within each trajectory. TASPO aligns guidance from verified successful sibling trajectories with the completed target interaction, measures guidance-induced support over executable actions, and converts these scores into positive, bounded, mean-one weights. The constraints preserve advantage polarity and decision-level mean while limiting local reweighting, without additional environment interaction. Across ALFWorld, Search-QA, and WebShop with three backbone models, TASPO improves over GRPO by 12.4 percentage points on average. Analyses confirm that both alignment and action-level aggregation are essential, while TASPO stabilizes policy-KL optimization dynamics. Codes are available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/TASPO-0DAA/https://anonymous.4open.science/r/TASPO-0DAA/.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
reinforcement learning, large language model agents, credit assignment, on-policy (self)-distillation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_1rnoOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TASPO, a credit assignment framework that reconciles outcome-based rewards with process supervision in agentic policy optimization. The paper is motivated by two key observations:

  1. Limitations of outcome-based reinforcement learning and conflicts with process supervision. Methods such as GRPO rely on final outcomes and assign the same advantage to all tokens within a trajectory, failing to distinguish their individual contributions to the final result. This motivates the introduction of process supervision. However, methods such as OPSD optimize the likelihood between current model's action and the teacher model, which differs from the outcome-based optimization objective of GRPO and may lead to conflicting optimization directions. To reconcile these objectives, TASPO uses process supervision as the weight of credit, while outcome rewards determine the polarity and mean of the advantage.

  2. Context and granularity mismatches in process supervision. Process supervision in OPSD may rely on information that is not applicable to the states encountered in the target trajectory. To address this issue, TASPO introduces trajectory-aligned process supervision to ensure that the guidance is relevant to the target trajectory's actual interaction history. Furthermore, since agents interact with their environments by executing complete actions, token-level supervision may assign different credit to tokens belonging to the same action. TASPO therefore performs credit assignment at the action level, aligning the granularity of supervision with the executable decisions made by the agent.

Experiments on ALFWorld, Search-QA, and WebShop with three backbone models show an average improvement of 12.4 percentage points over GRPO across nine settings.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies an important challenge in reconciling process supervision with outcome-based reinforcement learning, particularly the potential misalignment between their optimization objectives. TASPO addresses this issue through a simple credit reweighting mechanism that incorporates process guidance while preserving the polarity and mean of outcome-based advantages.

  2. The paper provides extensive experiments across multiple agent benchmarks and backbone models, demonstrating consistent improvements over GRPO. The ablation studies further examine key design choices and provide empirical support for the effectiveness of the proposed method.

Critical weaknesses

A critical motivation of this paper is that directly combining process supervision, such as OPSD, with outcome-based RL, such as GRPO, introduces conflicting optimization objectives. While this argument is plausible, the empirical evidence supporting the proposed mechanism is limited.

It seems that there isn't any direct evidence can directly characterize the alleged gradient conflict between GRPO and OPSD. The reported performance improvements do not establish that mitigating such conflicts is the primary reason for TASPO's advantage.

Figure 3(b) appears to be a conceptual illustration rather than a quantitative measurement of actual training gradients.

Given the central role of this argument in the paper's motivation, I believe more direct evidence of the claimed optimization objectives' conflict would substantially strengthen the contribution.

Questions for authors
  1. What does "TASPO" mean? I cannot find an explicit explanation of the method's name in the paper.
  2. Are Figures 1(b) and 1(c) based on real experimental data? The two figures are intended to illustrate the context and granularity mismatches, but the paper does not clearly explain how they were produced. Besides, Figure 1(c) appears a little different in visual style from the other experimental figures. If AI tools were used to generate or modify the figure, should you clarify their use in the AI Use Statement?
  3. Why are the StepOPSD results missing for Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct in Table 1?
  4. Could you provide more detailed statistics on the generation and utilization of privileged information during training? For example, it would be helpful to report the number of candidate guidance items extracted, the number and proportion retained after trajectory alignment, and the fraction of trajectories for which valid PI is available. Furthermore, Section 4.2 states that "As the policy improves, successful rollouts provide richer evidence for aligned guidance, enabling progressively finer credit allocation." Is this claim supported by empirical measurements?
  5. The baseline specification in Table 4. OPSD and GRPO+OPSD are labeled as using a "Self" teacher, whereas TASPO is labeled "Self + PI". But according to [1], OPSD should use a self-teacher conditioned on privileged information. Could you elaborate on how OPSD is implemented in your setting?

[1] Self-Distilled Reasoner: On-Policy Self-Distillation for Large Language Models

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1rno(1/3)

We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and for recognizing the challenge we address and the breadth of our experiments. This part addresses the weakness; Parts 2/3 and 3/3 answer the questions. Revisions addressing your comments are highlighted in dark green; the shared PI-availability analysis in Appendix D.8 is highlighted in blue.

W. It seems that there isn't any direct evidence can directly characterize the alleged gradient conflict between GRPO and OPSD. The reported performance improvements do not establish that mitigating such conflicts is the primary reason for TASPO's advantage. Figure 3(b) appears to be a conceptual illustration rather than a quantitative measurement of actual training gradients.

We agree that performance improvements alone do not establish the mechanism. Figure 3(b) visualizes measured objective gradients from training. We clarify its construction and provide complementary evidence at three levels.

1. Token-level coefficient disagreement. On ALFWorld with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, we measure disagreement between the outcome and distillation surrogate coefficients using AiΔ<0A_i\Delta < 0, where Δ=log⁡π(y∣PI)−log⁡π(y)\Delta=\log\pi(y\mid\mathrm{PI})-\log\pi(y). Excluding ∣Δ∣<0.05|\Delta| < 0.05, the disagreement rate is 31%, averaged over 150 training updates, and 38% when weighted by ∣Ai∣∣Δ∣|A_i||\Delta|. Among these conflicting tokens, 63% occur in failed trajectories and receive positive teacher support. TASPO does not optimize a separate distillation term; its positive weights introduce no coefficient-sign reversals relative to the outcome advantage.

2. Gradient-level measurements. Let gUg_U, dd, and gTg_T denote the GRPO, OPSD, and TASPO objective gradients. This diagnostic uses raw successful-trajectory PI for OPSD.

Figure 3(b) projects the full-batch gradients at update 80 onto the plane spanned by gUg_U and dd. Dots show per-trajectory projections, and arrow lengths are normalized for display. In this plane, the joint gradient gJ=gU+λdg_J=g_U+\lambda d, with λ=0.1\lambda=0.1, deviates from gUg_U by 35°, compared with 6° for TASPO. Additionally, 23% of per-trajectory OPSD gradients point more than 90° away from the outcome reference.

To examine whether this pattern extends beyond one update, we measure gradient directions in full parameter space at 15 checkpoints, from update 10 to 150 in increments of 10:

StatisticCheckpointsMean ± std
cos⁡(d,gU)\cos(d,g_U)All0.12 ± 0.07
Fraction of did_i with cos⁡(di,gU)<0\cos(d_i,g_U) < 0All34% ± 6%
∠(gJ,gU)\angle(g_J,g_U)Early → Late29° ± 5° → 43° ± 6°
∠(gT,gU)\angle(g_T,g_U)Early → Late7° ± 2° → 8° ± 2°

Early and late denote updates 10–50 and 100–150, respectively. The aggregate distillation gradient has weak average alignment with the outcome gradient, while approximately one-third of trajectory-level distillation gradients oppose the batch outcome reference. TASPO exhibits smaller mean angular deviations in both windows.

3. Training-level sensitivity to the distillation coefficient. Separately, Appendix D.2 compares GRPO+OPSD and TASPO under the same aligned-PI construction protocol, using three training seeds. Each method constructs PI from its own on-policy trajectories. We test three distillation coefficients around λ0=0.1\lambda_0=0.1:

MethodMean angle to the GRPO gradientALFWorld Avg. (%)
GRPO0°71.8
GRPO+OPSD, 0.5λ00.5\lambda_022°80.6
GRPO+OPSD, λ0\lambda_035°83.2
GRPO+OPSD, 2λ02\lambda_051°78.9
TASPO7°86.3

Among the tested coefficients, λ0\lambda_0 achieves the highest GRPO+OPSD success rate. Larger coefficients are accompanied by larger mean gradient deviations. TASPO exceeds all three configurations under the matched PI-construction protocol.

Together, these results document objective disagreement and smaller gradient deviations under TASPO, alongside improved performance in the controlled comparison. They support our motivation for constrained redistribution, but do not by themselves establish gradient rotation as the primary cause of the performance gap.

Revision. We have clarified the discussion in Section 4.2(line372-377), added the token-level coefficient disagreement analysis and gradient diagnostics to Appendix B.6(line1049-1073), and included the matched-PI distillation-coefficient study in Appendix D.2(line1262-1284).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1rno(2/3)

Q1. What does "TASPO" mean? I cannot find an explicit explanation of the method's name in the paper.

TASPO stands for "Trajectory-Aligned Supervision for Policy Optimization." This was the initial working title for the project, describing the method itself: performing policy optimization through process supervision that is aligned with target trajectories. We later concluded that the title should highlight our core contribution rather than the specific procedural steps—namely, how to reconcile process supervision with outcome-based credit (where the outcome determines the sign and total magnitude, while process supervision governs the relative distribution within the trajectory). Consequently, we updated the title to its current form: "Reconciling Process Supervision with Outcome-Based Credit in Agentic Policy Optimization," while retaining the original acronym. The relationship between the name and the title is as follows: "Trajectory-Aligned Supervision" corresponds to the "process supervision" discussed in the paper (Section 3.2), while "for Policy Optimization" reflects how this approach is integrated into the optimization process by redistributing outcome-based credit (Sections 3.1 and 3.4).

Q2. Are Figures 1(b) and 1(c) based on real experimental data? [...] If AI tools were used to generate or modify the figure, should you clarify their use in the AI Use Statement?

We thank the reviewer for pointing this out, both figures were generated directly from our experimental records:

  • Figure 1(b) compares measured performance under different PI sources: Generic Skill, Random Success, and Nearest Success.
  • Figure 1(c) compares action-level and token-level credit allocation using LLM-as-judge assessments of actions from recorded trajectories.
  • Figure 3(b) and its gradient measurements are explained in Part 1/3.

AI use. We used AI tools to generate and refine the visual presentation from our experimental data and author-specified instructions, including the layout, colors, and labels. The experimental data were obtained by us; the LLM-based assessments in Figure 1(c) and AI-assisted figure preparation are distinct uses of AI. The revised AI Use Statement(line1717-1720) discloses AI assistance in preparing the figures.

Q3. Why are the StepOPSD results missing for Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct in Table 1?

The StepOPSD entries are reported results from its paper (Zhang et al., 2026), not matched reruns, because we could not locate a usable official implementation to rerun it under our budget. That paper reports Qwen2.5-3B and Qwen3-1.7B on ALFWorld and Search-QA only, with no Qwen2.5-7B or WebShop results, hence the empty cells. In the revised version, Table 1 (line 275) marks these entries as reported results, and Appendix C.1 lists their source configurations.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1rno(3/3)

Q4. Could you provide more detailed statistics on the generation and utilization of privileged information during training? Furthermore, Section 4.2 states that "As the policy improves, successful rollouts provide richer evidence for aligned guidance, enabling progressively finer credit allocation." Is this claim supported by empirical measurements?

We track four statistics: the number of candidate guidance items extracted per rollout group (NeN_e), the number retained per target after alignment (NgN_g), the retention ratio (Ng/NeN_g/N_e), and the valid-PI rate, the fraction of nonzero-advantage trajectories (Ai≠0A_i\neq0) that receive valid aligned PI (the complement of the no-PI fallback rate reported in our response to Reviewer ikMb). The table compares the first 10 and the last 10 policy updates.

BackboneEnvironmentNeN_eNgN_gNg/NeN_g/N_e (%)Valid-PI rate (%)
Qwen2.5-3BALFWorld4.1 → 6.83.2 → 5.978 → 8783.2 → 93.6
WebShop5.3 → 7.44.2 → 6.779 → 9177.4 → 89.1
Qwen2.5-7BALFWorld4.7 → 7.23.8 → 6.581 → 9086.8 → 94.5
WebShop5.7 → 7.94.8 → 7.484 → 9482.6 → 91.4
Qwen3-1.7BALFWorld2.9 → 5.42.0 → 4.669 → 8572.7 → 91.0
WebShop4.1 → 6.23.1 → 5.576 → 8971.9 → 87.3

Across all six settings, both the amount of aligned guidance and the fraction of trajectories that receive it increase over training. This supports the statement in Section 4.2: as training progresses, successful rollouts provide richer evidence, and credit redistribution applies to more trajectories. We have added these statistics to Appendix D.8(line1560-1608) and revised the sentence in Section 4.2(line373-377) to state this more precisely.

Q5. OPSD and GRPO+OPSD are labeled as using a "Self" teacher, whereas TASPO is labeled "Self + PI". But according to [1], OPSD should use a self-teacher conditioned on privileged information. Could you elaborate on how OPSD is implemented in your setting?

Yes, the OPSD self-teacher is conditioned on PI, consistent with Self-Distilled Reasoner [1]. In Table 4, "Self" referred to the teacher model (the same base model as the student), not to the absence of PI. In our agent adaptation, each task produces 8 on-policy rollouts; the first environment-verified successful trajectory supplies its complete interaction record (actions and observations) as shared PI for the group's teacher evaluations. If no rollout succeeds, the group receives no distillation signal.

The distinction lies in how PI is constructed and used. OPSD conditions its self-teacher on a raw successful trajectory and directly optimizes a distillation objective. TASPO instead extracts guidance from successful siblings, aligns it with each target's realized history, and uses action-level likelihood shifts to redistribute the original outcome advantage.

We have revised Table 4 (line 449) to distinguish raw-PI and aligned-PI conditioning explicitly.

Again, we thank the reviewer for the valuable feedback. Please let us know if there are any further questions or suggestions.

[1] Self-Distilled Reasoner: On-Policy Self-Distillation for Large Language Models

Reviewer_9U9wOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TASPO constructs guidance from successful sibling trajectories and uses it to score the actions in a sampled trajectory. These scores determine how the outcome advantage is distributed across steps. The weights are positive, bounded, and have a mean of one, so the adjusted advantage keeps the original sign and trajectory-level mean.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation and design of the method are reasonable and easy to follow. Process guidance can change how strongly an action is reinforced or penalized, but it cannot change the sign of its outcome advantage. This limits the impact of inaccurate guidance on training.

  2. The experiments are fairly comprehensive. They cover three environments and three backbones, and include a broad set of baselines from RL, OPD, and step-level credit assignment baseline (e.g., GiGPO). The ablations are also clear. They study guidance construction and compare token-level and action-level guidance allocation, which helps in understanding the design choices of the method.

Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is whether TASPO provides a consistent improvement over the baselines, especially in the Qwen2.5-7B comparison in the main table. Compared with OPID, TASPO improves ALFWorld and Search-QA by less than 1 pp, but its WebShop success rate is 3.3 pp lower. The main table does not report standard deviations or error bars across runs. Results in these agent environments often vary considerably between runs, and the differences in the means are small. The means alone are therefore not sufficient to show that the improvement over OPID is stable and reliable.

  2. The paper should explain its methodological contribution relative to the baselines more clearly, especially relative to StepOPSD and SGCD. StepOPSD already uses action-centered steps and sign-preserving advantage shaping, and SGCD uses bounded credit weights instead of a separate distillation loss. Compared with these works, it is unclear to me how much TASPO contributes beyond combining the designs of these two papers. The mean-one constraint appears to be the main difference, but no ablation isolates its effect.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors report the mean and variance of the results in the main table? This would help me assess how stable the reported improvements are.

  2. Could the authors clarify what distinct design choices TASPO introduces beyond the techniques already used in StepOPSD and SGCD? it would be also helpful to see an ablation that removes the mean-one normalization (e.g., using unnormalized or amplification-only weights) while keeping all other components fixed.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 9U9w(1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the careful and constructive review, and for recognizing the sign-preserving design and the breadth of our experiments. This part addresses the stability of the reported improvements; Part 2/2 addresses the contribution relative to StepOPSD and SGCD and the mean-one ablation. For ease of reference, revisions addressing your comments are highlighted in purple in the revised manuscript.

W1. My main concern is whether TASPO provides a consistent improvement over the baselines, especially in the Qwen2.5-7B comparison in the main table. Compared with OPID, TASPO improves ALFWorld and Search-QA by less than 1 pp, but its WebShop success rate is 3.3 pp lower. The main table does not report standard deviations or error bars across runs. Results in these agent environments often vary considerably between runs, and the differences in the means are small. The means alone are therefore not sufficient to show that the improvement over OPID is stable and reliable.

Q1. Could the authors report the mean and variance of the results in the main table? This would help me assess how stable the reported improvements are.

Table 1 now reports the mean ± standard deviation over three training seeds for every entry. Below we summarize the aggregate metrics for GRPO, SDAR, OPID, and TASPO, which share the same training and evaluation settings (all values in %).

BackboneMethodALFWorld Avg.Search-QA Avg.WebShop ScoreWebShop Succ.
Qwen2.5-3BGRPO71.8 ± 2.836.4 ± 1.979.8 ± 2.663.3 ± 3.4
SDAR80.1 ± 2.543.4 ± 1.885.0 ± 2.268.0 ± 3.1
OPID84.3 ± 2.245.0 ± 2.185.0 ± 2.374.2 ± 3.7
TASPO86.3 ± 1.446.4 ± 1.288.5 ± 1.478.1 ± 2.6
Qwen2.5-7BGRPO77.0 ± 2.548.1 ± 1.685.7 ± 2.175.0 ± 3.0
SDAR83.9 ± 2.449.0 ± 1.989.4 ± 1.882.8 ± 5.9
OPID90.0 ± 2.149.2 ± 2.285.3 ± 2.679.7 ± 4.3
TASPO90.1 ± 1.349.8 ± 1.087.7 ± 1.676.4 ± 2.1
Qwen3-1.7BGRPO40.1 ± 3.843.6 ± 2.455.8 ± 3.043.0 ± 3.5
SDAR47.6 ± 3.241.9 ± 2.376.8 ± 2.658.6 ± 3.1
OPID58.9 ± 3.140.4 ± 2.179.6 ± 2.464.8 ± 3.4
TASPO69.6 ± 1.946.6 ± 1.577.6 ± 1.867.1 ± 2.5

Stability. Across three independent training seeds, TASPO has the lowest observed standard deviation among the four methods in all 12 backbone–metric combinations.

Performance relative to OPID. TASPO achieves higher means in 10 of the 12 comparisons. On Qwen2.5-7B, it combines similar mean performance on ALFWorld and Search-QA (+0.1 and +0.6 pp) with lower observed variability. WebShop results differ by metric: TASPO obtains a higher Score (87.7 vs. 85.3), while OPID achieves higher strict Success (79.7 vs. 76.4). Larger gains appear on other backbones, reaching +10.7 pp on ALFWorld and +6.2 pp on Search-QA with Qwen3-1.7B.

Comparison with GRPO. TASPO improves the mean over GRPO, the objective it directly modifies, in all 12 combinations.

Revision. Table 1 (lines 271–303) of the revised manuscript now reports the mean ± standard deviation for every entry.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 9U9w(2/2)

W2. The paper should explain its methodological contribution relative to the baselines more clearly, especially relative to StepOPSD and SGCD. [The mean-one constraint appears to be the main difference, but no ablation isolates its effect.

Q2. Could the authors clarify what distinct design choices TASPO introduces beyond the techniques already used in StepOPSD and SGCD? It would be also helpful to see an ablation that removes the mean-one normalization (e.g., using unnormalized or amplification-only weights) while keeping all other components fixed.

Thank you for this question.

StepOPSD [1], SGCD [2], and TASPO share a starting point: process signals should reshape the GRPO advantage rather than compete with it as a separate loss. They differ in how much freedom the process signal is given. Neither StepOPSD nor SGCD constrains how much total credit a trajectory receives. TASPO enforces a stricter principle: outcome feedback fixes the sign and the trajectory-average credit; process supervision only decides its allocation across decisions. Realizing this principle requires three design choices, each supported by a controlled ablation.

StepOPSDSGCDTASPO
GuidanceFirst successful peer, used as isOne LLM-generated reference shared by the groupChecked against each target's own history
Credit unitPer-token weights in action spansPer-token / segment weightsOne relative weight per action
Weight ruleClipped sigmoid of token gap, per-step budgetAmplify-only, W∈[1,2]W\in[1,2]Zero-sum, w∈[1−ϵw,1+ϵw]w\in[1-\epsilon_w,1+\epsilon_w]
Trajectory-average advantageNot guaranteedNot preservedPreserved exactly

1. Target-aligned guidance. StepOPSD conditions on the raw successful peer, and SGCD gives every sibling the same group-level reference. Neither specifies a separate step that checks whether the guidance applies to the states the target trajectory actually reached. TASPO retains guidance only if it is consistent with the target's completed history (Section 3.2). Alignment alone adds 3.3 pp on ALFWorld (Appendix D.1). In the new WebShop replay diagnostic (see our response to Reviewer ikMb), aligned PI also agrees much better with replay-estimated utility than raw successful-sibling PI (Spearman 0.38 vs. 0.22).

2. One relative weight per action. StepOPSD scores action-centered spans but still weights each token inside them differently; SGCD weights tokens by divergence saliency. TASPO averages the likelihood shift over the executable action, centers it within the trajectory, and applies one weight to the whole turn. This outperforms token-level allocation by 6.6 / 3.5 / 6.0 pp on ALFWorld / Search-QA / WebShop and halves the across-seed std on ALFWorld (2.9 → 1.4; Table 3).

3. Outcome-preserving redistribution. TASPO's weights are zero-sum deviations around one:

A~it=Aiwit,wit=1+η(qit−qˉi),1Ti∑t=1TiA~it=Ai.\widetilde{A}_{it}=A_i w_{it},\quad w_{it}=1+\eta(q_{it}-\bar{q}_i),\quad \frac{1}{T_i}\sum_{t=1}^{T_i}\widetilde{A}_{it}=A_i. Each trajectory's average credit thus equals its verified outcome advantage, and the zero-sum balance of GRPO's group advantages is kept. In contrast, SGCD's amplify-only weights increase a trajectory's credit whenever any weight exceeds one, and StepOPSD equalizes the absolute modification budget across steps rather than preserving the trajectory-average advantage.

Mean-one ablation. As requested, we change only the weighting rule, keeping aligned PI, action scoring, redistribution strength, and the training configuration fixed (ALFWorld, Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, three seeds). Group zero-sum deviation, ∣∑iAi(wˉi−1)∣/∑i∣Ai∣\lvert\sum_{i}A_{i}(\bar{w}_{i}-1)\rvert/\sum_{i}\lvert A_{i}\rvert measures how far a rule shifts a group's net credit.

Weight ruleALFWorld Avg. (%)Group zero-sum deviationMean ∣wˉi−1∣\lvert\bar w_i-1\rvert
TASPO (mean-one)86.3 ± 1.400
w/o mean-one centering83.1 ± 2.20.080.04
Amplify-only (SGCD-style)81.7 ± 2.50.150.06

Once net credit is no longer anchored to the outcome, performance drops by 3.2 pp without centering and by 4.6 pp with amplify-only weighting, with larger across-seed variability. Amplify-only is an SGCD-style rule within TASPO, not a full SGCD reproduction.

Revision. We have added the comparison and the mean-one ablation, with full experimental details, to Appendix D.9 (lines 1611–1632) of the revised manuscript.

Again, we thank the reviewer for the valuable feedback. Please let us know if there are any further questions or suggestions.

[1] StepOPSD: Step-Aware Online Preference Self-Distillation for Agent Reinforcement Learning

[2] Keep Policy Gradient in Charge: Sibling-Guided Credit Distillation for Long-Horizon Tool-Use Agents

Thank you for the explanation. My main concerns have been addressed, and will update my rating accordingly.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Authors

Thank you once again for your review and for providing constructive feedback. We appreciate you taking the time to consider our responses. We are pleased that they have addressed most of your concerns!

Reviewer_ikMbOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TASPO addresses the coarse credit assignment in GRPO, which gives every turn in a trajectory the same advantage. It uses privileged information from successful rollouts on the same task to measure changes in action likelihood, then redistributes the outcome advantage across turns while preserving its sign and mean within each trajectory. The method requires no additional environment rollouts or trained critic. On ALFWorld, Search QA, and WebShop, it improves average performance over GRPO by 12.4 percentage points.

Critical strengths
  1. TASPO uses information from successful rollouts to provide finer grained credit assignment, without requiring a trained critic or additional environment rollouts. Its redistribution also preserves the sign and mean of the original advantage within each trajectory.

  2. TASPO improves average performance over GRPO by 12.4 percentage points across ALFWorld, Search QA, and WebShop, showing gains in three different agent environments.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Changes in action likelihood after adding privileged information may reflect the model’s sensitivity to additional instructions rather than the action’s actual utility. For example, an important action that already has a high probability may show only a small change. The paper provides a counterfactual validation on ALFWorld, but it is unclear whether this signal generalizes to other agent environments.

  2. TASPO depends on successful sibling trajectories to construct privileged information. On difficult tasks with low success rates, such trajectories may be scarce, causing the method to fall back to GRPO more often. The paper does not sufficiently analyze how task difficulty and privileged information coverage affect performance.

Questions for authors
  1. To what extent do changes in action likelihood after adding privileged information reflect action utility across different environments, especially for important actions that already have high probabilities? Extending the counterfactual validation to WebShop or Search QA would help address this question.

  2. Could the authors report how often TASPO falls back to GRPO and compare its performance gains across task difficulty levels and privileged information coverage rates, particularly when successful sibling trajectories are scarce?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ikMb(1/2)

We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and for recognizing that TASPO provides finer-grained credit assignment without a trained critic or additional environment rollouts. We address the concerns point by point below. For ease of reference, revisions addressing your comments are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript.

W1 / Q1. Changes in action likelihood after adding privileged information may reflect the model's sensitivity to additional instructions rather than the action's actual utility. For example, an important action that already has a high probability may show only a small change. The paper provides a counterfactual validation on ALFWorld, but it is unclear whether this signal generalizes to other agent environments.

We address this question with three analyses based on replay-estimated action utility:

  1. a context-control experiment;

  2. a stratification by original action probability;

  3. an extension of the counterfactual replay diagnostic to WebShop.

In short, the ranking signal nearly disappears when PI is replaced by irrelevant text, stays largely intact for high-probability actions, and reproduces in WebShop.

  1. The signal is not explained by sensitivity to additional context.

If the likelihood shifts only reflected sensitivity to additional instructions, any added context of similar length would produce a similar ranking of actions. To test this, we reuse the ALFWorld replay diagnostic in Appendix D.4 with the same frozen checkpoint, 100 trajectories, 400 decision points, and replay-utility estimates. The only change is the context injected for scoring.

contextSpearman ρPairwise acc. (%)Utility gap (pp)
TASPO aligned PI0.4169.619.6
Length-matched irrelevant text0.0451.91.8
Aligned PI from a different task0.13565.1

With length-matched irrelevant text, agreement with replay utility drops to near chance (ρ = 0.04; pairwise accuracy 51.9%). PI from a different task recovers only a small part of the signal (ρ = 0.13). The ranking signal therefore comes mainly from guidance that is relevant to the target task, not from the mere presence of additional context.

  1. High-probability actions retain a comparable ranking signal.

We agree that an action that is already highly likely has limited room for its likelihood to increase. TASPO bounds the effect of such cases. Its weights are positive and bounded, so a small shift can rescale an action's outcome-based credit by at most ±ε_w. It can never remove or reverse that credit (Section 3.4).

Whether high-probability actions are still ranked reliably is an empirical question, so we tested it directly. We split the 400 decision points into terciles by their original action log-probabilities under the policy without PI, then computed the agreement metrics within each tercile.

Original-probability tercilenSpearman ρPairwise acc. (%)
High1330.3769
Middle1340.4470.7
Low1330.468.2

Ranking quality is similar across the three terciles. In the high-probability tercile, the signal keeps a Spearman correlation of 0.37 and a pairwise accuracy of 69.0%, close to the overall values (0.41 and 69.6%). The ceiling effect the reviewer describes therefore has only a marginal effect on the ranking signal in practice.

  1. The signal transfers to WebShop.

Following the reviewer's suggestion, we extend the counterfactual replay diagnostic to WebShop. Using a frozen Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct checkpoint, we evaluate 100 held-out trajectories with four decision points each. At each decision point, we restore the recorded browsing state, sample three alternative actions, and run 15 continuations per action.

Scoring signalSpearman ρPairwise acc. (%)
TASPO aligned PI0.3867.2
Raw successful-sibling PI0.2259.8
Policy confidence0.0652.1
Length-matched irrelevant text0.0551.6

The WebShop results reproduce the ALFWorld pattern. Aligned PI agrees most strongly with replay utility (ρ = 0.38; 67.2%), followed by raw successful-sibling PI (ρ = 0.22). Policy confidence and length-matched irrelevant text stay near chance. The utility signal therefore holds beyond ALFWorld, and again it cannot be attributed to generic context sensitivity.

Revision. We have added the context controls, probability-stratified analysis, and WebShop replay diagnostic, together with their experimental settings and results, to Appendix D.4(line 1401-1430) of the revised version.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ikMb(2/2)

W2 / Q2. Fallback frequency and performance under limited successful-sibling availability

We thank for raising this question. Across our nine training settings, TASPO falls back to GRPO on 8–19% of trajectories that carry a nonzero advantage, and this rate falls by half or more from early to late training. On the tasks where fallback is most frequent—those the initial policy never solves—TASPO still gains +20.5 pp over GRPO. When we artificially discard valid PI, the gain shrinks gradually rather than collapsing: keeping only 25% of PI retains about 40% of the full improvement. Details below.

  1. How often does TASPO fall back to GRPO?

Over all 150 training updates we log (i) the share of trajectories with zero group advantage (AiA_i=0), which carry no outcome-advantage signal under either method; (ii) the share with nonzero advantage and valid aligned PI (PI coverage); and (iii) the share of nonzero-advantage trajectories without valid PI—the fallback rate we talk about.

BackboneEnvironmentPI coverage (%)Ai=0A_i=0 (%)No-PI fallback (%)Early → Late (%)
Qwen2.5-3BALFWorld72.419.510.116.8 → 6.4
Search-QA63.826.812.819.5 → 8.1
WebShop77.18.415.822.6 → 10.9
Qwen2.5-7BALFWorld68.625.18.413.2 → 5.5
Search-QA66.32610.415.9 → 7.2
WebShop79.9912.217.4 → 8.6
Qwen3-1.7BALFWorld61.127.615.627.3 → 9.0
Search-QA62.526.415.122.8 → 10.3
WebShop72.710.21928.1 → 12.7

Two observations can be made. First, fallback stays below 20% in every setting. This is because a single successful sibling already yields candidate guidance for every other trajectory in its group (subject to alignment with each target's history); Multiple successes are not required. Second, fallback falls by half or more from early to late training in all nine settings, consistent with the reinforcing cycle described in Section 4.2: as the policy improves, more groups contain a success from which PI can be built.

  1. Does fallback erase the gains on difficult tasks?

We group ALFWorld tasks by how many of 8 rollouts the initial Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct policy solves, so the grouping is fixed before training and independent of either method. We report final performance and the training-time fallback rate within each group.

Initial successes (/8)Task share (%)GRPO (%)TASPO (%)Gain (pp)Training fallback (%)
052.161.582+20.515.2
1–226.480.290.1+9.98.4
≥321.586.391.5+5.25.1
All10071.886.2+14.410.1

Tasks with no initial successes account for 52.1% of the task set and have the highest training fallback rate, at 15.2%. Nevertheless, TASPO improves their final performance from 61.5% to 82.0%, a gain of 20.5 percentage points. Gains are positive in all three groups. These results show that limited initial successful-sibling availability does not prevent substantial improvements during training.

  1. How does performance degrade as PI becomes scarcer?.

We further test sensitivity to PI availability by randomly retaining each otherwise valid PI with probability rr, using uniform GRPO credit whenever it is discarded. The analyzer, hyperparameters, and training protocol remain fixed.

PI retention rr0 (GRPO)0.250.50.751 (TASPO)
ALFWorld Avg. (%)71.877.681.984.686.3

Mean performance increases at each tested retention level. Retaining only 25% of otherwise available PI preserves approximately 40% of the full improvement over GRPO; retaining 50% preserves approximately 70%. This controlled experiment shows that partial use of valid PI can still provide substantial benefits, while greater availability yields larger gains.

Revision. We have added the fallback statistics, difficulty-stratified results, and controlled PI-retention experiment to Appendix D.8(line1561-1608) of the revised version.

Again, we thank the reviewer for the valuable feedback. Please let us know if there are any further questions or suggestions.

Thank you for your thoughtful response. The clarifications have addressed my concerns, and I will maintain my positive rating.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

We thank the Area Chairs and all reviewers for their time and constructive feedback. We have addressed the reviewers’ comments in our individual responses and revised the manuscript accordingly. In the follow-up discussion, Reviewer 9U9w confirmed that our responses had addressed their main concerns and subsequently raised their rating from 2 to 3. For ease of reference, revisions are color-coded by reviewer: blue for Reviewer ikMb, purple for Reviewer 9U9w, and dark green for Reviewer 1rno.

We appreciate the reviewers’ recognition of the following aspects of our work:

  • Important problem and principled design (Reviewers 9U9w, 1rno): TASPO reconciles process supervision with outcome-based reinforcement learning. The outcome advantage sets the sign and trajectory mean of the credit, while process guidance redistributes credit across decisions within explicit bounds.
  • Fine-grained credit without a trained critic or additional rollouts (Reviewers ikMb, 1rno): TASPO assigns credit at the decision level by reweighting the outcome advantage using existing training rollouts.
  • Comprehensive experiments and clear ablations (Reviewers ikMb, 9U9w, 1rno): Our experiments cover three agent environments and three backbones, with baselines from RL, on-policy distillation, and step-level credit assignment. TASPO consistently improves over GRPO, and the ablations examine the contribution of its main design choices.

In response to the reviewers’ questions, we added the following analyses and clarifications:

  • Run-to-run stability (Reviewer 9U9w): Table 1 now reports mean ± standard deviation across three training seeds for GRPO, SDAR, OPID, and TASPO. TASPO has a higher mean than GRPO in all 12 backbone–metric combinations. We also corrected Appendix C.1, which had incorrectly described the original single-run results as averages across three training seeds.
  • Distinction from StepOPSD and SGCD (Reviewer 9U9w): Appendix D.9 compares the three methods and adds the requested ablation. With the other components held fixed, removing mean-one centering reduces ALFWorld success by 3.2 percentage points, and using SGCD-style amplification-only weighting reduces it by 4.6 percentage points.
  • Evidence for optimization conflict (Reviewer 1rno):
    • Token- and gradient-level diagnostics: Appendix B.6 measures how often the outcome and distillation objectives assign token-level coefficients with opposite signs and compares their gradient directions at 15 checkpoints. Figure 3(b) shows one of these measurements.
    • Distillation-coefficient sensitivity: Appendix D.2 varies the OPSD coefficient while using the same aligned PI construction as TASPO. TASPO achieves a higher mean success rate than each tested coefficient setting.
    • Scope of the claim: Section 4.2 presents these findings as evidence motivating the design and leaves open how much gradient conflict accounts for the performance gains.
  • Validity of the PI-induced signal (Reviewer ikMb): Appendix D.4 adds controls for the injected context, stratifies decision points by original action probability, and extends the counterfactual replay diagnostic to WebShop. On ALFWorld, rankings based on aligned privileged information (PI) agree more closely with replay-estimated utility than rankings based on irrelevant context. The agreement remains positive in the highest-probability group, and we also observe positive agreement on WebShop.
  • PI availability and fallback (Reviewers ikMb, 1rno): Appendix D.8 reports PI generation and retention statistics, fallback rates across all nine settings, results stratified by initial task difficulty, and a controlled PI-retention experiment. Among trajectories with nonzero advantage, 8.4%–19.0% revert to uniform GRPO credit because no valid PI is available. TASPO improves over GRPO by 20.5 percentage points on ALFWorld tasks with zero successes in eight initial-policy rollouts.
  • Clarity and presentation (Reviewer 1rno): We spell out TASPO, document how Figures 1(b), 1(c), and 3(b) were produced, and disclose AI assistance with figure preparation in the AI Use Statement. Table 1 identifies StepOPSD results taken from prior work, Appendix C.1 documents the corresponding experimental configurations, and Table 4 clarifies that OPSD also conditions on PI.

We appreciate the reviewers’ suggestions, which helped us clarify the scope of our claims and strengthen the empirical evaluation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up Discussions-1

We thank the PC,SAC, AC and reviewers for the continued discussion. Following our earlier general response, we have received encouraging feedback from all three reviewers:

  • Reviewer 9U9w confirmed that our responses addressed their main concerns and raised their rating from 2 to 3.
  • Reviewer ikMb explicitly stated that our clarifications had addressed their concerns and that they would maintain their positive rating.
  • Reviewer 1rno acknowledged that our explanations had improved their understanding of the work and indicated that they would maintain their positive rating.

We also appreciate the additional follow-up questions from Reviewers ikMb and 1rno, which we have addressed in their respective discussion threads:

  • Sign-dependent credit redistribution (Reviewer ikMb). In response to the question about positive- versus negative-advantage redistribution, we conducted an additional controlled ablation on ALFWorld. Both variants improve over GRPO, with Positive-only achieving +6.6 pp and Negative-only achieving +9.7 pp. Combining both yields the strongest performance (+14.5 pp), demonstrating their complementary contributions.
  • Comprehensive AI-use disclosure (Reviewer 1rno). We provided a figure-by-figure account of AI assistance for all figures in the main text and appendix, clarifying the experimental data sources, author-designed scientific content, and AI-assisted visualization procedures. We also described representative workflows for Figures 1(c) and 3(a).

Taken together, the revised manuscript and subsequent discussions have addressed the reviewers' original concerns and provided further clarification and experimental evidence in response to their follow-up questions. We sincerely appreciate the reviewers' constructive engagement.

As the discussion period is drawing to a close, please feel free to reach out to us if you have any further questions or suggestions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.