- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper identifies a common issue in Agentic RL + OPSD training: due to the sources of privileged information (PI) and various other factors, the teacher's judgment of whether the current action is correct may not always be accurate, and may not align with outcome feedback. To address this issue, the paper builds on the idea of LOPD and proposes Pilot. Based on learnable latent PI, it trains an analyzer to generate outcome-aligned PI, so that the teacher conditioned on this PI makes judgments about actions that align with environmental feedback. When updating the actor, the paper uses PI-Guided Actor Optimization to introduce a finer-grained loss on top of GRPO.
The authors evaluate Pilot on ALFWorld and WebShop using Qwen2.5-3B/7B-Instruct as backbones, and compare it with a wide range of mainstream RL and OPD/OPSD methods. Compared with existing baselines, Pilot achieves consistent improvements.
Critical strengths
- The paper is clearly written and easy to understand. Readers can quickly follow the logical progression from the problem identified by the authors to their proposed solution and method analysis. The analyzer architecture, training procedure, and loss derivations are also clear and easy to follow.
- Pilot's approach of improving PI quality by training a latent PI analyzer is insightful. It also provides a promising direction for future work on dynamically generating PI for the current trajectory to prevent the teacher from being misled.
- Pilot achieves relatively consistent improvements over existing baselines across two backbones and two benchmarks, demonstrating the effectiveness of the method. The experiments are also quite solid, with fairly comprehensive ablation studies supporting the effectiveness of most design choices.
Critical weaknesses
- Some figures are not vector graphics but PNG images that become blurry when zoomed in (e.g., Figures 1 and 2). This is not quite in line with the presentation standards expected of an academic paper.
- In my view, the purpose of combining RL with OPSD is that RL provides reliable but relatively coarse-grained supervision, while OPSD can provide fine-grained token-level supervision. However, the proposed method forces the PI-conditioned teacher's average assessment over an entire trajectory to align with the coarse-grained supervision from the final outcome. In this setting, even an ultimately successful trajectory may contain incorrect or redundant steps. The Analyzer's training makes no distinction between the correct and incorrect steps within that trajectory, which may result in the PI-conditioned teacher still being unable to distinguish good and bad steps within the same trajectory at a fine-grained level.
- The gate in the current L_OPSD design is always positive, and the L_OPSD term always encourages the sampled actions. This is undesirable for actions that are inherently poor or redundant.
Questions for authors
- Are there any experiments that directly demonstrate the effectiveness of the Outcome Alignment mechanism? For example, after training with Outcome Alignment, do queries with high outcome credit actually receive more positive PI influence, while queries with low outcome credit receive more negative PI influence?
- During Analyzer training, its learning signal depends on sufficient outcome variation within the reference group. For tasks that are too difficult, where many rollout groups have all-zero rewards, would Pilot fail? Traditional RL + OPSD can also alleviate this issue to some extent.
6 comments
W3. Potential Limitations of Positive Gating in Action Reinforcement
Response: Thank you for pointing this out. We agree that positive gating assigns nonzero auxiliary imitation weights even to actions with negative influence. Pilot is designed to weaken auxiliary reinforcement of these actions rather than directly convert negative influence into a penalty. PI influence measures how PI changes the sampled action’s log-probability; it is not a direct label of action correctness. Negative influence therefore does not necessarily indicate an incorrect or redundant action.
1. How soft gating modulates auxiliary reinforcement.
With and , negative influence receives , whereas positive influence receives . Negative-influence actions thus receive lower auxiliary imitation weights. This gate is used jointly with the GRPO objective, and both objectives determine the overall policy update. A positive gate neither reinforces all sampled actions equally nor implies that the overall update necessarily increases every action’s probability.
2. Empirical comparison of gating variants.
To investigate whether completely filtering or explicitly suppressing negative-influence actions is beneficial, we evaluated four additional variants:
| Method | Gate or auxiliary update | Validation success rate (%) | Validation score (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pilot (originally reported) | 82.0 | 90.6 | |
| Hard-zero nonpositive influence | 65.6 | 74.9 | |
| Smooth positive-only gate | 63.3 | 82.4 | |
| Signed auxiliary update | , with clipping | 60.2 | 77.1 |
| No Actor auxiliary objective | Zero auxiliary loss coefficient; retain Analyzer training | 58.6 | 76.7 |
The signed variant promotes actions with positive weights and suppresses actions with negative weights within a clipped log-probability-change interval of . Both the weights and old-policy log-probabilities are detached. The variant without the Actor auxiliary objective retains Analyzer training and therefore is not an independent GRPO baseline.
None of these alternatives exceeded Pilot’s originally reported results. Among the supplementary variants, the signed update also achieved lower success rate and score than smooth positive-only gating. These observations are consistent with the rationale for soft gating: reducing auxiliary imitation weights for negative-influence actions can be an effective choice without directly converting negative influence into a penalty.
We have added a related discussion in Appendix D.4 to clarify that sigmoid gating continuously modulates auxiliary imitation strength rather than directly determining action correctness or guaranteeing that all incorrect or redundant actions are filtered out. We have also added the experimental settings and results of these variants in Appendix D.4 to explain the empirical basis of this design.
Q1. Experimental Validation of Outcome Alignment Effectiveness
Response: Thank you for suggesting this direct examination of the mechanism. We conducted a controlled experiment to measure whether Outcome Alignment makes PI influence more favorable for higher-credit queries than for lower-credit queries. The results show substantially stronger credit–influence alignment and a larger high–low credit influence gap after training with correctly associated outcome credits, including on tasks excluded from Analyzer training.
1. Controlled experimental setup. We held the Actor checkpoint, rollout corpus, source–query pairings, and evaluation credits fixed. The Actor remained frozen throughout, and we compared four Analyzer variants:
- Initialized Analyzer: evaluated the common initialization without further training.
- No Alignment: removed the Outcome Alignment term and trained using only the original anchor and influence regularizers.
- Shuffled Credit: retained the alignment objective and regularizers but shuffled query-level training credits within each task.
- Full Alignment: trained with correctly associated query outcome credits and the original regularizers.
The three trained variants started from the same Analyzer initialization and used the same data order, learning rate, and budget of 150 Analyzer updates, with random seed 0. We used four training tasks comprising 313 turns and four held-out tasks comprising 23 valid query trajectories and 294 turns. The held-out tasks did not participate in Analyzer updates.
2. Direct measurement of credit–influence alignment. For query trajectory , we measure its average bounded PI influence as
where is the mean sampled-action token log-probability with PI minus that without PI. Let denote the normalized outcome credit. We report two metrics:
- Credit–influence alignment: .
- High–low credit influence gap: .
Both metrics are computed within each held-out task and then averaged across tasks. Higher values indicate stronger alignment between outcome credit and PI influence.
| Analyzer variant | Credit–influence alignment ↑ | High–low credit influence gap ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| Initialized Analyzer | 0.00776 | 0.01604 |
| No Alignment | 0.00062 | 0.00147 |
| Shuffled Credit | 0.00620 | 0.01300 |
| Full Alignment | 0.08159 | 0.22275 |
3. Findings. Full Alignment increased credit–influence alignment from 0.00776 to 0.08159 and the high–low credit influence gap from 0.01604 to 0.22275 relative to initialization. Its influence gap also exceeded that of every control on each of the four held-out tasks. Removing the alignment term substantially weakened this separation, and shuffling credits also reduced it, supporting the importance of the correct credit–query correspondence.
These controlled results provide direct evidence that Outcome Alignment learns a relative trajectory-level relationship: higher-credit queries receive more favorable PI influence than lower-credit queries, and this relationship extends to the held-out tasks in this experiment.
Response: Thank you for pointing this out. We have replaced Figures 1 and 2 with vector graphics and checked the remaining figures to ensure that text and graphical elements remain clear when zoomed in.
Response: Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that successful trajectories may contain incorrect or redundant steps. Outcome Alignment constrains average trajectory-level influence while retaining step-specific scoring and weighting. To examine whether these weights reflect differences in action utility within the same trajectory, we conducted an additional within-trajectory counterfactual continuation analysis.
1. Trajectory-level alignment and step-specific weighting.
For query trajectory j, the average bounded PI influence is
\sum_{t\in\mathcal T_j} \tanh\left(\frac{\Delta_{jt}}{T_\Delta}\right).$$ The Analyzer’s alignment term encourages queries with higher relative outcome credit to receive higher average influence, subject to regularization. **This average constraint neither assigns the trajectory’s final outcome label to every action nor requires all steps to have identical or positive influence.** At each step, influence is computed by comparing the log-probability of the same sampled action with and without PI, conditioned on its interaction history, and is used to determine the auxiliary imitation weight. **2. Within-trajectory counterfactual analysis of action utility.** Across four ALFWorld tasks, we selected one high-gate and one low-gate nonterminal valid decision position from **the same original trajectory** for each task. Positions were selected before continuation evaluation, with the Actor, Analyzer, PI pairings, and gate weights fixed. Each pair therefore shares the same original trajectory outcome, allowing us to examine whether the gates contain decision information beyond overall trajectory success or failure. At each position, we restored the complete environment state and interaction history before the action and estimated: - $Q_t$: the success rate (%) when the original action is forced and execution then continues with the frozen PI-free Actor. - $V_t$: the success rate (%) when the current action is resampled from the same Actor and execution then continues. Both branches used the same remaining environment-step budget, with **eight independent continuations per branch**. We measured the original action’s local advantage over resampling from the current policy as $$\widehat A_t=\widehat Q_t-\widehat V_t.$$ This advantage is estimated independently through environment continuations and can be positive, zero, or negative; it is distinct from the gate weight, which remains positive. Success rates, estimated advantages, and advantage gaps below are expressed in %. | Task | Gate weights (High / Low) | High-gate advantage (%) | Low-gate advantage (%) | Advantage gap (%) | | :--- | :---: | :---: | :---: | :---: | | Examine CD | 0.70 / 0.35 | +37.5 | −12.5 | +50.0 | | Clean fork | 0.68 / 0.40 | +25.0 | 0.0 | +25.0 | | Examine laptop | 0.75 / 0.30 | +25.0 | −12.5 | +37.5 | | Clean lettuce | 0.72 / 0.25 | +25.0 | −37.5 | +62.5 | **In all four comparisons, the high-gate action had a higher estimated local advantage than the low-gate action within the same trajectory, with a mean advantage gap of 43.75%.** High-gate actions consistently had positive estimated advantages, whereas low-gate actions had zero or negative estimated advantages and received lower auxiliary imitation weights. **Despite sharing the same original trajectory outcome, high-gate actions consistently exhibited higher estimated local advantages, showing that the gates captured differences in action utility beyond overall trajectory success or failure at the evaluated positions.** We have added a related discussion in **Appendix E.3** to clarify how trajectory-level alignment and step-specific auxiliary weighting complement each other.