- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Process Advantage Signal Shaping (PASS), an advantage-construction framework for process-supervised reinforcement learning in LLM reasoning. PASS consists of three main components: Advantage Fusion (AF), which separately normalizes and combines process, outcome, and format rewards; Chunk-by-Value (CV), which defines chunks according to numerical changes in the fused reward signal; and Divide-Length (DL), which normalizes accumulated future rewards by the number of remaining chunks.
The method is evaluated on mathematical reasoning and multi-hop question answering. In mathematics, PASS incorporates PRM-based process supervision and improves average pass@1 by 4.62 percentage points over outcome-only GRPO across seven benchmarks
Overall, the paper addresses a practically relevant problem and provides encouraging evidence that advantage construction can influence RL performance.
Critical strengths
- The paper investigates an important problem in process-supervised reinforcement learning: how to convert dense process feedback into effective advantages, rather than focusing solely on obtaining more accurate process rewards. The joint consideration of reward normalization, credit-assignment granularity, and future reward accumulation provides a clear and practically relevant perspective on advantage construction.
- PASS achieves higher average pass@1 than outcome-only GRPO across all seven mathematical reasoning benchmarks, with an overall improvement of 4.62 percentage points and a slight reduction in average response length.
- The authors evaluate PASS with both PRM-based step-level rewards in mathematics and teacher-derived token-level signals from OPD and G-OPD in multi-hop QA. They also investigate the influence of different normalization schemes.
Critical weaknesses
1.limited comparison with existing methods. For example, Step-GRPO[1] also investigates the incorporation of step-level PRM feedback into GRPO to improve mathematical reasoning quality and efficiency. Although its specific mechanism differs from PASS, the two methods address closely related problems, making Step-GRPO a relevant point of comparison.
The multi-hop QA experiments include Process-only and AF-only controls, but these are primarily internal ablations constructed by the authors. The GR3-style control is also an adaptation of an existing method rather than a direct comparison with its complete original implementation.
Consequently, the current results demonstrate advantages over outcome-only GRPO and several simplified configurations, but do not adequately establish the benefits of PASS relative to existing approaches for process-supervised policy optimization.
- limited justification and empirical validation of the Chunk-by-Value (CV) mechanism.
Different responses may be at entirely different reasoning stages at the same token position. Consequently, changes in the shared positional mean do not necessarily correspond to meaningful credit-assignment boundaries for individual trajectories. Moreover, when responses have different lengths, the set of responses contributing to the positional mean changes as shorter responses terminate. This can introduce chunk boundaries even when the reward traces of individual responses remain constant.
The paper also does not report empirical chunk counts, chunk-length distributions, boundary stability, or direct comparisons between segmentation strategies. It is therefore unclear whether CV provides more effective advantages than the original PRM step boundaries, response-specific segmentation, or simpler fixed-length chunking.
[1] Step-GRPO: Enhancing Reasoning Quality and Efficiency via Structured PRM-Based Reinforcement Learning
Questions for authors
- Why do the mathematics experiments primarily use outcome-only GRPO as the baseline, without comparisons to existing process-supervised RL approaches such as Step-GRPO? Does PASS retain its advantages under matched actor, PRM, and training-budget settings?
- How many chunks does CV produce per response in practice? To what extent do shared boundaries align with process-score transitions in individual responses? What fraction of valid tokens receives zero advantage because no terminal endpoint is retained?
- Could the authors provide component-wise ablations to isolate the effects of CV, RTG, and DL? In particular, how much improvement does full PASS provide over simple reward fusion or direct RTG when using the same process signal and normalization scheme?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer 8V3k (2/3)
W2/Q2 - Shared boundaries and their justification
CV defines shared computational units for credit accumulation; it does not assume that equal token positions represent equal semantic reasoning stages. Native PRM steps specify where local evaluations are produced. CV instead derives a common partition from changes in the masked positional mean of the fused score traces, then uses those units for return-to-go accumulation and residual-count normalization. This separates scoring granularity from accumulation granularity.
Your observations about individual changes cancelling and the active-response set changing are correct. They characterize the approximation introduced by this shared partition. We have clarified them in the discussion rather than treating numerical boundaries as recovered semantic stages.
A supplementary diagnostic shows that the shared partition retains over 80% of native PRM boundaries. In a separate single-seed PASS run covering all 1,248 training steps, native-boundary recall is 82.13%. Recall divides the intersection of retained CV endpoints and native PRM endpoints by the native endpoint count, averaged over eligible responses within each step and then over steps. This suggests that CV can preserve much of the native scoring structure while introducing additional accumulation units. It is preliminary evidence about structure preservation, not semantic alignment or batch stability. This diagnostic is reported separately from the three-seed experiments; definitions of both overlap directions are in Appendix I.
The controlled learning comparison tests whether these units are useful. With the PRM, AF, RTG, and DL held fixed, native PRM-step accumulation yields 33.44 average pass@1, versus 36.39 for CV PASS: +2.95 pp, with 2.5% shorter outputs. Thus this estimator's benefit does not depend on generating more tokens. The intervention changes endpoint selection and accumulation units together; it does not independently identify the effects of shared coordinates and reward adaptivity.
For the practical granularity and coverage questions, the three-seed training diagnostics show approximately 132 retained endpoints per response, a mean chunk length of 7.25 tokens, and an uncovered tail of approximately 0.15% of valid tokens. Tokens after the last retained endpoint receive zero direct advantage; if no endpoint is retained, this advantage path is zero throughout. Reference regularization remains separate. Full distributions, masking, and aggregation details are in Appendices B and I.
The resulting answer is that semantic stage alignment is not required by CV's computational objective; the diagnostic provides initial evidence that native scoring boundaries are substantially retained, and the controlled comparison supports practical learning value. Boundary stability and the detailed origins of additional endpoints remain open properties, rather than conclusions inferred from tail coverage.
Manuscript changes: Section 4.2 explains the computational objective and broadcasting rule; Section 6 interprets the shared-coordinate approximation and briefly notes the supplementary recall result. Appendix I reports the single-seed diagnostic separately from Table 21 and Figure 5's three-seed analysis. Appendix B specifies the actual endpoint and zero-tail rules.
Response to Reviewer 8V3k (3/3)
Q3 - Component contributions
The gains extend beyond adding process feedback and fusion: accumulation units and remaining-horizon scaling each have substantial conditional effects. Native-step RTG is closely related to the future-step accumulation already used in DeepSeekMath's process-supervised GRPO. Our controls retain common AF, normalization, and training settings to test CV and DL; they do not reproduce DeepSeekMath's original training recipe.
On mathematics, AF direct scores 18.73, native-step RTG 20.89, and full PASS 36.39 average pass@1. The more discriminating comparisons hold other estimator settings fixed:
| Changed | Fixed | Δ mean pass@1 | Δ mean tokens |
|---|---|---|---|
| Native PRM steps → CV | RTG+DL | +2.95 pp | −2.5% |
| Add DL | CV+RTG | +3.17 pp | −10.8% |
The deltas above are differences between configuration means; they do not report an SD of paired seed-level differences. These comparisons connect the benefit to credit construction while improving, rather than spending more, output tokens. Full PASS has the highest mean in the mathematics matrix, but the marginal gains overlap: native → CV gains 12.32 pp without DL and 2.95 with DL; adding DL gains 12.55 under native segmentation and 3.17 under CV. The effects are conditional and cannot be added as independent contributions. The experiment does not separately establish why their benefits overlap or prove a particular synergy mechanism.
The OPD controls test the construction with token-varying teacher feedback and reveal a metric-dependent accuracy–length trade-off. With CV fixed, adding RTG gains 2.96 pp, and adding DL then gains 0.65 pp. Comparing the complete CV and token estimators gives:
| Metric | CV PASS | Token RTG+DL |
|---|---|---|
| pass@1 (%) | 58.22 ± 0.22 | 58.41 ± 0.56 |
| pass@8 (%) | 72.07 ± 0.13 | 71.04 ± 0.32 |
| pass@16 (%) | 74.99 ± 0.10 | 73.70 ± 0.40 |
| Response tokens | 281.0 ± 16.4 | 335.0 ± 70.3 |
Token accumulation slightly favors pass@1. CV PASS has higher pass@8/16 on each of the three benchmarks and shorter outputs on each, averaging 16.1% fewer tokens. Its lower observed pass@1 seed SD is supplementary descriptive evidence. Thus CV improves accuracy and length relative to native PRM-step accumulation in mathematics, while offering higher multi-sample success and shorter outputs at slightly lower pass@1 with token-derived feedback.
All matched configurations use three independent training seeds. Evaluation macro scores first average benchmarks equally within seed, then report the cross-seed mean and sample SD; the QA table reports these statistics for every metric, with response lengths retokenized from saved outputs. These statistics are distinct from the time-then-seed aggregation of training diagnostics.
Manuscript changes: Section 5.1 and Table 3 integrate the mathematics controls; Section 5.2 analyzes the OPD ablations. Appendix H, Tables 13–20, provides the full per-benchmark pass@1/8/16 and response lengths, and Section 6 discusses conditional effects and the cross-signal trade-off.
Follow-up: Fixed-Length Segmentation Control
We have completed an additional three-seed mathematics experiment to further address the reviewer's concern about whether CV's gains can be explained by changes in accumulation granularity alone.
As stated in W2: "... more effective advantages than the original PRM step boundaries, response-specific segmentation, or simpler fixed-length chunking."
Keeping the PRM, AF, RTG, DL, and training configuration unchanged, we replace CV's reward-adaptive endpoint detection with a fixed 8-token grid, retaining each response's native PRM boundaries and final endpoint. The resulting partition uses the union of these endpoints, so individual chunks can be shorter than eight tokens.
Importantly, the fixed-grid control yields an observed mean chunk length of 7.10 tokens, closely matching CV's 7.25 tokens, under the same three-seed training-diagnostic aggregation protocol. This provides a simple, reward-independent grid refinement at comparable average accumulation granularity.
The seven-benchmark pass@1 results (%) are shown below. All entries report mean ± sample standard deviation across three independent training seeds. Average is computed by first taking the benchmark-equal mean within each seed and then aggregating across seeds, consistent with the manuscript.
| Benchmark | Native PRM-step RTG+DL | Fixed-grid RTG+DL (8-token interval) | PASS (CV+RTG+DL) |
|---|---|---|---|
| AIME24 | 15.45 ± 0.77 | 16.04 ± 0.54 | 16.84 ± 1.17 |
| AIME25 | 6.67 ± 0.36 | 8.99 ± 0.32 | 9.51 ± 0.30 |
| AMC23 | 51.51 ± 1.70 | 53.23 ± 1.40 | 55.86 ± 1.09 |
| GSM8K | 71.99 ± 1.43 | 75.93 ± 0.57 | 76.91 ± 1.72 |
| MATH | 51.58 ± 0.72 | 54.70 ± 0.37 | 55.44 ± 1.00 |
| Minerva | 26.54 ± 0.49 | 28.01 ± 0.91 | 28.39 ± 0.93 |
| OlympiadBench | 10.33 ± 0.26 | 11.49 ± 0.28 | 11.78 ± 0.34 |
| Average | 33.44 ± 0.66 | 35.48 ± 0.34 | 36.39 ± 0.54 |
The fixed-grid control improves over native PRM-step accumulation by 2.04 percentage points, demonstrating that finer accumulation granularity itself provides substantial benefits. Importantly, CV achieves a further 0.91 pp improvement over fixed-grid segmentation at comparable observed mean chunk length, with higher mean pass@1 on all seven benchmarks.
These results provide additional empirical evidence that CV's reward-adaptive partition offers learning benefits beyond a simple fixed-grid refinement of the accumulation units.
We thank the reviewer for motivating this additional controlled comparison.
Response to Reviewer 8V3k (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the detailed assessment and concrete questions regarding comparisons with existing methods, the justification of shared credit units, and component contributions. In response, we have added controlled comparisons and diagnostic evidence, and revised the manuscript to clarify our methodological choices and their limitations. We address these concerns in the following three parts.
Thank you for identifying the need for an external comparison and more direct tests of credit construction. We address these separately: Step-GRPO tests effectiveness relative to a related method; internal controls test the value of PASS's particular credit units and normalization. PASS retains an accuracy advantage over Step-GRPO under the same actor, PRM, data, and training budget.
With Qwen2.5-Math-7B, Qwen2.5-Math-PRM-7B, and DeepScaleR, average pass@1 is 36.39 ± 0.54 for PASS versus 30.00 ± 2.66 for Step-GRPO, a gain of 6.39 percentage points (pp). PASS has higher mean accuracy on all seven mathematics benchmarks. These are benchmark-equal averages within each training seed, followed by mean ± sample SD across three independent training seeds.
This comparison extends the evidence beyond outcome-only GRPO and internal simplified configurations. It also entails an accuracy–length trade-off: PASS averages 863.7 response tokens versus 435.9 for Step-GRPO. Both methods use the same training environment but retain their respective reward/advantage constructions, so the full difference cannot be attributed to CV alone. The implementation settings, including Step-GRPO's trajectory-reward construction, are specified with the training protocol in Appendix H.
A complementary internal comparison addresses the concern that the gains might simply require longer generation. Holding the PRM, fusion, RTG, and DL fixed, replacing native PRM-step accumulation with CV improves accuracy while shortening responses. Thus the external comparison establishes a benefit relative to an existing method, while the controlled comparison tests a specific design choice; the two serve different evidential purposes.
The GR$^3$-style experiment serves a different purpose: with the AF front end fixed, it tests whether simple post-fusion length rescaling suffices. As detailed in Appendix G, our implementation applies the length factor to AF-fused token advantages, without CV or RTG; the original method rescales raw rewards before group normalization. These operations are not equivalent, and this is not an ablation that changes DL alone. We therefore limit its conclusion to this implementation; the added Step-GRPO experiment supplies the external process-supervised method comparison.
Manuscript changes: Section 2 clarifies the method relationships. Step-GRPO appears in Section 5.1, Table 3, with full mathematics results in Appendix H, Tables 13–16. GR$^3$-style appears in Section 5.2, Table 4, with its configuration and rescaling rule in Appendix G, Table 12 and the accompanying text.