- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on the Generalized Category Discovery field and aims to enhance pseudo-text representations by transferring fine-grained visual attribute semantics into the textual space. This paper proposes a plug-and-play framework named TransGCD which introduces two complementary techniques, termed Object-centric Semantic Decomposition (OSD) and Attribute-guided Semantic Injection (ASI). The OSD module decomposes visual representations into complementary object-centric attributes, which are subsequently injected into the text encoder by the ASI module to generate fine-grained pseudo-text representations.
Critical strengths
The research motivation of this paper is clear, and the problem is worthy of further investigation. In recent years, GCD research has increasingly shifted its attention from unimodal visual learning (e.g., SimGCD) toward multimodal learning (e.g.,GET). However, existing pseudo-text representations are mainly derived from global visual features and often overlook fine-grained semantic information. Therefore, investigating how to effectively incorporate fine-grained visual semantics into pseudo-text representations is meaningful and worthwhile.
Critical weaknesses
- Numerical inconsistencies in Table 3. The reported improvements in Table 3 are inconsistent with the corresponding baseline and full-model results. Specifically, the improvement on CUB should be 2.5 (87.9 − 85.4), rather than the reported 2.4. Similarly, the improvement on FGVC-Aircraft should be 3.5 (69.9 − 66.4), rather than 3.6. The authors should clarify whether these discrepancies result from rounding or calculation errors and ensure the numerical consistency of the reported results.
- Computing overhead is not discussed. The authors should report the additional parameters, FLOPs, training time, and inference time compared with the baselines to demonstrate whether the performance improvements justify the extra computational overhead.
- The ablation studies are incomplete. The discussion about the loss functions , ,,and$L_{sem}$ is not provided.
- Table 3 is not referenced in the main text. The authors should explicitly refer to Table 3 when discussing the effectiveness of different components in Section 4.3.
Questions for authors
- The numerical inconsistencies in Table 3 raise concerns about the reliability of the reported experimental results. Could the authors clarify the reasons for these inconsistencies?
- Due to the lack of ablation studies on the proposed loss functions, their individual effectiveness and necessity are not sufficiently demonstrated. Could the authors provide additional ablation experiments to further validate the contributions of these loss functions?