- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes WBPrior for image retrieval using the 2-Wasserstein barycenter. The authors argue that the conventional weighted averaging approach has difficulty in handling severe appearance changes. In this context, they propose to model each image patch as a diagonal Gaussian and compute the 2-Wasserstein barycenter of the patches, preserving both mean and learned scale information. Such mean and scale are more informative and thus facilitate the subsequent image retrieval. Experiments across multiple applications such as drone-to-satellite geo-localization and sketch-based image retrieval show promising results and improved robustness.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents an interesting and promising approach to robust image retrieval. The idea of leveraging Gaussian and 2-Wasserstein barycenter appears to be reasonable. It yields additional information beyond conventional mean pooling, potentially improving feature discrimination under significant appearance changes.
- The authors derive a closed-form solution that avoids expensive iterative optimal transport computations. This design allows the proposed representation to be incorporated into existing retrieval frameworks with relatively low overhead.
- The proposed method achieves competitive performance across multiple retrieval benchmarks. Experiments demonstrate that replacing conventional slot-mean aggregation with the Wasserstein barycenter leads to improved performance. The authors also conduct ablation studies that investigate the contributions of the learned scale vector and the proposed aggregation strategy.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation for adopting Gaussian distributions and 2-Wasserstein barycenters is not sufficiently convincing. The main idea is to preserve additional information beyond the mean feature. However, it is unclear why modeling patch features as Gaussian distributions and aggregating them using a 2-Wasserstein barycenter is particularly necessary for this purpose. Moreover, the predicted Gaussian variances are learned features rather than empirical feature statistics or calibrated uncertainties.
- The authors provide comparisons with alternative aggregation strategies, but the improvement over conventional Euclidean aggregation is relatively modest. For instance, As shown in Table 19, Euclidean (Frobenius) achieves much better performance than slot mean, but the improvement of WBPRIOR over Euclidean (Frobenius) is relatively minor. This raises the question of whether the additional mathematical formulation is truly necessary, or whether a simpler learned representation with appropriate feature aggregation could achieve comparable performance.
- The comparisons with recent SOTA methods appear incomplete. Several relevant approaches [1, 2] are missing from the evluations. Comparisons with these recent approaches would strengthen the experimental evaluations.
[1] Zixuan Song, Jing Zhang, Di Wang, Zidie Zhou, Wenbin Liu, Haonan Guo, En Wang, and Bo Du. "Geobridge: A semantic-anchored multi-view foundation model bridging images and text for geo-localization." In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, pp. 27793-27803. 2026.
[2] Minglei Li, Mengfan He, Chunyu Li, Chao Chen, Xingyu Shao, and Ziyang Meng. "(MGS) -Net: Unifying Micro-Geometric Scale and Macro-Geometric Structure for Cross-View Geo-Localization." arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.10704 (2026).
Questions for authors
Please refer to my concerns in Weaknesses.
3 comments
I thank the authors for the response and for the additional experiments. Some of my concerns have been addressed. However, according to the added comparisons, it seems that the introduced method performs worse than MGS²-Net. The authors argue that MGS²-Net is a larger model, but this is not very convincing. Since I am not an expert in this domain, I would like to highlight this concern for the consideration of the ACs and other reviewers, and I will keep my original rating.
Follow-up: accuracy under corruption and (MGS)²-Net code availability
Thank you for reading our response carefully, for keeping your positive rating, and for sharing your view openly with the AC. We are glad that the new experiments resolved most of your concerns. The remaining point is the comparison with (MGS)²-Net. We would like to set out three facts, because they limit what this comparison can show.
1. The paper's claim is accuracy under corruption, and (MGS)²-Net reports no such result.
WBPrior is a part representation for retrieval under severe corruption. The central results of the paper measure accuracy under nine severe corruptions:
| Evidence | What changes | Corrupt(9) R@1 gain |
|---|---|---|
| Tab. 1, matched study | slot mean replaced by the W2 part | +8.19 pp |
| Tab. 2, seven published hosts | WBPrior branch added to each host | +3.62 to +8.63 pp |
| Five-seed study, sensor noise | Euclidean averaging replaced by the barycenter | +2.01 pp |
For standalone clean accuracy, the abstract claims only that WBPrior is "competitive with recent systems". The two methods sit side by side as follows:
| Method | Input | SUES-200 clean R@1 | U-1652 clean R@1 | Under corruption |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WBPrior (ours) | RGB, ViT-S/14 | 98.32 | 94.86 | nine conditions reported |
| (MGS)²-Net | RGB + depth, DINOv2-B | 99.46 | 97.60 | not reported |
We agree that (MGS)²-Net is more accurate on clean images, as our earlier reply stated. Whether it also holds up better under corruption is unknown. On the question this paper asks, the two methods have therefore not been compared yet.
2. The comparison cannot be run today, and we correct one sentence of our earlier reply.
Our earlier reply said that public code and checkpoints exist for both baselines. For (MGS)²-Net this is wrong, and we apologise for the error. The official repository linked from its arXiv page has been empty since it was created in February 2026: it holds no code and no trained model, and we found no released model elsewhere. Nobody can evaluate (MGS)²-Net under corruption until the authors release it.
For GeoBridge, only a pre-training checkpoint is public, with no model trained on University-1652. Used as released, it reaches 7.10% clean R@1 on University-1652. After our fine-tuning it reaches 38.94%, far below the published 95.82%. We do not consider either number a fair stand-in for GeoBridge, and this is why we quote published clean results instead of unverified reproductions.
3. The clean gap is small, and the inputs differ.
On SUES-200 the gap is 1.14 pp, with both methods close to the ceiling. (MGS)²-Net adds depth maps from a second foundation model (Depth Anything 3) to a DINOv2-B backbone, and evaluates at 336 px. WBPrior uses RGB images only, with a ViT-S/14 encoder and 23.4M parameters in total. We do not offer model size as an excuse. Our point is that extra depth input can raise clean accuracy, but it tells us nothing about accuracy under sensor noise, blur or geometric change, which is what WBPrior targets.
The two methods can also be combined. WBPrior attaches to an existing retriever, and Tab. 2 shows that it raises accuracy under corruption on seven published hosts. Once (MGS)²-Net is released, adding WBPrior to it is a natural experiment, and we will report it in the final version if the code becomes available in time.
For the AC, we also note that (MGS)²-Net is an arXiv preprint (February 2026) without a peer-reviewed venue. The ICLR reviewer guidelines state that arXiv is not a peer-reviewed venue and that authors are not required to compare with papers that appear only on arXiv. We added it because you asked, and we will keep it in Tab. 3 with the context above.
You mention that some of your concerns were addressed. If any point other than (MGS)²-Net is still open, we would be grateful to hear it, so that we can answer it before the discussion period ends. Thank you again for your time and your constructive review.
Response to Reviewer oA2d: why the learned scale matters, five-seed Euclidean study, and recent methods
Thank you for the careful review and for raising these points. We have conducted additional experiments to clarify the role of the learned scale and the choice of aggregation. We also include two recent methods in our comparison, together with an analysis of their model sizes and available evaluation results. Our responses are detailed below.
W1. Why Gaussians and the 2-Wasserstein barycenter
Reviewer concern: It is not clear why information beyond the mean is needed, and the predicted variances are learned features, not statistics or calibrated uncertainties.
Ans. We agree that the predicted variance is a learned feature rather than calibrated uncertainty (Sec. 3.2). When two parts have similar feature means, their learned scales provide an additional dimension to distinguish them. We use diagonal Gaussians as a lightweight representation for which the W₂ distance and barycenter admit simple closed-form expressions (Eq. 1):
W₂²(N(μ₁, diag v₁), N(μ₂, diag v₂)) = ‖μ₁ - μ₂‖² + ‖√v₁ - √v₂‖²
In Tab. 1, replacing the slot mean with the W2 part raises Corrupt(9) R@1 from 50.93% to 59.12% (+8.19 pp, paired 95% CI [+7.17, +9.24]). A matched head with the same capacity but no Gaussian structure (App. A5.3) trails by 4.87 pp under corruption, suggesting that the improvement cannot be explained by parameter count alone.
W2. Is the barycenter needed over Euclidean aggregation?
Reviewer concern: The gain over Euclidean aggregation (Tab. 19) is small. Would a simpler representation with suitable aggregation do as well?
Ans. The Euclidean (Frobenius) row in Tab. 19 is an ablation of the same Gaussian representation: it retains the learned scale but averages variances rather than standard deviations. Its large margin over slot mean confirms the benefit of learned scale. For aggregation, W₂ geometry averages standard deviations in closed form. By contrast, variance averaging produces a larger aggregate scale whenever patch scales differ, by Jensen's inequality. Because the two rules respond differently to dispersion among patch scales, we hypothesized that their differences would be visible under sensor corruption. We tested this in a 5-seed paired study on SUES-200 (identical backbone, heads, assignment, losses, and schedule):
At the seed level, the barycenter shows a significant gain under sensor noise (+2.01 pp, paired t(4) p = 0.0096, seed CI [+0.81, +3.20]; Bonferroni-adjusted p < 0.03 across three groups). On clean data, the gain is small (+0.30 pp) with CI crossing zero. Across all nine corruptions, the gain is not significant at the 5% level (p = 0.053, winning on 4 of 5 seeds). The results therefore indicate a specific empirical advantage under the tested sensor-noise condition, rather than uniform superiority across all corruptions. The closed-form barycenter adds zero parameters and negligible O(d) compute. This 5-seed study (224 px, 30 epochs, D→S, 16k queries) will be added to the appendix.
W3. GeoBridge and (MGS)²-Net
Ans. Both will be added to Tab. 3 of the final version:
WBPrior uses 23.4M parameters and 22.14 GFLOPs, roughly 13x smaller than GeoBridge's visual encoder (≥304M) and 5x smaller than (MGS)²-Net (115.6M total). It beats GeoBridge on SUES-200 (98.32% vs 97.26%). (MGS)²-Net achieves higher clean accuracy on both datasets, and GeoBridge on University-1652, though differences in input resolution (448 px vs 224/336 px), pretraining, and architecture prevent attributing this to backbone alone. SUES-200 results average the four altitudes; (MGS)²-Net cites arXiv v2 (Tab. 2).
Neither baseline reports corruption evaluations under our protocol. Although public code and checkpoints exist, we could not establish a controlled reproduction matching their reported clean numbers under our exact benchmark and preprocessing protocol. To avoid misleading comparisons from unverified reproductions, we report their published clean results instead.
References
[R1] Z. Song et al. GeoBridge: A Semantic-Anchored Multi-View Foundation Model Bridging Images and Text for Geo-Localization. CVPR, 2026.
[R2] M. Li et al. (MGS)²-Net: Unifying Micro-Geometric Scale and Macro-Geometric Structure for Cross-View Geo-Localization. arXiv 2602.10704, 2026.