L1: The contribution of individual components could be isolated more clearly.
The idea of independently encoding region canvases is interesting. However, the comparison with TextRegion changes several things at once, including cropping, resizing, background treatment and independent encoding. The authors also acknowledge that their experiments do not isolate the effect of attention locality.
Since the paper argues that the region representation is the main source of improvement, it would be helpful to include a few controlled ablations on CLIP and SigLIP2 that separate these factors, for example:
● plain proposal crops without background blur;
● background blur applied to the full image without cropping.
This would make it easier to understand which components contribute most to the gains, and would strengthen the explanation for why LoCaR works.
L2: The benchmarking could be strengthened with additional relevant methods.
TextRegion is a useful direct baseline, but the evaluation could benefit from additional comparisons with recent methods for small-object or instance-level retrieval. SORCE, which the paper already cites, seems particularly relevant. Could the authors consider evaluating on SORCE-1K or comparing with other suitable retrieval methods where the protocols are compatible?
The Qwen results also need to be interpreted carefully. A matched TextRegion baseline is unavailable, and Qwen uses plain proposal crops rather than the background-blurred canvases used with CLIP and SigLIP2. A clearer discussion of these differences would help establish the scope of the claims about performance across backbones.
L3: A few numerical claims and statements should be clarified.
Some reported gain ranges do not appear to match the results in Table 1:
● CLIP. The fused LoCaR+ gains over standalone global retrieval are 2.42, 4.90 and 6.15 percentage points at R@1, R@5 and R@10, respectively, rather than the stated range of 2.40-6.05 pp.
● Qwen. The stated range of 9.13-11.69 pp excludes the reported R@5 gain of 12.29 pp.
● Conclusion. The conclusion's range of 2.40-9.13 pp does not match either; even at R@1 alone, the gains are 2.42-9.13 pp. It would help to specify the metric and correct the lower endpoint.
The Qwen gains also deserve a note. They are measured against standalone global retrieval (20.17 R@1), but the global channel actually used in fusion reaches 26.48 R@1 (Appendix A.2). Compared with this matched global channel, fused LoCaR+ achieves an improvement of 2.82 pp at R@1. Reporting this matched comparison in the introduction would give readers a clearer picture of the benefit of combining global and regional scores.
There is also a mismatch in the statement that paired support improves all three fused metrics for every backbone. For SigLIP2, fused R@1 and R@5 decrease slightly when support is added, although R@10 improves. It would be good to correct these statements and report paired confidence intervals or suitable significance tests for the main comparisons, particularly against TextRegion. This would help readers judge the reliability of the smaller improvements.
L4: The novelty could be positioned more clearly.
The canvas construction draws on existing ideas such as proposal cropping and background blurring in ReCLIP and FGVP. The combination may still be useful for gallery-level retrieval, but it would help if the authors more clearly explained what is new beyond adapting these existing ideas to this setting.
Related to this, Table 1 shows that unadapted region-only retrieval stays below global retrieval at every rank for all three backbones, so the practical benefit comes from fusing region and global scores. For CLIP, the advantage of the canvas representation over TextRegion largely disappears after fusion. Without paired support, fused TextRegion slightly outperforms LoCaR at R@1 (17.44 vs. 17.38), and with paired support, LoCaR+ leads TextRegion+ by only 0.05 pp (17.57 vs. 17.52). Framing LoCaR explicitly as a complementary channel to global retrieval, and discussing when the canvas representation matters most, would make the contribution more convincing.
Minor Weaknesses:
● Proposal selection and caching: The paper scores only the first 32 proposals per image, although the cache may contain embeddings for additional proposals. Could the authors clarify:
○ how proposals are ordered;
○ why the extra embeddings are stored;
○ whether encoding only the proposals used in the standard setup would reduce preprocessing cost?
The additional proposals may be useful for the cap ablation, so clarifying this trade-off would help.
● Hyperparameter and result clarity: The selected settings for K, γ, α and the support IoU threshold could be consolidated into one table for easier reproduction. It would also help to identify the backbone and configuration used for Table 10, and to clarify how its results relate to the corresponding experiments in Table 2.
● Background treatment: In Table 3, white-fill backgrounds give slightly better fused results than blur, although blur gives better standalone region retrieval. This also holds in the comparison without paired support, where both settings use the same fusion weight (e.g., 26.29 vs. 25.99 fused R@1). Since fused retrieval is the main reported metric, could the authors clarify why blur is kept as the default?
Thank you for asking for a direct retrieval comparison and a plain-crop control. We ran both on RefCOCOg. ReCLIP’s two-view scorer gives the strongest region R@1 on both backbones, and plain crops outperform the submitted blurred crops on region R@1. These results clarify what the visual representation contributes and what paired support adds at test time.
W1. Contribution beyond visual prompting. ReCLIP and FGVP established visual prompting techniques that we build on. LoCaR+ adds paired-support adaptation of the retrieval score at test time. A fixed bank stores matched referring expressions and visual regions. For a new query, we measure which support expressions it resembles. For each candidate region, we measure which visual exemplars it resembles. Agreement on the same support pairs adds evidence to the image score. Both encoders stay frozen, and the same residual applies to TextRegion or independently encoded crops.
Table 1 measures the adaptation increment by adding support to the same LoCaR representation. On CLIP, SigLIP2 and Qwen, respectively, support improves region R@1 by 0.67, 0.69 and 0.77 points and region R@10 by 1.77, 1.91 and 1.70 points. Fused R@1 changes by +0.19, −0.06 and +0.15 points. The most consistent benefit of paired support is in the regional score, particularly at R@10.
Q1. Direct comparison with ReCLIP and FGVP. For each of 9,602 expressions, we ranked the same 2,600 gallery images using matched SAM2 proposals, frozen backbones and query embeddings. Each method scores an image by its best proposal. Fused retrieval adds the same whole-image channel within each backbone. We disabled paired support for all methods to compare the visual prompts directly.
ReCLIP combines a tight RGB crop with a full-image view blurred outside the proposal box. We evaluate its isolated-proposal scorer with its spatial-relation rules disabled. FGVP preserves the mask foreground and blurs its surroundings in the full image. Submitted LoCaR applies mask-guided blur inside a padded crop. The table gives R@1 differences in percentage points. Positive values favor the first method.
On SigLIP2, ReCLIP improves on plain crop for region R@1 (paired McNemar p = 0.000008), while their fused difference is statistically unresolved (p = 0.26). LoCaR exceeds FGVP by about 5.1 region points on SigLIP2. On CLIP, LoCaR’s 0.99-point fused advantage over FGVP is significant (p = 0.0006). The 0.37-point fused gap between ReCLIP and LoCaR on CLIP has no direct paired test.
W2 / Q2. What the ablations isolate. The three SigLIP2 crop variants use identical proposals, 10% padding, 224 px inputs, encoder readout and fusion weight (α = 0.5), with support disabled. Only the treatment of pixels outside the proposal mask changes.
Plain crops already gain 18.76 region points over TextRegion. Blurring those same crops then costs 9.07 region points and about 1.6 fused points (fused R@1, paired McNemar p ≈ 3 × 10⁻⁷). Table 4 isolates the readout effect. Keeping the blurred canvas fixed and replacing the standard attention-pooled readout with mean patch pooling lowers region R@1 from 19.26% to 10.32%. The crop–TextRegion comparison still changes object scale, visible context and independent encoding together, so it cannot isolate attention locality.
On the proposal-matched 336 px CLIP run, plain crop gives the highest region R@1 of the four representations above, followed by within-crop blur, white fill and TextRegion. Their fused R@1 values span only 0.3 points, with no significant pairwise difference. Qwen uses plain RGB crops throughout, so its support-on versus support-off comparison measures adaptation on that representation. We will revise Section 4.5 to credit the gains already achieved by plain crops and report background suppression as an ablation.