acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Mitigating Efficiency-Induced Premature Stopping in Knowledge-Intensive Agentic Reasoning

Abstract

Agentic reasoning is essential for knowledge-intensive tasks, where models must iteratively decide whether to continue reasoning, call a tool to retrieve external evidence, or produce an answer. However, these models often engage in lengthy deliberation before taking an action, substantially increasing token cost and latency without making meaningful progress. Existing test-time efficient methods mainly rely on efficiency-oriented early stopping, which may terminate reasoning before a necessary tool call and lead to severe performance degradation. To address this efficiency-induced premature termination, we propose OPERA, a lightweight test-time framework that uses only the reasoning model to reduce redundant deliberation while preserving productive reasoning. OPERA uses hierarchical action probing to assess whether the model is ready to take the next action, and identifies potential verbosity on-the-fly to estimate when to probe. It terminates reasoning only when probes consistently support the same action. Extensive experiments across knowledge-intensive benchmarks show that OPERA consistently reduces token usage while preserving or improving answer accuracy and more effectively mitigates premature termination than baselines.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Agentic reasoning, Efficient inference

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_qMDmOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes OPERA, a test-time framework for improving the efficiency of knowledge-intensive agentic reasoning while mitigating premature stopping. The method introduces consensus-based hierarchical action probing to assess the consistency of action types and contents, along with on-the-fly probe-timing estimation to reduce unnecessary probing. Experiments across multiple knowledge-intensive benchmarks demonstrate token savings while largely preserving or improving answer accuracy.

Critical strengths
  1. The motivation is clear and well presented. Addressing premature stopping in agentic reasoning is practically meaningful, particularly for tasks requiring external information retrieval.
  2. The method is intuitive and training-free. OPERA does not require additional models or training, making it relatively easy to apply to existing reasoning systems.
  3. The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, including comparisons with multiple baselines, ablation studies, and analyses of retrieval quality and probing behavior.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The reliability of action consistency as a stopping criterion remains unclear. Consistent action predictions do not necessarily indicate that the model is ready to act, as multiple probes may agree on an incorrect or incomplete search query.
  2. The actual inference efficiency is not sufficiently evaluated. Although the paper reports token savings, OPERA introduces additional probing operations that may incur non-negligible computational overhead. End-to-end latency measurements would better demonstrate its practical efficiency.
Questions for authors
  1. How reliable is action consistency as a proxy for action readiness? Could the authors provide further analysis of cases where the probes reach consensus but the selected action is incorrect or premature?
  2. How much wall-clock time does OPERA actually save? Given the additional action-type and content probing, it would be helpful to report end-to-end inference latency alongside token consumption.
  3. How sensitive is OPERA to its probing hyperparameters? For example, how do the number of probes CC, consensus threshold η\eta, and content similarity threshold τ\tau affect the accuracy–efficiency trade-off?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (1/2)

W1. The reliability of… & Q1. How reliable…

We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. OPERA performs hierarchical action probing and probe-timing estimation on-the-fly at test time, without relying on external evaluation models or ground-truth correctness labels. Since action correctness and the necessity of continuing reasoning cannot be directly verified under the unsupervised setting, OPERA takes inspiration from prior work using answer stabilization [1-2] and uses consensus across multiple probe points as a proxy for the stability of the model's intended next action.

To evaluate the reliability of action consensus-based stopping, we conduct a continuation analysis across all five benchmarks and compare the answers produced at early-stopping points with those obtained by allowing reasoning to continue. We also include representative baselines REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT to directly compare the frequency of premature stopping and the benefits of avoiding unnecessary continuation. The results are summarized below:

ModelMethodIncorrect StopCorrect Stop
Qwen3-4BOPERA4.62%6.08%
REFRAIN8.38%4.25%
Qwen3-8BOPERA6.77%7.18%
Dynasor-CoT8.93%6.40%

The results show that OPERA prevents more harmful continuations than it misses beneficial corrections. Specifically, correct stops account for 6.08% and 7.18% of cases, exceeding incorrect stops at 4.62% and 6.77%. This gives accuracy advantages of 1.46 and 0.41 percentage points over continued reasoning and suggests that OPERA effectively avoids unnecessary deliberation. In contrast, REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT show higher incorrect-stop rates than correct-stop rates, which indicates a greater tendency toward premature termination of productive reasoning. These provide empirical evidence that OPERA's consensus-based stopping mitigates premature termination while identifying genuine redundancy.

W2. The actual… & Q2. & How much…

We thank the reviewer for suggesting wall-clock runtime analysis. We agree that decoded-token savings alone do not fully mean inference efficiency considering the additional probing operations of OPERA. To address this concern, we measure the end-to-end inference wall-clock runtime of OPERA against vanilla agentic reasoning on the NQ dataset including the overhead of all probing operations. The results are shown below:

ModelMethodTotal RuntimeAvg. Decoded TokensTime/1K Tokens (Seconds)
Qwen3-4BVanilla Agentic Reasoning4:46:582,125.652.24
OPERA4:05:141,874.102.17
Qwen3-8BVanilla Agentic Reasoning2:21:05615.243.81
OPERA2:03:53555.283.71

OPERA achieves consistent wall-clock runtime improvements across both model sizes. Specifically, OPERA reduces end-to-end runtime by 14.54% on Qwen3-4B and 12.19% on Qwen3-8B, while reducing average decoded-token usage by 11.83% and 9.75%. These results show that OPERA's token efficiency improvements turn into practical wall-clock savings across different model sizes. This direct translation from token reductions to runtime savings is because OPERA requires no external scoring models, and the token reported in our paper includes all probe tokens.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (2/2)

Q3. How sensitive…

We thank the reviewer for suggesting a sensitivity analysis of OPERA's probing hyperparameters. To evaluate their impact on accuracy and token efficiency, we conduct additional experiments by varying the number of probes (CC), consensus threshold (η\eta), and content similarity threshold (τ\tau), while keeping other settings fixed:

Probe CountEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
CC = 425.93555.28
CC = 626.20596.76
CC = 825.84619.89
CC = 1025.96648.00

Increasing the number of probes consistently increases token consumption, while EM remains relatively stable ranging from 25.84% to 26.20%. These results show that OPERA maintains robust accuracy across different probe counts, while additional probes introduce more decoding costs and stricter consensus requirements, which makes early stopping more difficult and thereby increases the average decoded tokens.

Consensus ThresholdEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
η\eta = 0.7527.26507.28
η\eta = 1.0025.93555.28

Here, η\eta denotes the majority-voting consensus threshold used in hierarchical action probing. Given the default probe count CC = 4 and η\eta > 0.5 (Eq.3), we evaluate both available majority-consensus levels: η\eta = 0.75 requiring agreement among at least three probes, and η\eta = 1.00 requiring agreement among all four probes. Relaxing the consensus threshold from 1.00 to 0.75 improves EM by 1.33 percentage points while reducing decoded-token usage by 8.64%. This suggests that allowing occasional disagreement among probes can enable earlier stopping without necessarily sacrificing accuracy.

Similarity ThresholdEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
τ\tau = 0.3027.23476.60
τ\tau = 0.5026.59494.65
τ\tau = 0.7026.26520.09
τ\tau = 0.9025.93555.28

The results show that OPERA maintains robust accuracy across different content similarity thresholds with EM ranging from 25.93 to 27.23. As τ\tau increases from 0.30 to 0.90, EM decreases modestly while average decoded-token usage increases, which reflects the more conservative stopping behavior induced by stricter content verification. Importantly, the stable EM accuracy suggests that OPERA is not sensitive to the choice of similarity threshold and remains robust across the tested settings.

Overall, these results show OPERA's robustness to different probing hyperparameters. EM remains stable across the tested configurations, while the variations in decoded-token usage reflect the expected behavior of the stopping mechanism, where more probes and stricter consistency requirements lead to more conservative stopping decisions. These findings highlight a consistent accuracy-efficiency trade-off across different hyperparameter settings, showing that OPERA maintains robust accuracy while allowing flexibility in reasoning efficiency.

[1] Fu, Y., et al. (2025). Efficiently Scaling LLM Reasoning Programs with Certaindex. NeurIPS.

[2] Liu, X., & Wang, L. (2025). Answer Convergence as a Signal for Early Stopping in Reasoning. EMNLP.

Reviewer_VG5BOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes OPERA to reduce lengthy deliberation before knowledge-intensive agents search or answer. At multiple prefixes of the reasoning trajectory, it first checks the next action type, then the consistency of query or answer content. When both checks pass, it ends the current thinking span and injects the action. The authors also use an online bandit with entropy-shift-weighted rewards to select the waiting length before the next probe, stating that the method requires no training or auxiliary evaluation models.

The authors evaluate two Qwen3 models on five QA and scientific reasoning benchmarks, reporting accuracy and total decoded tokens including probe generations. They also provide component ablations, retrieval analyses, and comparisons with an action-adapted Dynasor-Agentic baseline.

Critical strengths
  1. Action-aware early stopping has practical value. Extending probes from final answers to search or answer actions, with separate checks for action type and content, addresses the risk that premature answers prevent retrieval. Hierarchical action consensus and probe-delay control provide concrete methodological additions.

  2. The experiments support lower total decoding cost. In the main table, average token usage decreases by approximately 11.6%/27.1% on 4B/8B, while average EM increases by 0.50/1.07 percentage points. Table 2 includes Dynasor-Agentic with search/answer support; OPERA achieves higher mean accuracy with fewer tokens across the three tasks on both models. The timing ablation on 4B/GPQA-D also supports improvements in both accuracy and cost.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The explanation of the core mechanism and positioning of the incremental contribution remain insufficient. Neither consensus across adjacent prefixes nor the reward in Eq. (8) verifies action correctness or whether the omitted reasoning is necessary. The analyses do not establish the proposed explanation of identifying genuine redundancy and avoiding premature stopping. The cited and evaluated REFRAIN already combines two-stage discrimination with online SW-UCB; the paper needs to isolate the added benefits of hierarchical action probing and delay scheduling.

  2. Ablation specifications and cost comparisons limit the conclusions. The one-stage probing replacement, fixed probing interval, and content similarity function lack clear definitions. In Table 2, adding the scheduler increases total tokens in five of six settings; on 8B/GPQA-D, a 3.54-point accuracy gain uses approximately 8% more tokens. Without comparisons at comparable cost or estimates of run-to-run variability, the robustness of the gains remains unclear. Total decoded tokens alone also do not establish end-to-end speedups.

Questions for authors
  1. Please define content similarity for search/answer actions and the controller's state and feedback rules. Could you assess whether consensus corresponds to reliable stopping through premature-stopping statistics, continuations from intervention points, or similar tests?

  2. Please specify the one-stage and fixed-timing configurations, compare reasonable fixed intervals and representative baselines at comparable total decoding cost, and report run-to-run variability. If claiming practical speedups, please report end-to-end latency.

  3. Please clarify the methodological additions over REFRAIN and Dynasor, discuss DTSR, and explain the baseline selection in relation to the cited DEER and ThinkBrake. A representative comparison under comparable settings would suffice.

I would reconsider my score if these clarifications and comparisons support consistent gains at comparable cost.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (1/2)

W1. The explanation… & Q1. Please define…

We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. OPERA performs hierarchical action probing and probe-timing estimation on-the-fly at test time, without relying on external evaluation models or ground-truth correctness labels. Since action correctness and the necessity of continuing reasoning cannot be directly verified under the unsupervised setting, OPERA takes inspiration from prior work using answer stabilization [1-2] and uses consensus across multiple probe points as a proxy for the stability of the model's intended next action. Specifically, hierarchical action probing assesses the consistency of both the action type and its corresponding content, while the reward in Eq. (8) evaluates successful consensus verification with probing cost to guide when to probe.

For content verification, OPERA measures pairwise text similarity between the probed search queries or final answers, and assesses whether the candidate action contents achieve sufficient consensus. The probe-timing controller maintains recent rewards for each candidate probing interval as its state. After each probing attempt, it updates the rewards based on whether consensus-based stopping succeeds, the probing-token cost, and changes in reasoning uncertainty, then uses this feedback to determine when to probe next.

To further evaluate whether consensus provides a reliable stopping signal, we conduct a continuation analysis across all five benchmarks and compare the answers produced at early-stopping points with those obtained by allowing reasoning to continue. We also include representative baselines REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT to directly compare the frequency of premature stopping and the benefits of avoiding unnecessary continuation. The results are summarized below:

ModelMethodIncorrect StopCorrect Stop
Qwen3-4BOPERA4.62%6.08%
REFRAIN8.38%4.25%
Qwen3-8BOPERA6.77%7.18%
Dynasor-CoT8.93%6.40%

The results show that OPERA prevents more harmful continuations than it misses beneficial corrections. Specifically, correct stops account for 6.08% and 7.18% of cases, exceeding incorrect stops at 4.62% and 6.77%. This gives accuracy advantages of 1.46 and 0.41 percentage points (pp) over continued reasoning and suggests that OPERA effectively avoids unnecessary deliberation. In contrast, REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT show higher incorrect-stop rates than correct-stop rates, which indicates a greater tendency toward premature termination of productive reasoning. These provide empirical evidence that OPERA's consensus-based stopping mitigates premature termination while identifying genuine redundancy.

W1. The cited… & Q3. Please clarify…

We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to clarify OPERA's methodological contributions. REFRAIN uses two-stage discrimination to identify semantic redundancy with an external encoder and applies SW-UCB to adapt its stopping threshold, while OPERA uses prompt-based hierarchical probing to assess the intended action consensus and adaptively learns when to probe without external models. On the other hand, Dynasor relies on answer-consistency probing at fixed intervals, while OPERA verifies both search and answer actions and adaptively schedules probing to mitigate premature stopping. These distinctions are particularly important for knowledge-intensive agentic reasoning, where preserving necessary tool calls is critical.

To show the methodological distinctions, we summarize the key characteristics of existing approaches and OPERA below, and highlight OPERA's unique integration of action-aware stopping and feedback-adaptive probe-timing estimation on-the-fly:

MethodDoes It Use Prompt-Based Probing?Is It Free of External Scoring Model?Does It Adapt Probe Timing via Feedback?Is Stopping Action-Aware?What Is the Stopping Signal?
REFRAINNoNoNoNoSemantic redundancy
ThinkBrakeNoYesNoNoTermination-Token Probability
DynasorYesYesNoNoAnswer consistency
DTSRYesYesNoNoThought sufficiency
DEERYesYesNoNoTrial-Answer Confidence
OPERAYesYesYesYesAction Consensus

Regarding the baseline selections, our original baselines were selected to represent different categories of test-time efficient reasoning methods: external model-based redundancy detection (REFRAIN), fixed-interval answer probing (Dynasor), and probability-based stopping (HALT-CoT). Following the suggestions on baselines, we further compare OPERA with DTSR and ThinkBrake on NQ using three random seeds (0, 1, 2) following the common experimental practice [3-4], and report mean and standard deviation for both EM and total decoded tokens:

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (2/2)

ModelMethodEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
Qwen3-4BOPERA30.34 ± 0.421,886.87 ± 20.26
DTSR29.30 ± 0.352,124.78 ± 4.80
ThinkBrake29.34 ± 0.542,095.86 ± 8.31
Qwen3-8BOPERA26.26 ± 0.29556.75 ± 1.59
DTSR25.02 ± 0.27558.10 ± 3.33
ThinkBrake24.09 ± 0.37701.72 ± 5.65

OPERA consistently achieves higher EM with fewer decoded tokens across both model sizes. Specifically, on Qwen3-4B, it outperforms DTSR and ThinkBrake by 1.04 and 1.00 pp of EM, while reducing decoded tokens by 11.20% and 9.97%; on Qwen3-8B, OPERA improves EM by 1.24 and 2.17 pp, while using comparable tokens to DTSR and 20.66% fewer tokens than ThinkBrake. To address the concern within the limited rebuttal period, we prioritize NQ, whose 3,610 single-hop questions provide a focused test of OPERA’s ability to reduce redundant reasoning while preserving necessary retrieval. We expect similar trends across other benchmarks and will include additional results in the final version. Overall, these results highlight the benefits of action-aware hierarchical verification and probe-timing estimation in balancing reasoning efficiency with the preservation of necessary agentic actions.

W2. Ablation… & Q2. Please specify…

We thank the reviewer for suggestions on clearer ablation specifications and more comprehensive efficiency comparisons. We first summarize the ablation specifications are as follows:

  • The one-stage probing variant replaces OPERA's hierarchical action probing with a single probe that predicts the complete action, including both its type and content.

  • The fixed-interval variant removes adaptive probe-timing estimation and instead performs action probing at predefined token intervals.

  • The content similarity function measures text similarity between the candidate action contents , such as search queries or final answers, generated across different probe points, with τ\tau controlling the required similarity for consensus.

Regarding comparisons at comparable decoding costs, following the reviewer's suggestion, we conduct experiments on GPQA-D to compare OPERA with fixed-interval probing methods under comparable token budgets. We include two representative fixed-interval probing baselines, Dynasor-CoT and Dynasor-Agentic, and OPERA without probe-timing estimation, which also uses fixed-interval probing. The results are shown below:

ModelMethodEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
Qwen3-4BOPERA52.534,979.79
Dynasor-CoT43.434,972.93
Dynasor-Agentic50.006,693.43
w/o Probe-Timing Estimation46.465,053.02
Qwen3-8BOPERA53.033,105.98
Dynasor-CoT36.363,098.96
Dynasor-Agentic49.494,083.40
w/o Probe-Timing Estimation51.523,099.17

At comparable decoding costs, OPERA outperforms Dynasor-CoT by 9.10 and 16.67 pp EM accuracy on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B. Compared with the fixed-interval variant without probe-timing estimation, OPERA improves EM by 6.07 pp on Qwen3-4B and by 1.51 pp on Qwen3-8B under comparable decoded token budget. OPERA also achieves higher accuracy with substantially fewer tokens than Dynasor-Agentic. These results show that the accuracy improvements are not simply because of increased decoding costs, which further supports the effectiveness of hierarchical action verification and probe-timing estimation.

We agree that decoded-token reductions alone do not fully capture wall-clock performance. Therefore, we measure the end-to-end runtime of OPERA and vanilla agentic reasoning on NQ, including the computational overhead of all probing operations.

ModelMethodTotal RuntimeAvg. Decoded TokensTime/1K Tokens (Seconds)
Qwen3-4BVanilla Agentic Reasoning4:46:582,125.652.24
OPERA4:05:141,874.102.17
Qwen3-8BVanilla Agentic Reasoning2:21:05615.243.81
OPERA2:03:53555.283.71

OPERA achieves consistent wall-clock runtime improvements across both model sizes. Specifically, OPERA reduces end-to-end runtime by 14.54% on Qwen3-4B and 12.19% on Qwen3-8B, while reducing average decoded-token usage by 11.83% and 9.75%. These results show that OPERA's token efficiency improvements turn into practical wall-clock savings across different model sizes. This direct translation from token reductions to runtime savings is because OPERA requires no external scoring models, and the token reported in our paper includes all probe tokens.

[1] Fu, Y., et al. (2025). Efficiently Scaling LLM Reasoning Programs with Certaindex. NeurIPS.

[2] Liu, X., & Wang, L. (2025). Answer Convergence as a Signal for Early Stopping in Reasoning. EMNLP.

[3] Gong, T., et al. (2023). SoTTA: Robust Test-Time Adaptation on Noisy Data Streams. NeurIPS.

[4] Mishchenko, K., et al. (2022). IntSGD: Adaptive Floatless Compression of Stochastic Gradients. ICLR.

Reviewer_QfpPOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

OPERA addresses premature stopping in efficiency-oriented early-exit methods for knowledge-intensive agents. Instead of relying solely on provisional answers, it probes the agent’s next action through a hierarchical consistency check, first assessing agreement on whether to search or answer, then evaluating the consistency of the corresponding query or answer across multiple reasoning prefixes. An online UCB-based scheduler adaptively determines when to probe by balancing stopping success, probing cost, and entropy shifts. Experiments on five QA and reasoning benchmarks using Qwen3-4B-Thinking-2507 and Qwen3-8B demonstrate approximately 10–34% reductions in total decoded tokens, including probing overhead, while maintaining or slightly improving overall EM. Ablation studies and comparisons with Dynasor-Agentic further demonstrate the contributions of the proposed components. The results highlight OPERA’s potential to improve the efficiency of agentic reasoning through action-level consistency checking.

Critical strengths
  1. A meaningful action-aware approach to early stopping. Unlike conventional methods that rely on answer consistency, OPERA distinguishes between tool calls and final answers. This distinction is valuable for knowledge-intensive tasks, where models may need to retrieve external evidence before producing an answer. It provides a useful perspective on improving agentic reasoning efficiency.
  2. A lightweight and training-free framework. OPERA combines hierarchical action probing with adaptive probe-timing estimation to identify opportunities for early stopping. By verifying both action types and contents, it aims to reduce premature termination without requiring additional training or auxiliary models, offering practical advantages in deployment.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Although OPERA includes comparisons with Dynasor-Agentic and component ablations, its advantages over simpler alternatives remain unclear. Prompt-based early tool invocation, fixed probing intervals, or limited reasoning budgets might achieve similar efficiency gains with less complexity. For instance, removing adaptive timing on NQ with Qwen3-8B yields slightly higher accuracy (26.43 vs. 25.93 EM) with fewer tokens (0.55K vs. 0.56K).
  2. OPERA reports relatively small average EM improvements (+0.50 for Qwen3-4B and +1.07 for Qwen3-8B), with accuracy decreasing on some benchmarks. Since experiments use temperature 0.7 and report results from a single random seed, it remains unclear whether these improvements are consistent across runs or reflect sampling variability.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the author compare OPERA with simpler alternative methods under the same computational budget, such as early tool invocation based on prompts or fixed probe intervals (for example, a simple single prompt), to better illustrate the necessity of the additional complexity?
  2. Could the authors conduct a counterfactual analysis to examine whether OPERA's early stopping decisions occasionally prevent the model from correcting mistakes through further reasoning?
  3. Given that the improvements of EM are relatively minor and that its performance has declined on some benchmark tests, could the authors repeat the experiments multiple times with different seeds and report the mean and standard deviation to assess the stability of the results?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (1/2)

W1. Although OPERA… & Q1. Could the author compare…

We thank the reviewer for this valuable feedback. Replacing OPERA's probe-timing estimation with fixed probing interval can lead to overly aggressive probing. As shown in Table 2, removing probe-timing estimation reduces EM in five of six model-dataset comparisons. The decreases are particularly notable on GPQA-D, reaching 6.07 and 3.54 EM percentage points (pp) for Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B. These results suggest that fixed probing can trigger premature stopping before productive reasoning is completed and highlight the importance of adaptive probe timing for balancing efficiency and accuracy across different tasks.

Following the reviewer's suggestion, we compare OPERA with the representative prompt-based fixed-interval baseline Dynasor-CoT and its tool-integrated adaptation Dynasor-Agentic under comparable decoded token budgets. We conduct controlled experiments on NQ under comparable or even larger decoded-token budgets for these baselines, as shown below:

ModelMethodEMAvg. Decoded Tokens
Qwen3-4BOPERA30.361,909.37
Dynasor-CoT27.951,906.49
Dynasor-Agentic28.253,147.03
Qwen3-8BOPERA25.93555.28
Dynasor-CoT23.99555.76
Dynasor-Agentic24.93555.61

Under comparable decoded-token budgets, OPERA outperforms Dynasor-CoT by 2.41and 1.94 pp on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B. Compared with Dynasor-Agentic, OPERA achieves 2.11 pp higher accuracy with 39.33% fewer decoded tokens on the Qwen3-4B, and 1.00 pp higher accuracy at comparable token cost on the Qwen3-8B. These results show that OPERA's hierarchical action verification and adaptive probe-timing estimation provide clear benefits over simpler prompt-based fixed-interval probing, and improve accuracy while mitigating premature stopping without requiring additional computational budgets.

W2. OPERA reports… & Q3. Given that… We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of evaluating performance stability. OPERA primarily aims to improve the accuracy-efficiency trade-off in test-time efficient agentic reasoning, rather than significantly improving accuracy over vanilla agentic reasoning. As shown in Table 1, compared with existing efficient reasoning methods, which often reduce token usage at the cost of substantial accuracy degradation, OPERA improves average EM over the strongest baseline by 5.07 and 1.16 pp on Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B. Meanwhile, compared with vanilla agentic reasoning, OPERA maintains comparable or slightly higher accuracy while reducing total decoded tokens by 11.61% and 27.14%. These results demonstrate how OPERA mitigates efficiency-induced accuracy loss while maintaining meaningful token savings.

To address the concern on result stability, we rerun experiments on NQ using three random seeds (0, 1, 2) following common experimental practice [1-2], and compare OPERA against the strongest efficient reasoning baseline for each model. We report the mean and standard deviation of EM accuracy:

ModelMethodEMModelMethodEM
Qwen3-4BOPERA30.34 ± 0.42Qwen3-8BOPERA26.26 ± 0.29
REFRAIN28.40 ± 0.53Dynasor-CoT25.49 ± 0.24

OPERA achieves higher mean EM across both model sizes with small standard deviations. To address the concern within the limited rebuttal period, we prioritize NQ, whose 3,610 single-hop questions provide a focused test of OPERA’s ability to reduce redundant reasoning while preserving necessary retrieval. We expect similar trends across other benchmarks and will include additional results in the final version. These additional results show that OPERA's accuracy improvements are not limited to a single random seed, further supporting its effectiveness in mitigating premature stopping.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comments by Authors (2/2)

Q2. Could the authors conduct…

We thank the reviewer for suggesting this counterfactual analysis. To examine whether OPERA's early stopping prevents beneficial self-correction, we compare the answers by OPERA with those by continuing reasoning beyond its stopping points across all benchmarks. The results are summarized below:

ModelOPERAContinuationProportion of Cases
Qwen3-4BIncorrectCorrect4.62%
CorrectIncorrect6.08%
Qwen3-8BIncorrectCorrect6.77%
CorrectIncorrect7.18%

The results show that OPERA's early stopping prevents subsequent self-correction in 4.62% and 6.77% of cases for Qwen3-4B and Qwen3-8B. However, OPERA also prevents further deliberation from turning correct answers into incorrect ones in 6.08% and 7.18% of cases. These beneficial stopping decisions outweigh the missed corrections, showing accuracy gains of 1.46 and 0.41 pp over continuations. These findings suggest that OPERA more often avoids harmful over-deliberation than interrupts productive self-correction, which supports its effectiveness in mitigating premature stopping while preserving reasoning quality.

[1] Gong, T., et al. (2023). SoTTA: Robust Test-Time Adaptation on Noisy Data Streams. NeurIPS.

[2] Mishchenko, K., et al. (2022). IntSGD: Adaptive Floatless Compression of Stochastic Gradients. ICLR.

Thanks for your clarifications and I appreciate the additional validation. My concerns have been addressed so I improve my rating to 3.

Many thanks for the feedback. We appreciate your time and thoughtful review of our work!

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.