- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OPERA, a test-time framework for improving the efficiency of knowledge-intensive agentic reasoning while mitigating premature stopping. The method introduces consensus-based hierarchical action probing to assess the consistency of action types and contents, along with on-the-fly probe-timing estimation to reduce unnecessary probing. Experiments across multiple knowledge-intensive benchmarks demonstrate token savings while largely preserving or improving answer accuracy.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear and well presented. Addressing premature stopping in agentic reasoning is practically meaningful, particularly for tasks requiring external information retrieval.
- The method is intuitive and training-free. OPERA does not require additional models or training, making it relatively easy to apply to existing reasoning systems.
- The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive, including comparisons with multiple baselines, ablation studies, and analyses of retrieval quality and probing behavior.
Critical weaknesses
- The reliability of action consistency as a stopping criterion remains unclear. Consistent action predictions do not necessarily indicate that the model is ready to act, as multiple probes may agree on an incorrect or incomplete search query.
- The actual inference efficiency is not sufficiently evaluated. Although the paper reports token savings, OPERA introduces additional probing operations that may incur non-negligible computational overhead. End-to-end latency measurements would better demonstrate its practical efficiency.
Questions for authors
- How reliable is action consistency as a proxy for action readiness? Could the authors provide further analysis of cases where the probes reach consensus but the selected action is incorrect or premature?
- How much wall-clock time does OPERA actually save? Given the additional action-type and content probing, it would be helpful to report end-to-end inference latency alongside token consumption.
- How sensitive is OPERA to its probing hyperparameters? For example, how do the number of probes , consensus threshold , and content similarity threshold affect the accuracy–efficiency trade-off?
2 comments
Official Comments by Authors (2/2)
Q3. How sensitive…
We thank the reviewer for suggesting a sensitivity analysis of OPERA's probing hyperparameters. To evaluate their impact on accuracy and token efficiency, we conduct additional experiments by varying the number of probes (), consensus threshold (), and content similarity threshold (), while keeping other settings fixed:
| Probe Count | EM | Avg. Decoded Tokens |
|---|---|---|
| = 4 | 25.93 | 555.28 |
| = 6 | 26.20 | 596.76 |
| = 8 | 25.84 | 619.89 |
| = 10 | 25.96 | 648.00 |
Increasing the number of probes consistently increases token consumption, while EM remains relatively stable ranging from 25.84% to 26.20%. These results show that OPERA maintains robust accuracy across different probe counts, while additional probes introduce more decoding costs and stricter consensus requirements, which makes early stopping more difficult and thereby increases the average decoded tokens.
| Consensus Threshold | EM | Avg. Decoded Tokens |
|---|---|---|
| = 0.75 | 27.26 | 507.28 |
| = 1.00 | 25.93 | 555.28 |
Here, denotes the majority-voting consensus threshold used in hierarchical action probing. Given the default probe count = 4 and > 0.5 (Eq.3), we evaluate both available majority-consensus levels: = 0.75 requiring agreement among at least three probes, and = 1.00 requiring agreement among all four probes. Relaxing the consensus threshold from 1.00 to 0.75 improves EM by 1.33 percentage points while reducing decoded-token usage by 8.64%. This suggests that allowing occasional disagreement among probes can enable earlier stopping without necessarily sacrificing accuracy.
| Similarity Threshold | EM | Avg. Decoded Tokens |
|---|---|---|
| = 0.30 | 27.23 | 476.60 |
| = 0.50 | 26.59 | 494.65 |
| = 0.70 | 26.26 | 520.09 |
| = 0.90 | 25.93 | 555.28 |
The results show that OPERA maintains robust accuracy across different content similarity thresholds with EM ranging from 25.93 to 27.23. As increases from 0.30 to 0.90, EM decreases modestly while average decoded-token usage increases, which reflects the more conservative stopping behavior induced by stricter content verification. Importantly, the stable EM accuracy suggests that OPERA is not sensitive to the choice of similarity threshold and remains robust across the tested settings.
Overall, these results show OPERA's robustness to different probing hyperparameters. EM remains stable across the tested configurations, while the variations in decoded-token usage reflect the expected behavior of the stopping mechanism, where more probes and stricter consistency requirements lead to more conservative stopping decisions. These findings highlight a consistent accuracy-efficiency trade-off across different hyperparameter settings, showing that OPERA maintains robust accuracy while allowing flexibility in reasoning efficiency.
[1] Fu, Y., et al. (2025). Efficiently Scaling LLM Reasoning Programs with Certaindex. NeurIPS.
[2] Liu, X., & Wang, L. (2025). Answer Convergence as a Signal for Early Stopping in Reasoning. EMNLP.
Official Comments by Authors (1/2)
W1. The reliability of… & Q1. How reliable…
We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. OPERA performs hierarchical action probing and probe-timing estimation on-the-fly at test time, without relying on external evaluation models or ground-truth correctness labels. Since action correctness and the necessity of continuing reasoning cannot be directly verified under the unsupervised setting, OPERA takes inspiration from prior work using answer stabilization [1-2] and uses consensus across multiple probe points as a proxy for the stability of the model's intended next action.
To evaluate the reliability of action consensus-based stopping, we conduct a continuation analysis across all five benchmarks and compare the answers produced at early-stopping points with those obtained by allowing reasoning to continue. We also include representative baselines REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT to directly compare the frequency of premature stopping and the benefits of avoiding unnecessary continuation. The results are summarized below:
The results show that OPERA prevents more harmful continuations than it misses beneficial corrections. Specifically, correct stops account for 6.08% and 7.18% of cases, exceeding incorrect stops at 4.62% and 6.77%. This gives accuracy advantages of 1.46 and 0.41 percentage points over continued reasoning and suggests that OPERA effectively avoids unnecessary deliberation. In contrast, REFRAIN and Dynasor-CoT show higher incorrect-stop rates than correct-stop rates, which indicates a greater tendency toward premature termination of productive reasoning. These provide empirical evidence that OPERA's consensus-based stopping mitigates premature termination while identifying genuine redundancy.
W2. The actual… & Q2. & How much…
We thank the reviewer for suggesting wall-clock runtime analysis. We agree that decoded-token savings alone do not fully mean inference efficiency considering the additional probing operations of OPERA. To address this concern, we measure the end-to-end inference wall-clock runtime of OPERA against vanilla agentic reasoning on the NQ dataset including the overhead of all probing operations. The results are shown below:
OPERA achieves consistent wall-clock runtime improvements across both model sizes. Specifically, OPERA reduces end-to-end runtime by 14.54% on Qwen3-4B and 12.19% on Qwen3-8B, while reducing average decoded-token usage by 11.83% and 9.75%. These results show that OPERA's token efficiency improvements turn into practical wall-clock savings across different model sizes. This direct translation from token reductions to runtime savings is because OPERA requires no external scoring models, and the token reported in our paper includes all probe tokens.