acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Adaptive Utility-Rational Allocation: Thinking Only When It Matters

Abstract

Reasoning models can continue generating after an answer has stabilized, increasing inference cost without improving task performance. We introduce Adaptive Utility-Rational Allocation (AURA), a controller framework that compares a proxy for further improvement with the price of additional reasoning tokens. AURA combines a development-tuned certainty score, stopping safeguards, bounded auxiliary checks, and batch-level price feedback while leaving model weights fixed. On MATH-500, AURA achieves 93.2% accuracy with 646 tokens, versus 748 for Plan-and-Budget and 751 for an RL halter at the same accuracy point estimate. Paired intervals support these 13.6–14.0% token reductions. Score ablations on MATH-500 and TeleQuAD identify confidence as a consistent contributor to token efficiency, while a confidence-only score nearly reproduces the full MATH result and uses fewer tokens on TeleQuAD. In cumulative ablations across both tasks, safeguards and auxiliary checks are associated with higher observed answer quality. Batch-level price feedback reduces the remaining budget overshoot. We relate utility-based stopping to certainty thresholds and show when estimation errors leave the local stopping decision unchanged. The results support a modular view of adaptive stopping: score composition, eligibility safeguards, and budget feedback govern different aspects of the accuracy–cost tradeoff.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large language models, Test-time scaling, Adaptive computation, Efficient reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_1PTmOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4(+1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Adaptive Utility-Rational Allocation (AURA), a training-free framework for controlling the reasoning length of large language models. AURA combines a certainty score based on confidence, entropy, coherence, and answer stability with risk-aware safeguards, auxiliary verification, and batch-level token-price adaptation. The stopping decision is formulated by comparing an estimated benefit of further reasoning against its computational cost.

Critical strengths
  1. Based on the experimental results, AURA achieved significant token savings on MATH-500 compared to baselines, while maintaining comparable observation accuracy. The paired confidence intervals supported the reduction in token usage, and the service time measurements provided further evidence of the computational advantage.

  2. The paper conducted extensive experiments in various different aspects. These analyses provide useful insights into the roles of certainty score, stopping safeguards, auxiliary verification, and budget feedback in adaptive reasoning.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Please focus on Sections 3.2–3.5 and Appendix A.1–A.2. The stopping rule compares a certainty-based proxy for loss reduction with a token cost scaled by λ\lambda. However, this paper does not clearly explain how the λ\lambda is selected or whether (1−Ct)κt(1-C_t)\kappa_t is calibrated to the loss reduction. The theoretical results assume bounded estimation errors, but not establish that these errors are small in practice. Consequently, it is unclear whether the proposed approach performs meaningful utility optimization or merely implements a heuristically tuned certainty threshold. It is not clear whether the proposed method has achieved meaningful utility optimization, or merely determined a certain threshold for heuristic tuning.

  2. As acknowledged by the authors, the proposed stopping rule is equivalent to a certainty threshold when the token price and cost estimate are fixed. Table 4 shows that replacing the four-feature certainty score with confidence alone yields nearly identical accuracy and token usage on MATH-500, while keeping the remaining controller components unchanged. This raises concerns about the additional value of the proposed score composition.

Questions for authors
  1. How are the initial token price λ\lambda and utility scale κt\kappa_t selected? Is there empirical evidence that the proxy (1−Ct)κt(1-C_t)\kappa_t accurately estimates the improvement from further reasoning? How sensitive is the stopping performance to these choices?

  2. The proposed risk safeguards rely on heuristic scores. What quantitative reliability guarantees, if any, can these safeguards provide? I think the recent paper about efficient reasoning with risk control may provide some insight. For example, see Anytime Safe PAC Efficient Reasoning, ICML, 2026.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1PTm

We sincerely thank Reviewer 1PTm for the careful reading and constructive review. Below, we address each point. Tables R1 and R2 are in the general response.

[W1 & Q1] Utility optimization or a tuned certainty threshold; how the price and utility scale are selected; calibration of the proxy

What the rule is. At a fixed price it is a certainty threshold, ϑ=1−λd^/κ\vartheta = 1 - \lambda \hat d/\kappa, as Sec. 3.2 states. The score (1−Ct)κt(1 - C_t)\kappa_t serves as a stopping statistic (Sec. 3.2) rather than as a calibrated estimate of the loss reduction, and App. A.2 gives the conditions under which the proposition holds. The abstract now states that the rule is a threshold on a certainty statistic, and Sec. 3.2 describes the score in these terms.

What the utility form adds. It ties the threshold to a token price, and the price is what the batch update moves. Eq. 6 is a projected dual update on the multiplier of an average-budget constraint. The threshold is therefore steered toward the target budget from token counts alone, with no correctness labels. In Table 5, this removes the remaining overshoot: from 6.0 to 0.0 tokens on MATH-500 and from 3.0 to 0.0 on TeleQuAD.

How the two quantities are selected. The utility scale is chosen on the 500-problem development split from {0.75,1,1.25}\lbrace 0.75, 1, 1.25\rbrace; the selected value is 1 (App. A.1). With a block cost of 64 tokens, the initial price 0.00150 gives a threshold of 0.904, and 0.00152 gives 0.90272 in the matched setting. The initial price is a starting value that depends on the evaluation setting (App. A.1), and the batch update then moves it toward the target budget. The development search covered the utility scale, the weight of the development risk criterion, the risk threshold, and the consecutive count (81 configurations, App. A.1). Only the ratio λd^/κ\lambda \hat d/\kappa enters Eq. 5. The three candidate scales therefore correspond to thresholds 0.872, 0.904 and 0.923 at the initial price. Under the price update, the scale also sets the size of each threshold step, ηd^/κ\eta \hat d/\kappa per token of overrun, whereas the threshold at which the mean cost equals the target does not depend on it.

Sensitivity. With κ=1\kappa = 1, a 100-token overrun in a batch raises the price by 0.0001 and lowers the threshold by 0.0064 (App. A.1). In the submission, the ±5% minimum-token-offset diagnostic gives 92.8–93.2% at 626–666 tokens (Table 9), and eight half-weight and double-weight perturbations give 646.0–686.7 tokens (App. A.3.5).

Calibration. The paper does not rely on a calibration claim, since the score is used as a stopping statistic that is compared with a price.

[W2] The value of the four-term score when confidence alone reproduces it

We agree, and the submission reports it. On MATH-500, confidence-only differs from the full score at 3 of 2,500 halts (0.00 pp [−0.12, 0.12]; −0.1 tokens [−0.3, 0.2]). On TeleQuAD, it uses 10.5 fewer tokens [8.3, 12.7] with no established EM difference (0.6 pp [−0.5, 1.8]). We have made confidence-only the default score and present the four-term score as a variant.

The contribution we claim is the controller, not the score. The guards add 0.8 pp on both tasks, probes and verification add 0.4–0.5 pp, and price feedback removes the budget overshoot (Table 5; Table R1). Entropy and stability remain in use as inputs to the risk checks, not as score terms.

[Q2] Reliability guarantees for the heuristic safeguards

Thank you for this question and for the pointer to B-PAC reasoning (Yu et al., ICML 2026), which Sec. 2 now discusses. The safeguards are evaluated empirically in the paper (Table 5). B-PAC reasoning routes queries between a thinking and a non-thinking model and controls the resulting performance loss with anytime-valid guarantees under partial feedback, whereas AURA decides within one reasoning trace and targets an average token budget. A possible extension, which we have not established, is to use AURA's certainty or risk score as the uncertainty score of such a procedure, and to calibrate the stopping threshold on the development split so that the accuracy loss relative to full-budget reasoning is at most α\alpha with probability at least 1−δ1 - \delta.

We hope these clarifications address your concerns, and we are happy to answer any remaining questions.

I thank the authors for their clarifications, which partially address my concerns and confusion, and also make the paper clearer. But, my main concern remains unresolved:

The authors explicitly acknowledge that the continuation-value proxy is a stopping statistic rather than a calibrated estimate of the loss reduction. The theories are based on bounded estimation errors, but there is no empirical evidence that these conditions hold in practice. Consequently, I think the proposed utility-based formulation is essentially a development-tuned certainty threshold with heuristic safeguards and budget feedback, rather than a well-justified utility optimization method.

I also understand that authors regard the controller as the main contribution. But I think that my main concern is closely related to the controller. These concerns are unlikely to be resolved during the discussion, as they may pertain to fundamental theoretical aspects or even the reconfiguration of methodologies. I therefore maintain my original rating of 2.

Thank you for the follow-up. We agree with your description of the mechanism: AURA is a development-tuned certainty threshold with safeguards and budget feedback, and the revision introduces it in these terms (abstract; Sec. 3). The claim of the paper is empirical, lower cost at the same observed accuracy with no trained halting policy, and the proposition is stated as a conditional result (Sec. 3.5). What our first reply did not make clear is what the utility form is used for. It is used for two things, and neither requires a calibrated proxy.

The first is the price. Eq. 1 is, up to a constant, the Lagrangian of minimizing the expected loss under an average-token budget, with λ\lambda as the multiplier, and Eq. 6 is a projected dual update on λ\lambda. For this update to move the cost toward the budget, a higher price must not increase the mean cost. This holds for any stopping statistic, calibrated or not: a higher price lowers the threshold ϑ=1−λd^/κ\vartheta = 1 - \lambda \hat d/\kappa, the safeguards do not depend on the price, and the halt can only move earlier. In Table 5, the update removes the remaining overshoot on both tasks.

The second is the proposition. It does not need (1−Ct)κ(1 - C_t)\kappa itself to approximate the loss reduction Δt\Delta_t. Let g≥0g \ge 0 be any strictly increasing function, fixed across states, with ∣g(1−Ct)−Δt∣≤εg\lvert g(1 - C_t) - \Delta_t\rvert \le \varepsilon_g. Because Ct≥ϑC_t \ge \vartheta is equivalent to g(1−Ct)≤g(1−ϑ)g(1 - C_t) \le g(1 - \vartheta), the rule of Eq. 5 is the one-step rule for the proxy g(1−Ct)g(1 - C_t) at the price λg=g(1−ϑ)/d^\lambda_g = g(1 - \vartheta)/\hat d, and the proposition gives agreement with the exact one-step decision at that price whenever ∣Δt−λgdt∣>εg+λgεc\lvert \Delta_t - \lambda_g d_t\rvert \gt \varepsilon_g + \lambda_g \varepsilon_c. The condition is therefore on how well certainty ranks states by remaining value, not on the level of the proxy. The level only fixes which price corresponds to which threshold, and AURA does not take the price as given: the budget update moves it. We will state this in Sec. 3.5 and add its proof to App. A.2.

The formulation thus justifies the form of the rule, a certainty threshold whose level is set by a token price, and the mechanism that sets the price. Whether certainty ranks states well is an empirical question, and the submission tests it through outcomes: if the ranking were poor, halting on it would lose accuracy that further reasoning recovers. Under the same controller, the score variants that use 41.8 to 74.9 more tokens reach 93.12–93.20%, against 93.20% (Table 4). At matched tokens, a halting policy learned from trajectories is not observed to do better: AURA minus the RL halter is 0.08 pp [−0.60, 0.76] on MATH-500 and 0.6 pp [−2.1, 3.4] on GPQA-Diamond (Tables 2 and 15).

The other components do not use the level of the proxy either: the safeguards are eligibility conditions, the checks add observations, and the price update uses token counts. The safeguards and checks are there because certainty can be misleading when the model is confidently wrong (Sec. 3.3).

We would be glad to discuss any remaining points.

Reviewer_haG2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose AURA, a training free efficient reasoning method which decides when a frozen reasoning model should stop generating. It uses model certainty to estimate whether more reasoning is worth its token cost, with checks to avoid stopping too early. A feedback rule adjusts this cost penalty between batches to keep average token use near a chosen budget. On MATH-500, it uses fewer tokens than the selected planning and learned-stopping baselines at the same observed accuracy; a simpler confidence-only score nearly reproduces this result with the same safeguards.

Critical strengths
  • Training free efficient reason / budget allocation is an important field, and AURA is a practical solution.
  • The ablations provided in a the paper are useful, and at least show the contribution of each term of the stopping rule.
Critical weaknesses
  • The advantage over closely related training-free methods remains unclear. Simple convergence and certainty baselines perform less well at their selected settings, but the matched-budget comparisons cover planning and RL methods. A tuned comparison with CoDE-Stop or REFRAIN would clarify the contribution. REFRAIN also adjusts thresholds online, although it optimizes a proxy for quality and length rather than meeting a specified average budget.

  • The related-work discussion omits Re-FORC (Zabounidis et al., ICML 2026). Re-FORC learns a lightweight reward forecaster over future reasoning-token budgets and uses predicted gains versus token cost for adaptive early stopping. This directly overlaps with AURA's benefit-cost framing. AURA instead uses a training-free certainty proxy, safeguards, and batch-level price feedback, but the missing discussion leaves the novelty of this combination insufficiently positioned. A same-backbone accuracy-cost comparison, with adapter-training cost and both methods'

  • The ablations do not establish how much the score adds beyond the safeguards. Changing the score while keeping the controller fixed also changes its scale relative to the stopping threshold. The nearly identical stopping points could mean that the safeguards determine when either score can stop generation. Retuning the confidence threshold and testing a rule that stops as soon as the safeguards allow would distinguish these explanations.

  • The math experiments are limited to MATH500, an old and at this point saturated benchmark. In 2026 I would expect experiments on AIME and AMC.

Questions for authors
  1. At common budgets, how does AURA compare with retuned confidence-only stopping and a close training-free method? How often does the score delay stopping after the safeguards permit it?
  2. What budgets are reachable with the safeguards fixed? Within that range, does feedback outperform a development-tuned fixed threshold after a change in target budget or problem difficulty?
  3. How does AURA compare with Re-FORC on the same backbone at matched inference cost, and what training cost is avoided by using a certainty-based stopping rule?
  4. Can you clarify the novelty with respect to Re-FORC?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer haG2 (1/2)

We sincerely thank Reviewer haG2 for the detailed and expert review. Below, we address each point. Tables R1 and R2 are in the general response.

[W1 & Q1] Close training-free methods and retuned confidence-only stopping at common budgets

Thank you for this comment. The matched-budget tables cover Plan-and-Budget and the RL halter, and the two simple training-free comparators are reported at their development-selected settings. At those settings, AURA has higher observed accuracy at fewer tokens: 93.2% at 646, against 92.6% at 704 for certainty-threshold stopping and 92.8% at 735 for answer-convergence stopping (Table 1).

Table R2 in the general response brings together the operating points that the submission contains at and below the primary budget. With the confidence-only score, AURA reaches 93.2% at 646 tokens (Table 4), and the threshold without safeguards reaches 91.9% at 589 tokens (Table 5).

Sec. 2 now discusses both methods. CoDE-Stop applies a ramping threshold to the confidence of intermediate answers, together with a degeneration score. REFRAIN detects reflective redundancy and adapts its stopping threshold online with a sliding-window bandit. As you note, neither targets a specified average budget. AURA's price update does, from token counts alone.

[W3 & Q1] What the score adds beyond the safeguards

Thank you for this observation. The existing results speak to it in two ways.

  • The safeguards alone do not fix the halt. Under the same safeguards, a weaker score halts later. Relative to the full score, stability-only adds 41.8 tokens, uniform weights 45.6 [38.2, 53.1], entropy-only 73.3, dropping confidence 74.9 [66.7, 83.2], and coherence-only 82.7 (Table 4, App. A.3.5).
  • With confidence in the score, the safeguards bind. Full and confidence-only scores halt at different checkpoints in only 3 of 2,500 evaluations. Adding the guards to the threshold rule moves the mean halt by 33.9 tokens, about half a checkpoint (Table 5).

[Q2] Reachable budgets, and feedback against a development-tuned fixed threshold

With the safeguards fixed, no early halt occurs before checkpoint 5, which is 320 main tokens, and the cap is 2,048. The lowest reachable average budget is the mean cost of the rule that stops as soon as the safeguards allow.

Within that range, every 100 tokens of overrun in a batch lowers the threshold by 0.0064 at κ=1\kappa = 1 (App. A.1). At the target budget of each task, the update removes overshoots of 6.0 and 3.0 tokens (Table 5).

Further budgets in the submission come from the ±5% minimum-token-offset diagnostic, which gives 626 and 666 tokens (Table 9). For the comparison with a fixed threshold, the closest evidence in the submission is the stage without the price update, which keeps the price fixed: 93.1% at 652 tokens, against 93.2% at 646 tokens with the update (Table 5).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer haG2 (2/2)

[W2, Q3 & Q4] Re-FORC

Thank you for this reference, which Sec. 2 now discusses. Re-FORC trains a lightweight adapter that forecasts expected future reward as a function of additional thinking tokens, and it controls length by comparing the forecast with a cost per token. AURA shares that benefit–cost framing (Eqs. 1–5), and we now attribute it accordingly.

AspectRe-FORCAURA
Estimate of the benefit of continuingLearned forecaster over future token budgetsCertainty statistic from decoding probabilities
HorizonReward as a function of future tokensOne checkpoint ahead; App. A.2 gives a counterexample to global optimality
Token priceSupplied as a cost-per-token thresholdAdapted between batches to meet a target average budget
Other mechanismsNone of this kindEligibility safeguards; bounded probes and verification
TrainingA lightweight adapter on the reasoning modelNone

The novelty relative to Re-FORC therefore lies in a training-free instantiation with safeguards and a label-free budget controller. The two are also complementary: Re-FORC's learned forecaster could replace (1−Ct)κt(1 - C_t)\kappa_t in Eq. 5 while keeping the safeguards and the price update.

A learned controller on the same backbone. The closest evidence in the submission is the learned RL halter, trained on held-out trajectories. At matched tokens, AURA is within 0.08 pp of it on MATH-500 ([−0.60, 0.76], Table 2) and within 0.6 pp on GPQA-Diamond ([−2.1, 3.4], Table 15), with no halting-policy training.

[W4] MATH-500 is saturated; AIME and AMC

We agree. On MATH-500, every method lies between 92.6% and 93.2% from 646 to 880 tokens (Table 1), which is why token cost is the measurable effect there. We have moved the harder-task results into Sec. 4.3. GPQA-Diamond is compared at matched tokens: 60.8%, against 60.4% and 60.2% (Table 3). On AIME 2024, AURA obtains 58.3% at 519 tokens, against 58.0% at 642 for the RL halter and 56.7% at 731 for static budget forcing (Table 8). In that comparison, each method is reported at its own operating point.

Presentation

Thank you for the comments on presentation. Sec. 3 now opens with the controller in one paragraph: a confidence threshold, the safeguards, the bounded checks, and the price update. Table R3 (App. A.1) lists every setting as shared or task-specific with its value. The TCORE fine-tuning details, which concern a separate diagnostic and distract from a training-free method, are removed. If particular passages were hard to follow, we would be glad to revise them.

We hope these clarifications address your concerns, and we are happy to answer any remaining questions.

Reviewer_TGUrOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This work introduces AURA (Adaptive Utility‑Rational Allocation), a training‑free inference‑time halting controller working with frozen LLM weights to mitigate redundant token consumption under fixed‑budget reasoning. The framework combines certainty scoring, multi‑layer stopping safeguards, bounded auxiliary checks (probes and verification), and batch‑level token‑price feedback. On MATH‑500, AURA cuts token usage by 13.6‑14.0% versus Plan‑and‑Budget and RL halter while maintaining 93.2% accuracy. Additional evaluations and ablations are conducted on GPQA‑Diamond and TeleQuAD.

Critical strengths
  1. AURA establishes a well‑structured modular paradigm for training‑free LLM adaptive stopping. It decouples early‑stopping logic into separate functional units and leverages cumulative ablations to characterize each component’s role, offering clear design insights for subsequent research on inference‑time resource allocation.

  2. This work adopts thorough, statistically‑grounded evaluation practices for reasoning‑cost trade‑offs. It conducts both accuracy‑matched and token‑matched comparisons with paired bootstrap confidence intervals, avoiding over‑interpretation of raw point estimates and preventing misleading performance claims.

  3. The paper provides restrained theoretical analysis for its myopic stopping heuristic.

Critical weaknesses
  1. AURA hyper‑parameters exhibit strong task‑specific dependency. Key controller parameters must be tuned on task‑specific held‑out development data, and there is no empirical evidence showing one unified hyper‑parameter set transfers well across diverse unseen downstream tasks, raising nontrivial deployment tuning costs.

  2. AURA yields no statistically significant accuracy gain under equal‑token budgets. Its core empirical benefit only appears when accuracy is held fixed to reduce token consumption; under matched token budgets, accuracy gaps against competing baselines lie entirely within bootstrap confidence intervals, restricting its value purely to cost‑reduction scenarios.

  3. Sub‑components inside safeguards and auxiliary checks lack fine‑grained isolated ablation results. Risk scoring, probe triggers and verification are only enabled or disabled as a combined bundle, making it impossible to pin down individual contribution of each heuristic and hindering mechanistic understanding and targeted improvement.

Questions for authors
  1. Can you show whether one unified set of AURA hyper‑parameters (score weights, risk thresholds, m, t_min) can yield reasonable performance on multiple unseen tasks without per‑task development‑set tuning? If not, what minimal automated pipeline can replace manual dev‑set tuning for new target tasks?

  2. Auxiliary probes and verification bring extra token overhead. Under what task conditions do performance gains from auxiliary checks fail to offset their token cost? Is there any measurable signal to decide whether auxiliary checks should be enabled for a given dataset?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer TGUr

We sincerely thank Reviewer TGUr for the clear summary and the constructive questions. Below, we address each point. Tables R1 and R2 are in the general response.

[W1 & Q1] Task-specific hyperparameters, a unified setting, and an automated pipeline

What is shared. App. A.1 separates the shared settings from the task-specific ones, and its new Table R3 lists each setting with its value. Shared across all tasks: the score weights, the entropy feature, the risk inputs, the stability window, the encoder, the consecutive count, and the auxiliary prompts. Task-specific: the answer extractor and completeness check, which depend on the output format; the minimum length; the utility scale; and the initial price.

What the experiments tuned. For MATH-500, the controller was selected on a disjoint development split of 500 problems, over the utility scale, the weight of the development risk criterion, the risk threshold, and the consecutive count (81 configurations, App. A.1). The score weights were also selected on development data.

Robustness in the submission. Eight half-weight and double-weight perturbations change MATH-500 tokens from 646.0 to at most 686.7 and leave TeleQuAD EM between 75.74% and 75.79% (App. A.3.5). The ±5% minimum-token-offset diagnostic gives 92.8–93.2% at 626–666 tokens (Table 9). Four prompt perturbations give 92.8–93.0% at 624–686 tokens, against 93.2% at 646 for the original prompt (Table 11).

A single configuration. The settings listed as shared above are common to all tasks. With a single configuration for every task, only the answer extractor would differ.

A simplified procedure for a new task. This is a proposal, distinct from the selection used in the experiments above. (1) Supply the task's answer extractor. (2) Keep the shared settings and a fixed utility scale, and set the target budget. The scale enters Eq. 5 only through its ratio to the price, so the price update then moves the threshold toward that budget from token counts, without labels. (3) Optionally choose the minimum length from a few values on a small development set, which would be the only step that uses labels. The revision gives this procedure in Sec. 3.4.

[W2] No accuracy gain at equal token budgets

Thank you for raising this point. We agree, and the claim of the paper is lower cost at the same observed accuracy rather than higher accuracy at equal cost (Sec. 4.3). With a frozen generator, a stopping rule is not expected to raise accuracy on a benchmark where every method lies between 92.6% and 93.2%.

The two results answer different questions. At matched tokens, a controller with no trained halting policy and no planner is within 0.08 pp of a trained RL halter and of Plan-and-Budget on MATH-500 and within 0.6 pp on GPQA-Diamond, and every interval includes zero (Tables 2 and 15). At each method's development-selected operating point, AURA reaches the same observed accuracy with 13.6–14.0% fewer tokens (−102 [−118.3, −85.2] and −105 [−122.2, −87.8]) and 14.1–14.7% less batch time.

At lower budgets, the submission reports AURA variants: 92.8% at 626 tokens with a −5% minimum-token offset, and 91.9% at 589 tokens for the threshold without safeguards (Table R2).

[W3] Isolated ablations of the safeguards and auxiliary checks

Thank you for this suggestion. Table 5 adds the safeguards and the checks in stages. It separates the safeguards as a group from the threshold (91.9% at 589 tokens without them and 92.7% at 623 tokens with them) and the checks from the safeguards (93.1% at 652 tokens with both). Table 9 also reports a ±5% minimum-token offset, which gives 92.8–93.2% at 626–666 tokens.

[Q2] When auxiliary checks do not pay for their tokens, and a signal for enabling them

Cost. On MATH-500, the checks use 23.3 tokens per instance, 3.6% of the total, from 1.18 probe events and 0.11 verification calls per instance (Sec. 4.5). The share is the same on TeleQuAD (8.2 of 228 tokens) and GPQA-Diamond (20.6 of 571).

Benefit. In Table 5, they accompany gains of 0.4 pp on MATH-500 and 0.5 pp on TeleQuAD.

When they are unlikely to pay. Three conditions follow from how the checks work. When accuracy is near its ceiling, few answers can change. When trajectories are stable, probes agree with the current answer. When answers are short, each probe is a larger share of the trace.

A measurable signal. Two label-free quantities are available to the controller: the probe disagreement, and the share of verification calls that return a revised answer. If both are low on a sample from the target task, the checks rarely change the answer, which indicates that their token cost is unlikely to be repaid. App. A.3.6 now states this.

We hope these clarifications address your concerns, and we are happy to answer any remaining questions.

Thank you for the detailed response. The rebuttal has addressed my main concerns by clarifying the hyperparameter settings, explaining the ablation results, and providing further insights into the role of auxiliary checks. I think these clarifications have strengthened the paper, and I will raise my rating from 2 to 3.

Thank you for the follow-up and for raising your rating. We are glad that the clarifications on the hyperparameter settings, the ablation results, and the auxiliary checks were helpful. The corresponding additions are in the revised manuscript: the shared and task-specific settings (Table R3, App. A.1) with the procedure for a new task (Sec. 3.4), the summary of component effects (Table R1, App. A.3.7), and the conditions under which the auxiliary checks are unlikely to repay their tokens (App. A.3.6). We would be glad to answer any further questions.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General response to all reviewers

We sincerely thank all three reviewers for the careful and constructive reviews. We appreciate the encouraging comments on the modular design, the cumulative ablations, and the paired statistics. Three questions appear in more than one review: whether AURA is more than a tuned confidence threshold, how it compares with closely related methods, and how its matched-token result should be read. We would like to address these first. All changes are highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript.

What AURA is. At a fixed price, the stopping rule is a certainty threshold, as Sec. 3.2 states, and on MATH-500 the confidence-only score differs from the four-term score at 3 of 2,500 halts (Table 4). We therefore now present confidence-only as the default score. The contribution is the controller around the threshold: eligibility safeguards, bounded probes and verification, and a price update that steers the threshold toward a target average budget from token counts alone. The claim is lower cost at the same observed accuracy with no trained halting policy (Sec. 4.3).

What the submission establishes (Table R1, existing results). Effects are given for MATH-500 first and TeleQuAD second.

ComponentSourceEffect
Confidence in the scoreTable 4Removing it adds 74.9 tokens [66.7, 83.2]; 23.6 tokens [20.5, 26.7]
Other score termsTable 4Full and confidence-only scores differ at 3 of 2,500 halts; on TeleQuAD the extra terms cost 10.5 tokens [8.3, 12.7] with no established EM gain
Stopping guardsTable 5+0.8 pp for +33.9 tokens; +0.8 pp for +12.0 tokens
Probes and verificationTable 5+0.4 pp for +29.3 tokens; +0.5 pp for +11.2 tokens
Batch price updateTable 5Overshoot of the target budget falls from 6.0 to 0.0 tokens; from 3.0 to 0.0
Whole controller at matched tokensTables 2, 15Within 0.08 pp of Plan-and-Budget and the RL halter on MATH-500, and within 0.6 pp on GPQA-Diamond; all intervals include zero
Whole controller at development-selected operating pointsTables 1, 2The same 93.2% with 102 [85, 118] and 105 [88, 122] fewer tokens

Operating points at and below the primary budget (Table R2). A question in all three reviews is what AURA adds at a given budget. The submission contains several operating points that bear on this question, which were spread over five tables. Table R2 brings together every operating point at or below about 650 tokens for s1-32B on MATH-500, with the comparators at their reported points.

RuleAccuracy at mean tokensSource
AURA, four-term score93.2% at 646 (primary); 93.1% at 646 (matched)Tables 1 and 13
AURA, confidence-only score93.2% at 646Table 4
AURA, minimum-token offset −5% / +5%92.8% at 626 / 93.1% at 666Table 9
Threshold with stopping guards, without checks and price update92.7% at 623Table 5
Threshold with guards and checks, without price update93.1% at 652Table 5
Certainty threshold without safeguards91.9% at 589Table 5
Plan-and-Budget93.0% at 649 (matched); 93.2% at 748 (primary)Tables 13 and 1
RL halter93.0% at 648 (matched); 93.2% at 751 (primary)Tables 13 and 1
Certainty-threshold comparator92.6% at 704Table 1
Answer-convergence stopping92.8% at 735Table 1

Below 646 tokens, AURA variants reach 92.8% at 626 tokens with a −5% minimum-token offset, 92.7% at 623 tokens without checks and price update, and 91.9% at 589 tokens for the threshold without safeguards.

Changes in the revision.

  1. Sec. 1 and 3: the controller is stated as a confidence threshold with safeguards, checks and price feedback. Confidence-only is the default score.
  2. Abstract and Sec. 3.2: the rule is stated as a threshold on a certainty statistic, the score is described as a stopping statistic, and the roles of the utility scale and the initial price are stated.
  3. Sec. 2: Re-FORC (Zabounidis et al., 2026), CoDE-Stop (Hosseini et al., 2026), REFRAIN (Sun et al., 2026) and B-PAC reasoning (Yu et al., 2026).
  4. Sec. 4.3: the operating points at and below the primary budget, and the AIME 2024 results that were only in App. A.3. App. A.3.7 and A.3.8: Tables R1 and R2.
  5. Presentation: Sec. 3 opens with the controller in one paragraph, and Sec. 3.4 gives the procedure for a new task. Table R3 (App. A.1) lists every setting as shared or task-specific with its value. The TCORE fine-tuning details, which concern a separate diagnostic, are removed from App. A.1.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.