- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
is paper proposes a transfer learning method for hyperspectral image (HSI) classification. The method consists of three main components: scene-style posterior estimation and normalization, scene-style transport, and style-survival correspondence discovery. With these components, the transfer learning problem for cross-scene HSI classification is reformulated as a scene-style estimation task. However, the model and algorithm details are not sufficiently clear, which, in my view, weakens the justification for the authors’ claims. The experimental results are competitive with those of SOTA methods.
Critical strengths
The experimental results appear promising.
Critical weaknesses
Its contributions are rather limited, since it relies solely on style-modeling to characterize scene variations. Moreover, style-modeling bears strong similarities to shared feature learning, given that the observed images are constructed from style component and shared component. The proposed method also fails to adequately substantiate its claim that the scene-type posterior distribution can be effectively estimated. Finally, the writing of paper is poor, as many critical technical details are insufficiently described and explained.
- Can the Gaussian distribution in Eq. (1) and affine transformation precisely characterize scene style variations?
- Can the intermediate style be represented by Eq. (2)?
- What is the theoretical foundation for using Eq. (4) to measure whether the same class assignment survives?
Questions for authors
Why is self-supervised learning capable of modeling scene-style variations, given that the target data lack sufficient class label information? Why does the proposed method outperform other related transfer learning approaches?