- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of unsupervised cross-scene hyperspectral image clustering without any manual annotations. To overcome cluster distortion caused by the entanglement of genuine land-cover semantics and scene-specific spectral variations such as lighting or sensor shifts, the authors introduce DTRA. The proposed method factorizes representations into semantic and scene-specific components, verifies transferable semantic prototypes via cross-scene variation exchange, and scores target samples using assignment confidence and exchange-induced discrepancy to progressively incorporate reliable target evidence for prototype refinement. The refined prototype state is then recurrently fed back into subsequent training rounds to guide future transfer decisions. Experiments across six cross-scene tasks on the Houston, Pavia, and HyRANK benchmark datasets demonstrate that the method consistently improves clustering accuracy over existing approaches.
Critical strengths
The paper is well-structured and clearly motivated. It decomposes cross-scene HSI clustering into “what to transfer” and “when to transfer,” which makes the method easy to follow and the contribution well defined.
The empirical validation is broad and convincing. It covers six directional cross-scene tasks, compares against nine recent methods, and includes component ablation, parameter sensitivity analysis, and mechanism-level visualization.
Critical weaknesses
The reported improvements are not consistently convincing. On several tasks, such as H18→H13, PC→PU, and PU→PC, the gains over the second-best method are only 0.5–1.3 percentage points, while the standard deviations are as large as 4–7 percentage points.
The evaluation is limited to ACC only, with no NMI or ARI, which are standard for clustering. Moreover, ablation and parameter analysis are conducted only on a single task (PU→PC), so it is unclear whether the conclusions generalize to other transfer directions.
Questions for authors
see Weaknesses
3 comments
have reviewed the authors' rebuttal. While the additional experiments do provide a clearer demonstration of the proposed method's performance advantages, given the overall novelty of the method, I have decided to maintain my current score.
We thank the reviewer for carefully reconsidering our response and acknowledging that the additional experiments provide clearer evidence of DTRA's performance advantages. We appreciate the reviewer's constructive feedback and thoughtful assessment, which have helped us improve the clarity and presentation of our work.
Response to Reviewer X85u
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive questions. The following responses address the concerns and questions point by point.
W1: Reliability of small ACC gains under run-to-run variability.
A. Table 1 reports mean ± SD over five independent runs. On H18→H13 and PC→PU, DTRA exceeds the second-best methods by 0.63 and 0.49 percentage points in mean ACC, respectively, with standard deviations of 7.04 and 4.32 points. Although the run-to-run variability is relatively large on these two directions, the reported results reflect the observed mean ACC over five independent runs rather than statistically established improvements. On PU→PC, DTRA achieves a 1.28-point improvement with a considerably smaller standard deviation of 0.03 points. Overall, DTRA achieves the highest observed mean ACC across all six directions, with task-dependent improvement margins and run-to-run variability.
W2(a): Clustering evaluation beyond ACC.
A: We added normalized mutual information (NMI) and adjusted Rand index (ARI) for all six transfer tasks and all eleven baselines in Appendix A (Table 3). The complete results are below (%, NMI/ARI in each cell).
Table 3: NMI/ARI (%) comparisons on six directional cross-scene clustering tasks. Each entry lists NMI and ARI separated by ``/'', respectively. Bold indicates the highest value for both metrics in each task.
DTRA has the highest NMI and ARI in every direction. For H13→H18, its NMI/ARI are 65.72/48.32 versus the second-best 54.55/36.84. For Lo→Di, they are 64.72/45.24 versus 55.36/32.88. These permutation-invariant metrics supplement Hungarian-matched ACC and support the clustering results beyond that measure.
W2(b): Generalizability of ablations and parameter analysis.
A. We extended Table 2 and Fig. 4 from PU→PC to H13→H18 and Lo→Di, covering Houston, Pavia, and HyRANK. The expanded ablations are reported below (ACC, %).
Table 2: Component ablations and alternative-strategy comparisons on three cross-scene tasks (ACC, %).
Every component removal reduces ACC on all three tasks, with task-dependent effects. Fig. 4 additionally examines τ, ϵπ, K, and β on these same three directions. The favorable regions support the shared defaults τ=0.20, ϵπ=0.05, K=4, and β=1.0. Sensitivity to K is relatively weak on PU→PC. Together, these results provide cross-dataset evidence for the components and parameter choices.