- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes TCPL for pixel-level spectral small target detection of known categories in unseen scenes. Training combines sparse support-point references, target/background descriptions, and dense query supervision. ATKE provides asymmetric text guidance, TCSV aggregates predictions under different support conditions into a consensus teacher, and CPLD distills these predictions into a learnable prototype bank and target anchor. At inference, only the query image is required, without support inputs, text encoding, or parameter updates. Experiments on Aircraft-14, Vehicle-74, and Plane-400 report improvements over adapted few-shot segmentation and hyperspectral target detection baselines, together with component and loss ablations.
Critical strengths
(1) Practical query-only deployment. Distilling support-conditioned predictions into learned prototypes and an anchor removes the need for support samples, text inputs, or test-time adaptation. This is a useful deployment property for detecting a known target category in new imagery. Asymmetric text guidance is also reasonably motivated by the potential mismatch between support and query backgrounds.
(2) Meaningful empirical gains and evaluation effort. The paper evaluates three datasets, multiple point budgets, and three random seeds, and includes internal baselines and ablations. On Vehicle-74, full TCPL improves AP from 51.79 to 62.52 relative to the Query-only variant (Table 4), providing evidence beyond comparisons with external methods. The controlled point-budget experiment and additional San Diego testing are useful supplements. The construction of the evaluation datasets, including new pixel-level aircraft annotations for Plane-400, is another potential contribution.
Critical weaknesses
Weakness 1:The baseline selection does not fully establish the advantage in the stated supervised setting. TCPL uses dense training-query masks and detects known categories at test time. The main comparisons contain six adapted few-shot segmentation methods and two hyperspectral target detection methods, but no independent, well-tuned standard supervised segmentation baseline matched to this setting. Appendix B.2 confirms that most FSS baselines also use dense training-query supervision, so this is not simply a dense-versus-sparse supervision comparison; however, MPA uses a different supervision protocol, and the effects of adapting the baselines to spectral inputs and point maps remain insufficiently explained. The strong internal Query-only result on Aircraft-14 (36.75 AP and 97.40 AUC, Table 4) makes an independent supervised baseline particularly important. Without it, the source of the large margins over the adapted methods remains uncertain. Weakness 2: The specific contribution and generalization benefit of consensus are not sufficiently isolated. Removing TCSV changes both attention retrieval to mean pooling and the multi-support teacher to a single teacher (Table 10). This prevents attributing the resulting difference specifically to consensus. Table 5 provides a cleaner KD ablation: KD improves Vehicle-74 AP by 4.94 percentage points, but Aircraft-14 AP by only 0.50, with increased AP standard deviations on both datasets. These results support dataset-dependent mean improvements, rather than a general claim of improved training stability. Evidence under independent scene shifts is also limited: Aircraft-14 has three test images, Vehicle-74 consists of crops from one flight-line image, and the additional San Diego evaluation lacks baseline comparisons. These limitations do not establish leakage or invalidate the reported gains, but leave the central transfer claim incompletely supported.
Questions for authors
- Could you provide a standard supervised segmentation or spectral detection baseline trained with the same dense masks, spectral inputs, splits, and model-selection budget, including comparison on the additional San Diego scenes? Please also clarify how unannotated support pixels are treated in the adapted FSS baselines.
- With attention retrieval, support exposure, supervised losses, and training budget held fixed, how much does a multi-support teacher improve over a single-support teacher? Please distinguish this effect from the benefit of retrieval and from the KD-versus-no-KD comparison.
- How are the Vehicle-74 spatial regions partitioned, and can the source-scene/crop mappings be provided? For Plane-400, does the source-image split also separate geographic locations? These details would clarify the scope of the generalization results.
- Could you provide representative generated target/background descriptions and compare instance-specific text with a fixed category description? This would clarify whether the text contributes sample-specific information beyond a category-level prior.
4 comments
Q3–Q4, W1–W2:
To Q3:
-
Vehicle-74 comes from a single AeroRIT flight-line image. We partitioned the image before cropping. In original-image pixels, the training, validation, and test regions span , , and along the horizontal axis, with 32, 10, and 32 retained patches, respectively. Within each region, we cropped non-overlapping patches starting at with a stride of 256 pixels and padded edge patches to 256 × 256 after cropping. The 512-pixel-wide validation region separates the training and test patches, so they are never directly adjacent. We also checked for vehicles crossing subset boundaries and excluded the affected patches. No source pixels or vehicle instances are shared across subsets. Vehicle-74 therefore evaluates spatial generalization within one acquisition.
-
Plane-400 is split by full source-image ID into 20/4/7 source images, corresponding to 264/39/97 patches. The test source images are held out in their entirety, although airport locations overlap with training. To supplement the cross-location evidence, we completed pixel-level annotations during the review period for 167 additional patches from 13 WorldView-3 images covering 10 unseen airports. Neither its airport IDs nor its satellite strip IDs overlap with the original data. These patches were used exclusively for testing.
To Q4:
The fixed category sentences are “An aircraft viewed from above.” and “A road vehicle viewed from above.” Target descriptions add visible instance structure when available. Background descriptions capture the land cover and layout of the same support image.
Table 4. Examples of descriptions used in training
| Training support | Target text beyond the category sentence | Background text |
|---|---|---|
| ABU-Airport-2 | cross-like silhouette, paired lateral wings, and central body trace. | Paved surface bordered by linear roads, a rectangular structure, and mottled patches, possibly vegetation. |
| AVIRIS Scene 01, group 3 | Category sentence only | Open ground with scattered irregular patches, possibly vegetation, crossed by a narrow diagonal linear road. |
| Vehicle-74, 03 | Structural cues: compact rectangular footprint and roof-body trace. | large striped roof beside intersecting roads and grass strips with shrubs |
We held each support’s background description and all training settings fixed and varied only the target text. Adding instance structure increased mean AP by 1.71 points on Aircraft-14 and 7.29 on Vehicle-74. Mean AUC increased by 0.89 points on Vehicle-74 and was unchanged on Aircraft-14.
Table 5. Target-text ablation (%, mean ± SD)
| Target text | Aircraft-14 AP | Aircraft-14 AUC | Vehicle-74 AP | Vehicle-74 AUC |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Category sentence only | 41.25±2.27 | 97.69±0.35 | 55.23±3.42 | 92.84±1.44 |
| Category + instance structure | 42.96±4.80 | 97.69±0.41 | 62.52±1.50 | 93.73±0.95 |
To W1:
We added an independent DeepLabV3+ baseline under matched dense supervision and clarified how each adapted FSS method uses unannotated support pixels.
To W2:
We added a teacher-aggregation comparison with retrieval and KD fixed, revised the conclusions to distinguish mean performance gains from training stability, and added DeepLabV3+ comparisons on both San Diego scenes.
If any questions remain, please let us know. We will do our best to address them promptly and improve the manuscript.
Dear Reviewer, with less than three days remaining in the discussion period, we would appreciate your review of our rebuttal and your feedback on whether it addresses your concerns. Thanks again for your time and help in improving the quality of this paper.
Dear Reviewer, with less than one day remaining in the discussion period, we would appreciate your review of our rebuttal and your feedback on whether it addresses your concerns. Thanks again for your time and help in improving the quality of this paper.
Q1–Q2:
Thank you for the detailed feedback.
To Q1:
1. Standard supervised baseline. We added DeepLabV3+ (ResNet-50), trained with the same dense training-query masks, full spectral inputs, splits, and number of epochs as TCPL. Both select checkpoints by validation AP. DeepLabV3+ uses only the query image and requires no support points or text.
TCPL achieves higher mean AP and AUC in all nine dataset–budget combinations. Its AP gains range from 17.00 to 21.86 percentage points on Vehicle-74 and from 5.52 to 6.08 on Plane-400. On Aircraft-14, TCPL leads by 12.69, 0.60, and 5.06 points at 1, 3, and 5 points, respectively.
Table 1. DeepLabV3+ and TCPL (%, mean ± SD)
2. Unseen San Diego scenes. We evaluated the Aircraft-14-trained DeepLabV3+ without fine-tuning. TCPL achieved higher AP and AUC on both scenes.
Table 2. San Diego evaluation (%)
3. Unannotated support pixels. Support-point maps encode annotated foreground as 1 and all unannotated pixels as 0, including unmarked targets. HSNet masks zero-valued support features. DCAMA uses the map as attention values, with zero-valued positions still participating in attention normalization. IFA, DCDNet, and FPTrans build background prototypes or proxies from non-point positions. During downsampling, HSNet, DCAMA, and IFA use adaptive max pooling. DCDNet and FPTrans use it only when it preserves more nonzero cells than their original interpolation. All five compute the segmentation loss using dense training-query masks. MPA supervises augmented support views with correspondingly transformed point maps, counts non-point pixels as background in its loss, and uses no dense masks from independent training queries. Therefore, we report MPA as a reference under its own supervision protocol.
To Q2:
With attention retrieval fixed, the multi-support teacher improved mean AP by 4.71 points on Aircraft-14 and 5.71 on Vehicle-74, and mean AUC by 0.24 and 0.59 points, respectively. Both settings use the same four supports per query, and all four predictions receive detection supervision. The single-support teacher uses the prediction from the support least often selected as teacher for that query, breaking ties by support ID. Both use KD with identical supervised losses and optimization budgets.
Table 3. Retrieval and teacher aggregation (%, mean ± SD)
With the multi-support teacher fixed, switching from mean pooling to attention retrieval increased mean AP by 4.43 and 6.56 points on Aircraft-14 and Vehicle-74, respectively. The separate KD ablation measures the effect of adding distillation, with mean AP gains of 0.50 and 4.94 points, respectively.