- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes structured curve representations for audience engagement. It combines a GRU-driven departure model with an arrival curve to predict live-room occupancy, and separates video-specific and watch-style parameters for cross-audience retention transfer. Experiments on KuaiLive-M3 and KuaiRec report gains over neural, forecasting, and survival baselines, supported by ablations on parameter sharing, residuals, audience composition, and unknown stream duration.
Critical strengths
-
The live-stream model improves on a similarly sized shared GRU. This provides meaningful evidence that the structured output helps prediction beyond reducing the size of independent pointwise models.
-
The watch-style factorization is supported by comparisons with content-based grouping and alternative parameter allocations. These experiments provide a useful insight into what enables retention transfer across audiences.
Critical weaknesses
-
The stated occupancy definition uses each viewer’s first entry and final departure. For viewers who leave and return, this counts intervening absences as occupancy. Since the appendix explicitly considers re-entry, the treatment of repeated sessions must be clarified to establish that the main experiment predicts actual occupancy.
-
The compact whole-trajectory claim needs qualification. Live-stream parameters vary with time, so three outputs at each step do not constitute one fixed three-parameter trajectory. The evaluation also appears to use progressively updated room features, leaving unclear how much the results support forecasting beyond an observed prefix.
Questions for authors
-
Are occupancy labels constructed from every viewing session, or from each viewer’s first entry and final departure? How are intervening absences handled?
-
For Table 1, are parameters recomputed using newly available room features at each evaluated time? Does any reported experiment freeze the observed prefix and predict the subsequent trajectory?
-
Could the authors clarify how the 128-dimensional room features are generated, including the visual encoder and frame sampling, how visual information is combined with ASR/text and metadata, and the PCA reduction procedure?
2 comments
Follow-up on Rebuttal and Remaining Concerns
Dear Reviewer dRuq,
We would appreciate your feedback on whether our responses and additional experiments address your concerns. If so, we hope these clarifications can be reflected in your updated assessment. If you still have reservations, it would be helpful to understand which points remain unresolved so that we can address them before discussion closes.
Thank you for your time.
Reviewer dRuq Specific Questions (Common questions addressed on top).
We thank the reviewer for the detailed questions and constructive feedback. We address the common questions of the reviewer on instantaneous audience occupancy and fixed compact future trajectory at the top.
Construction of the 128-dimensional room features.
The 128-dimensional live-room features are not generated by us: KuaiLive-M3 ships them as timestamped segment embeddings, and the release does not include the original video, so we cannot re-encode frames or optimize the representation for occupancy. KuaiLive docs state that each feature 128 vector is a PCA reduction of an original 2,307 multimodal feature (visual, ASR/text, and related live-room signals fused before the PCA step). Public Kuaishou live-content work on the same platform describes the visual stream as a vision transformer (Swin) on sampled frames and the text stream as BERT over concatenated ASR and comments. Because we observe only the frozen 128-d PCA vectors, we cannot retune that encoder for our task; Section 4.3 (Table 5) reports the corresponding ceiling: with ideal representations the mean error would be 2.23%, versus 5.53% with the released embeddings.
We hope these clarifications and new results encourage you to raise your score.