- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a cortico-cerebellar model in which a frozen, full-rank cortical RNN receives adaptive feedback from a cerebellum-inspired module. The authors argue that this feedback reorganizes cortical activity into compact, task-separated representations, thereby reducing interference during multi-task learning.
Critical strengths
The scientific motivation is meaningful. Studying how feedback from another brain region can reorganize cortical dynamics provides a useful perspective on learning. The author perform both single task and multi-task learning. Both models perform well when tasks are trained separately, but their performance differs for multi-task continual learning. Furthermore, The component ablations are useful to show the importance of task-specific feedback.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors explain the conceptual difference from Pemberton et al. 2024. A direct comparison would help establish the additional benefits of the proposed plasticity rules and representational reorganization.
- Local rules beating gradient descent need explanation. It is surprising that gradient based optimization is about 40 times worse than the local rules.
- The training procedure needs clarification. In section C.2, from 994-1004, could the author discuss what parameters are fixed and what are trained or changed using notations you defined?
Minor:
- Figure 3A is so difficult to read.
- in equation3 is not defined.
- line 798, Figure 7 and Figure S1 are double defined and please check your figure citations.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses above.