- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Mixture-of-Microzones (MoM), a cerebellum-inspired architecture that separates fast error correction from slower sensorimotor adaptation. It uses fixed directional gating to select modules that map sensory errors to motor corrections. In simulated reaching tasks, MoM achieves behavioral correction in substantially fewer trials than the baselines. The authors also include a small learned optimization experiment to illustrate how the directional gating works.
Critical strengths
- Separation of fast correction and slow adaptation: I find this distinction interesting, and the overall architecture is fairly intuitive. Fixed directional gating is also a reasonable design choice, since it introduces some structure without having to learn a separate routing mechanism.
- Strong behavioral correction results: The reduction from roughly 16–21 trials to 4 trials is quite noticeable. The ablations are helpful here, as they suggest that both the directional gating and the direct corrective pathway contribute to this result.
Critical weaknesses
- Correction versus learning: My main concern is whether MoM actually learns faster or just corrects errors more quickly through the direct pathway. These are different things, and the experiments do not fully separate them. In fact, Table 2 shows that internalization is slightly slower for MoM than for the baselines (25 versus 21–24 trials). The cortical weights and transformation matrices are also frozen during adaptation, which makes me question how much of the improvement reflects lasting adaptation. I would like to see what happens if the direct corrective pathway is turned off after adaptation. If the improvement disappears, the claim about faster adaptation would need to be qualified.
- Limited evaluation and missing baseline: Most of the evidence comes from a simulated 2D reaching task with predefined error directions. The learned optimization example is also restricted to 2D quadratic functions. I think the current experiments are enough to show that the architecture can work in these settings, but not enough to establish how broadly useful the microzone structure is. In particular, I would like to see a comparison with a simpler learned residual feedback controller that does not use directional experts. The current ablations remove individual components of MoM, but they do not answer whether multiple directional modules are necessary in the first place.
Questions for authors
What happens to MoM's performance if the direct corrective pathway is disabled after adaptation? Does the model retain any of the improvement?
2 comments
Thank you again for your review. As the discussion period comes to an end, we wanted to kindly ask whether our response and the revised manuscript have addressed your concerns. In brief:
-
Correction versus learning. As you suggested, we disabled the direct corrective pathway after adaptation without further learning: task error and take-off error remained unchanged (Appendix A.4.2, Table 6). Freezing plasticity instead preserves rapid correction but prevents internalization (Table 5). We therefore clarify that MoM accelerates behavioral correction, rather than weight-based learning.
-
Baseline without directional experts. We added a global, non-modular residual feedback controller matched for sensory inputs, feedback delay, training budget, and model capacity. MoM achieved faster and better-aligned corrections than this baseline (Table 1, Appendix A.7, Table 8).
-
Evaluation beyond 2D reaching. We additionally evaluated MoM as a corrective adapter for a frozen, pretrained SmolVLA policy on two LIBERO robotic manipulation tasks (Appendix A.4.4, Fig. 7), complementing our existing MNIST drawing experiments (Appendix A.4.3).
We note that other reviewers acknowledged the improvements and raised their assessments following the revisions. If these additions resolve your two main concerns, we would be grateful if you would consider reflecting this in your assessment. If anything remains unclear, we would be happy to clarify it before the deadline. Thank you again for your time and consideration.
We thank the reviewer for the insightful critique and for pointing out the need to explicitly separate online correction from permanent weight-based learning, as well as the importance of comparing against a non-modular baseline.
Correction vs. Learning & Post-Adaptation Cutout: Our central claim is that MoM accelerates initial behavioral correction through its geometrically routed direct pathway, rather than accelerating weight-based internalization. As shown in Table 2 and Figure 4B, MoM achieves behavioral correction within 4 ± 2 trials, whereas internalization requires 25 ± 4 trials, compared with 21 ± 3 trials for Pemberton et al. (2024) and 24 ± 3 trials for Filipe et al. (2026). Thus, MoM's rapid behavioral compensation is accompanied by a slightly slower internalization timescale, more closely resembling the experimental adaptation dynamics shown in Figure 4B. One possible explanation is that rapid online correction reduces residual task errors and therefore the pressure for subsequent weight-based adaptation, whereas models without direct correction experience larger errors that may promote faster internalization.
To directly address whether the improvement persists after adaptation, we performed the suggested post-adaptation direct-pathway cutout (Appendix A.4.2, Table 6). After full adaptation, we disabled the direct corrective output (Δu = 0) without further learning. Task error remained essentially unchanged, from 0.05 ± 0.02 cm with the direct pathway active to 0.05 ± 0.01 cm after cutout. Similarly, take-off error was 0.5 ± 0.2° before cutout and 0.4 ± 0.1° afterward (mean ± SD across 10 seeds). These results demonstrate that the learned behavioral compensation persists without ongoing direct correction, supporting the conclusion that adaptation has been internalized into the learned controller–adapter dynamics rather than depending indefinitely on the direct corrective pathway.
Evaluation, Generalization, and Non-Modular Baseline: To assess whether directional microzones provide an advantage over a general-purpose nonlinear feedback controller, we implemented a non-modular baseline that retains the cortico-cerebellar architecture and mossy-fiber expansion but replaces the four directional microzones and geometric gating with a single global forward predictor and a nonlinear sensory-to-motor mapping. Specifically, a 2000 → 12 → 6 ReLU network predicts sensorimotor variables, while a separate 4 → 16 → 2 ReLU MLP maps delayed visual error and predicted position into joint-space corrections. This baseline contains 24,204 parameters, closely matching MoM's 24,028 active parameters. Both models receive the same sensory information and feedback delay and use the same training budget, with corrective weights frozen during adaptation (Appendix A.7).
Under visuomotor rotation, the global nonlinear controller required 13 ± 2 trials to achieve behavioral correction, compared with 4 ± 2 trials for MoM. Its corrective alignment was also lower (0.60 ± 0.15 vs. 0.91 ± 0.05; Table 1). To control for total model capacity, we additionally evaluated a wider global predictor (2000 → 24 → 6) with the same nonlinear direct pathway, yielding 48,288 parameters, closely matching MoM's 48,056 total parameters. Although this stronger baseline improved to 10 ± 3 correction trials and 0.65 ± 0.10 alignment, it remained slower and less accurately aligned than MoM (Appendix A.7, Table 8). All values are mean ± SD across 10 seeds.
These comparisons show that the benefit of MoM cannot be explained solely by the presence of a direct feedback pathway or by the number of model parameters. Instead, the results support the advantage of geometrically routing sensory errors to specialized local error-to-action transformations, producing more appropriately directed motor corrections and faster behavioral compensation. Beyond centre-out reaching, we also evaluate generalization to more complex MNIST drawing trajectories under a 30° visuomotor rotation (Appendix A.4.3, Figure 6), where MoM preserves trajectory structure immediately after perturbation and improves further with adaptation.