- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
For image SR using diffusion, authors propose to generate Y (SR) from X (LR) by controlling the trajectory of successive improvement rather that taking any arbitrary trajectory to reach Y from X. They also show that the no of steps required for diffusion is less compared to competing method.
Critical strengths
- Less number of steps for diffusion
- Good number of experimentation
- Better SOTA for reference based image quality metrics
Critical weaknesses
-
It is not at all clear why should the evolution in restoration/deblurring be along a specified trajectory? The trajectory gets decided by the anchors. It also appears that the guided path is more or less linear locally -- suggesting the manifold of the latent space is Euclidean. In general the manifold may follow quite a bit of geodesic evolution which your method does not take care. That is why you are possibly seeing a reasonable improvement in the reference-based metrics like PSNR where the Euclidean distance is finally what is matched, while it is performing poorly for no-reference quality metrics.
-
Why should I even care that X -> Y evolution must pass through a path Z? We want good results and it is the end result that you are comparing for all baseline and other methods. We do not even know if the path Z is good.
-
Despite distillation, your parameter space is very huge compared to competitors and so is the FLOP count. Then how come your latency is much lower. Is there something we are missing. What is your definition of latency.
-
It is not clear how is the fake distribution p_{fake} estimated.
Questions for authors
see above.