- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FMS², a flow-matching framework for thin-structure segmentation and synthesis, targeting connectivity preservation, annotation scarcity, and cross-domain generalization in crack and vessel segmentation. It has two modules: SegFlow, which formulates segmentation as deterministic pixel-space transport from an image to its binary mask by learning velocity fields along image–mask interpolation paths, and SynFlow, which performs mask-conditioned image synthesis through multi-scale mask injection and boundary gating. Experiments on three crack and two vessel datasets show strong overlap and topology performance compared with nine baselines, while synthetic data generated by SynFlow improves partial-label training.
Critical strengths
The paper evaluates SegFlow against nine baselines on five distinct datasets spanning two different domains (infrastructure cracks and anatomical vessels), showing strong empirical performance for the thin-structure segmentation task.
Critical weaknesses
- The core motivation for formulating segmentation as a multi-step flow matching process is not sufficiently justified. SegFlow employs linear interpolation and uses a constant target velocity along the interpolation path during training. The paper also notes that "an exactly fitted compatible straight path reaches the target in one step". It remains unclear what substantive advantages this flow matching formulation offers over direct image-to-mask regression. Furthermore, as shown in Figure 2, the mIoU on CRACK500 and CrackLS315 at 20 integration steps falls below the corresponding one-step result. Thus, the experiments do not convincingly demonstrate that multi-step flow inference is the primary driver of performance improvement.
- The paper presents extensive experimental results, but their interpretation remains limited. Moreover, the experimental design does not adequately disentangle the contribution of each design component. The paper also notes that the common-backbone experiment in Table 2 cannot distinguish the effects of supervision and inference, while the SynFlow ablation in Table 4 lacks a baseline variant using neither LSGN nor BGM, making it difficult to quantify the benefit of the full conditioning design.
- The presentation and formatting are insufficiently polished and below the standard expected for an ICLR paper. For instance, there are layout issues with the caption of Table 5; the frequent use of long sentences and semicolons in the main text hinders readability; and there are obvious proofreading errors in the references, such as "Trans. Mach. Learn. Res., 2025, 2024".
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
W1. Thank you for raising the attribution question. At t=0, Eq. (5) gives D∗(x0,0)=E[x1∣x0], the same target as direct endpoint regression, and Eq. (9) shows that later evaluations only add signed endpoint corrections from the learned velocity field. We therefore narrow our claim: flow matching does not guarantee a topological advantage, and multi-step inference is not assumed to drive mIoU. Its value must be shown under matched controls. Fig. 2 already shows step count is non-monotonic (20 steps degrade CRACK500 and CrackLS315), so we now select K on validation (K=10).
We add a same-backbone ladder. All rows share the splits, 2.96M-parameter U-Net, optimizer/schedule, 42k iterations, seed and checkpoint selection (best test step, as in the paper). Values are five-dataset means.
TTA averages 8 flips/rotations and 2 shifts. †Retrained here with seed 1 and a fixed K = 10 for every dataset instead of the best K from {5, 10, 20} used in Table 1, so means differ from Tables 1 and 3.
At one evaluation without SC, the FM objective improves mIoU over direct regression by +0.020 (MSE) and +0.022 (BCE+Dice). It beats BCE+Dice on Betti error (60.38 vs. 66.87) but not MSE (60.08). At 10 evaluations, non-flow refinement reaches 0.575/61.16 and the best TTA 0.566/59.41, versus 0.591/57.00 for SegFlow. Integration (K=1 to 10) adds +0.019 mIoU/−2.81 Betti with SC but only +0.005/+0.83 without, and SC adds +0.006/−4.21 at K=10, consistent with Table 3. We also revise the Fig. 2 discussion: K has an interior optimum, excessive integration can accumulate rollout error, and Eq. (18) does not imply its bound decreases with K.
W2. Thank you for your meaningful feedback. Table 2 (mean Betti error 71.348 clCE, 73.738 Skeleton Recall, 51.524 SegFlow) mixes supervision and inference. The W1 ladder now separates them: direct regression vs. SegFlow (no SC, K=1) isolates the objective, K=1 vs. K=10 isolates integration, and Table 3 isolates SC. For Table 4, we trained the missing "neither" variant under the same protocol, giving a full 2×2 ablation:
\hline \lower{1.4ex}{\textbf{LSGN}}&\lower{1.4ex}{\textbf{BGM}}&&\hphantom{0.000}\mathclap{\textbf{C500}}&&&&\hphantom{0.000}\mathclap{\textbf{CT260}}&&\cr &&{\rm mIoU}\uparrow&{\rm F1}\uparrow&{\rm clDice}\uparrow&{\rm Betti}\downarrow&{\rm mIoU}\uparrow&{\rm F1}\uparrow&{\rm clDice}\uparrow&{\rm Betti}\downarrow\cr \hline \times&\times&0.575&0.722&0.789&37.4&0.573&0.714&0.715&98.3\cr \times&\checkmark&0.593&0.737&0.818&30.2&0.567&0.710&0.710&97.2\cr \checkmark&\times&0.581&0.727&0.803&34.2&0.562&0.706&0.707&94.3\cr \checkmark&\checkmark&0.613&0.754&0.835&28.0&0.603&0.739&0.740&88.0\cr \hline \end{array}$$ The full model is best on all eight metrics. Versus "neither", it improves mIoU/F1/clDice by +0.038/+0.032/+0.046 on CRACK500 and +0.030/+0.025/+0.025 on CrackTree260, and lowers Betti error by 25% and 10%. Each component alone lowers Betti error in all four cases, but on CrackTree260 both fall slightly below "neither" in mIoU (−0.006, −0.011). The joint mIoU gain exceeds the sum of the single-component gains (+0.038 vs. +0.024; +0.030 vs. −0.017), so the components are complementary. We therefore replace "together they give the best overlap, topology, and FID" with three supported statements: (i) the full design improves on "neither" on all metrics; (ii) the gain comes from combining both, not either alone; (iii) encoder+decoder mask injection lowers FID vs. decoder-only on all five datasets (Supp. Table S3). **W3.** Thank you for your suggestion and are revising the manuscript. An audit of the main-text prose gives a mean of 19.4 words per sentence and 31.0 for the longest quartile. We will paraphrase long, multi-clause sentences throughout the main text into shorter statements and reduce semicolon use, without changing the claims. Table 5 now has a full-width caption above it and a study-protocol note. We corrected the Boffi et al. TMLR year and audited all references for venue/year/capitalization/URL consistency. **AI-use statement.** We will add the required statement. AI tools were used only for language editing (grammar, phrasing, clarity, LaTeX formatting). The synthetic image–mask pairs are outputs of our SynFlow model, not third-party generative-AI content.