acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Controlling Creator Exposure under Recommendation Feedback

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Recommendation platforms allocate visibility among creators and shape users’ content menus, while engagement feeds back into subsequent allocations. Controlling information oligopoly and information cocoons requires coordinating global exposure concentration and per-user variety while accounting for the randomness of serving. In this paper, we formulate the Constrained Welfare Occupancy Program (CWOP), a request-level allocation model that maximizes expected utility under concentration ceilings and per-user entropy floors. Our analysis separates the utility cost of these targets from optimization error and establishes why feasible plans can still violate targets during finite-window serving. We derive policy-dependent safety margins that provide simultaneous exposure guarantees across adaptive windows under a known request distribution and conditionally independent sampling, and bound the utility cost of certification. An anonymized real-platform audit finds that exposure concentration is approximately eight times audience-stock concentration on a matched creator subset, measured by the Herfindahl–Hirschman index, while the estimated elasticity of audience growth with respect to audience stock is approximately 0.7. These observational findings motivate direct exposure control, while our framework makes its feasibility, reliability, and utility tradeoffs explicit.

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
Recommender Systems, Market Design, Creator Economy, Two-Sided Matching, Online Content Platforms

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 9%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.50 over 4 reviews, above 9% of the others.
Reviewer_WJobOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes the Constrained Welfare Occupancy Program (CWOP), a request-level allocation model that maximizes expected utility under concentration ceilings (HHI and per-creator share caps) and per-user entropy floors. The core technical contributions include: a decomposition of welfare loss into target cost and optimization error, derivation of policy-dependent safety margins for finite-window serving, and provision of joint guarantees simultaneously satisfying HHI, share cap, and entropy constraints. Evaluation is conducted on synthetic graphs and the Last.fm dataset, along with an observational finding from an anonymous real-platform audit.

I am open to raising my score if the authors can address the following: (a) provide analysis or experiments demonstrating the practical feasibility of the safety margins under realistic parameter settings, and (b) strengthen the empirical evaluation with datasets closer to the motivating application domains. The problem setting is interesting and the formalism has potential, but the current submission needs stronger empirical grounding.

Critical strengths

Joint constraint handling with statistical guarantees: Theorem 1's simultaneous guarantee covering HHI, share cap, and per-user entropy across adaptive serving windows is technically non-trivial. Proposition 2's N^{-1/2} necessity result for the cap margin is clearly derived. The decomposition of welfare loss into "cost of the targets" and "controller gap" is a conceptually clean framework that helps distinguish constraint-induced utility loss from optimization error—a useful distinction for practitioners.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty: The core techniques of CWOP—constraint tightening, conic programming, witness mixing—are well-established in the optimization literature, as the authors themselves acknowledge through citations to Nemirovski & Shapiro (2006) and Liu et al. (2021). The application to HHI/entropy constraints in recommendation exposure control is a sensible direction, but the paper reads more as a technology transfer than a methodological contribution. The safety margin derivations rely on standard Bernstein/Chernoff bounds without introducing new analytic tools.

  2. Practical feasibility and empirical grounding are insufficient. Three things are missing, plus two smaller ones.

    • The margins are never quantified. m_c, m_H, m_u involve logarithmic terms such as ℓ_C = log(6JC/δ), which under short windows and high confidence could eat most of the available slack. If they do, "optimizing under the constraints" degrades into "the constraints are barely feasible," and the utility numbers price certification rather than measure the controller. The paper's own figures invite the question: certification costs about 4.1% relative utility on the synthetic graphs but 17.1% on Last.fm, with no breakdown of margins versus targets.
    • The evaluation domain is narrow. All reproducible experiments are synthetic graphs plus Last.fm (128 users, 256 artists). Listening is repeat-heavy and catalogue-bounded, while feed exposure is recency-driven and unbounded in candidate supply; the concentration mechanism differs, and the paper does not argue that the conclusions transfer.
    • The audit cannot be checked. It reports a ratio and an elasticity without sector, scale or time span. Appendix E and the reproducibility statement explain why absolute levels are withheld, which is fair, but coarser disclosure is usually possible. As the eight-fold ratio appears in the abstract, readers need enough to tell whether it reflects the serving mechanism or one snapshot.

    Two smaller points. Theorem 1 alone introduces over ten nested symbols. And the baseline table covers Temperature, Log-share, FairCo-style and two-sided Frank-Wolfe, but nothing from exposure-constrained policy learning: Singh & Joachims (2019) is cited as the closest prior work and never run, so the cost of the joint guarantee remains unclear against that line.

Questions for authors
  1. In a typical realistic configuration (just like several hundred creators, several thousand requests), approximately what proportion of the available constraint slack is consumed by the safety margins in Theorem 1? Are there parameter regimes where the margins occupy most of the slack, making the feasible region extremely narrow? Relatedly, how much of the 17.1% utility loss on Last.fm is attributable to the margins rather than to the targets themselves?

  2. Beyond Last.fm, have you considered evaluating CWOP on datasets closer to real recommendation scenarios? Relatedly, how would a Singh & Joachims (2019)-style policy learner fare under the same three constraints?

  3. Regarding the anonymous platform audit—could you at least disclose the industry sector of the data source, the sample size, and the time span? Without these basic details, readers cannot assess the external validity of the finding.

Reviewer_aQPwOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies content creator exposure fairness under an entropy-like metric called HHI. The paper also provides some theoretical analysis about the constraint satisfaction and utility bound. The experiment compares the proposed method with ablations and one baseline called FairCo, and demonstrate that the proposed method improves the constraint satisfaction rate.

Critical strengths
  • Content creator exposure constraints and fairness problems are well-studies, important topics in recommender systems.

  • The proposed method keeps the constraint violation rate close to zero (, while there are several limitations too, see weaknesses).

  • The paper provides some theoretical analysis on constraint satisfaction and utility bound (although I did not check every line of derivations and claims).

Critical weaknesses

The manuscript is not easy to follow, and requires too much readers' effort to understand the content. This is mainly due to lack of background context explanation and unexplained variables and concepts. The use of LLM itself is OK, but the following points should be carefully checked and addressed by the author(s). (It's not the reviewer's job to do so, to be honest.)

(1) For example, what is HHI (and PD) and why the paper focuses on this metric is not explained in the Intro, while this metric appears to be important in the manuscript. "urn model" in Section 3.1 is also not explained. (I even did not figure out what is the formal name of the abbreviations refer to for HHI, PD, and URN.)

(2) In notation, cc is neither explained or formally defined, even though I can still guess c∈Cc \in \mathcal{C} is a content (and it required lots of effort in understanding).

(3) Also, some terminology are not following standards, e.g., "information cacoons" are often referred to as "filter bubbles" in recommendation context.

(4) The main text of the paper should be self-contained, and what "dual-box assumption in Theorem 6" is should be briefly explained in the main text, even though the paper refers to the Appendix for the detailed explanation.

(5) Either citation or URLs should be provided for public data, e.g., LastFM. Also, FairCo in the experiment should need citation to clarify that it is a baseline approach, even if the citation is provided in the related work section.


Aside from writing, the following is considered weaknesses of the paper.

  • The paper do not discuss why HHI is a reasonable metric to look at. "Interpreting concentration and variety" in Section 2 explains what it is, however, it neither discuss if HHI is a common metric (I don't think this is a common metric, but if this is already used in some existing work, citation should be included), nor explain why this metric is preferable over some existing metrics.

  • Empirical study is insufficient, specifically about the choice of baselines. There are mainly three points to mention.

  • (1) First, if I understand correctly, only FairCo is considered as baselines from related work. While the paper discusses in the related work that the proposed method is advantageous than existing work in handling potential non-linear reward function for ranking of items, if this claim holds true should be examined in the experiment section. If there is tradeoff between modeling non-linear case and guaranteeing exposure fairness, such a tradeoff should be carefully discusses in the paper, including empirical observations.

  • (2) The second point is, FairCo is not explained enough, and the only explanation is found in related work as "(FairCo) combine allocation with online control or learning". Because this serves as a baseline model in the experiment, the detailed discussion about what this method does and how the combination of the proposed method with FairCo can improve the original one should be explained (e.g., "original FairCo do not apply Eq.xx in the paper", etc.)

  • (3) In the synthetic setup, the proposed method keeps high utility score, while also constraining the violation rate to be near-zero. However, in the real data regime with LastFM, the results demonstrate the significant drop in the utility score compared to FairCo while the proposed method achieves near-zero violation. I'm not really sure from this result if the proposed method can achieve a good tradeoff in practical situations.

  • Missing related work. The "look-ahead" type of planning policy or adaptive planning is often used in control theory to avoid this type of constraint violation. The paper does not discuss the connection with these algorithms in related work. I believe this is closely connected to the proposed method, as both approach tries to avoid/reach specific constraint/goal taking the effect of noise in transition into account.

Questions for authors

Please write rebuttals with author(s)' own words, as LLM-generated sentence may be hallucinated and is hard to follow.

  • Is HHI a standard metric? If not, why the paper specifically looks at HHI?

  • What is "dual-box assumption in Theorem 6"?

  • What is the connection to "look-ahead" type of planning policy or adaptive planning that are often used in control theory? And what is the advantage of the proposed approach other these methods?

  • What is the baseline method FairCo, and how is it different from the proposed method?

Reviewer_UuC2OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This submission designs an allocation model that maximizes expected utility under constraints on creator concentration and variety in a user’s recommendations in a recommender system setting. This work is motivated by the observation that recommender systems can create feedback loops (where exposure to content produces engagement, which then influences subsequent exposure), which can concentrate visibility among just a few creators and narrow individual users’ recommendations.

The setting is as follows: the platform operates over “serving windows”, where at the beginning of each window, it receives a request distribution, eligible recommendation options, and utility scores. It then selects a policy mapping requests to distributions over recommendation options. There are different types of requests, and each type has a known probability and set of eligible recommendations.

The authors introduce Constrained Welfare Occupancy Program (CWOP), which maximizes user utility subject to a ceiling on “HHI”, which is a measure of how unevenly recommendation exposure is distributed across creators. They implement this program using both conic programming and a primal-dual algorithm.

The experiments in this paper measure how accurately CWOP solves the constrained optimization problem, whether targets hold under feedback-driven serving, and whether their approach transfers to a public listening-derived graph.

Critical strengths

I believe that this specific model of creator constraints, per-user diversity constraints, and guarantees for realized exposure over finite windows has not been studied in the literature. I appreciated that the authors ran experiments to empirically evaluate their mechanism.

Critical weaknesses

The paper was extremely hard to read from start to finish. Key parts of the model are not explained (or not explained well), and there is often very little tying the sections together. For instance, the jump from Section 3 to Section 4 was especially hard for me to follow. I think that the writing of this submission is nowhere near the quality required for publication in a venue like ICLR.

Given the state of the writing, it is very difficult to evaluate the quality of the model, the theoretical results, or the experimental results. That being said, the individual ingredients that make up this setting (exposure fairness, diversity constraints, etc.) have all been studied in the recommender systems literature before, so the conceptual novelty is a weakness.

Questions for authors

None.

Reviewer_Z785OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how recommendation systems can limit creator exposure concentration while maintaining variety within each request type’s recommendations. The main motivation is that satisfying exposure constraints in expectation does not guarantee that recommendations sampled over a finite window will satisfy them. The proposed Constrained Welfare Occupancy Program (CWOP) maximizes expected recommendation scores subject to a global concentration ceiling, a maximum creator-share constraint, and a minimum entropy constraint for each request type. The authors conducted experiments using synthetic and last fm data, to evaluate the resulting utility–reliability tradeoff.

Critical strengths

The formulation addresses complementary exposure problems. Balanced aggregate exposure does not necessarily provide variety within each user’s recommendations, while local variety does not prevent global concentration. The two-user example explains this distinction clearly, and global-only and local-only ablations demonstrate the corresponding failure modes.

Critical weaknesses

The main theorem assumes known request probabilities, independent sampling, and a policy frozen within each window, which may not hold true in many practical scenarios. It would be useful if the authors conduct experiments on settings with estimated or drifting request frequencies, dependent requests, or strongly uneven user activity to evaluate the proposed method's performance.

The computational cost of certified replanning remains insufficiently characterized. End-to-end runtimes, including certification and repair, are needed to clarify its practical runtime–accuracy tradeoff.

Questions for authors

How sensitive is certification to errors in request probabilities, especially for infrequent users? A small experiment with uneven or drifting request frequencies would help assess the assumptions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.