- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
- Scenes and images are commonly represented by Gaussian or triangle primitives. These primitives are independent, require many parameters per primitive, and can be inefficiently arranged with overlap, making them poorly suited to memory-constrained settings.
- The paper proposes hexels that use fewer parameters per primitive and can fully tile a plane without overlap. Motivated by the smooth variation of most textures, each hexel represents appearance as a linear variation within its hexagonal region.
- The method achieves high image fidelity under limited memory and primitive counts, and demonstrates efficiency in FPS, storage, and training VRAM.
Critical strengths
- The paper proves that, within the same local color-error ellipse, affine hexagons cover more area than other tileable primitives, mathematically demonstrating their efficiency under this constraint.
- When fewer primitives are used, each primitive needs to represent texture over a larger region. Linearly varying appearance within each hexel helps reduce the error over these larger regions.
- The paper proposes variants with different levels of appearance modeling, including spherical harmonics, showing that memory efficiency can be combined with high appearance fidelity.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper relies heavily on empirical comparisons throughout. Even the abstract largely lists numerical improvements and differences. This makes it difficult to read and does not adequately explain why the method is superior. A paper should explain its objective, how the method is constructed, which problems in existing methods it addresses, and why its design produces the reported improvements. Simply claiming that it is better because its numbers are higher is not sufficiently convincing. Referring to the models as V1, V2, and V3 makes them difficult to distinguish. The settings should have descriptive labels, be evaluated separately, or be presented as one main model with the others treated as ablations. Section 3.1 has no corresponding Section 3.2 and discusses experimental results despite not being part of the experiments section. T&T should be introduced explicitly as Tanks and Temples, even if researchers in the area recognize the abbreviation. Some equations also lack numbers. I would normally regard writing issues as minor camera ready corrections that do not affect the score, but in this paper I think most sections need to be rewritten.
-
Hexels are interesting, but I question why hexagons are the right choice. The paper and appendix establish that hexagons are efficient planar patches within a common local color-error ellipse. In Gaussian and triangle splatting, primitive sizes vary substantially. Although this variation can require overlap, using larger primitives that partially overlap may be more efficient. With that freedom, other primitives such as triangles may represent scenes more efficiently, while their compatibility with triangle meshes offers additional advantages, as in Triangle Splatting and MeshSplatting. Squares or rectangles may also be more natural for the many rectangular and right-angled structures in real scenes. An argument about filling a plane is not convincing enough when actual representations involve varying primitive sizes and scene boundaries.
Questions for authors
-
Apart from the use of hexagons, I do not see the fundamental difference from existing methods, particularly Triangle Splatting. Smooth representations for differentiable rendering in Triangle Splatting and local 2D coordinate systems, as in 2DGS, have already been used. The weighted-sum rendering used in the paper's 2D image branch also has a precedent in Image-GS. With the reason for using hexagons itself insufficiently convincing, the technical novelty is unclear to me.
-
Line 58 treats overlap between other primitives as a disadvantage, but it is unclear why overlap is inherently undesirable. As discussed above, overlap can be more efficient. More importantly, this method also uses a smooth representation for differentiable rendering and combines overlapping primitives. This seems contradictory. Although Gaussian splats cannot tile a plane, Triangle Splatting also uses a smooth representation that produces overlap, and I do not see why Hexels would be fundamentally different in this respect.
-
The tables use too many colors, making them difficult to distinguish in some viewing conditions or in grayscale. Highlighting all first-, second-, and third-place results, including ties, within each model group can leave almost every cell in a column colored. Beyond readability, the methods address the same task, and Hexels do not appear to offer a distinctive post-training advantage unavailable to the others, for example, an exclusive ability to use the learned representation as a mesh (just an example). I therefore do not see why the groups need separate state-of-the-art highlighting.
-
Spherical harmonics account for much of the storage and per-primitive parameter count in methods such as 3DGS and 2DGS. Comparing V1, which represents only view-independent color, against the original 3DGS under the same memory limit is therefore unfair (Table 2, Figure 1). Although the comparison is intended to address resource-constrained settings, the baselines are not configured for that purpose. If the comparison uses ordinary NVS models, their memory limits should be relaxed; alternatively, it should include methods designed to reduce memory, such as NeuralGS [1].
The following are minor editorial suggestions for the camera-ready version and do not affect my review score:
- The paper title and model name differ; this should be clarified.
- The citation for 3D Convex Splatting needs to be corrected.
- Correct missing spaces such as “primitive.Across” at line 36.
[1] Tang et al. NeuralGS: Bridging Neural Fields and 3D Gaussian Splatting for Compact 3D Representations
18 comments
Official Comment for W1
To summarize my response: W1 is a writing issue. My main concern is the insufficient explanation of the background and limitations of existing work, together with the lack of in-depth analysis of the results. The addition of the ablation in Figure 6 offers some improvement, but I still believe that the writing and structure of much of the manuscript need improvement.
The response appears to misunderstand the point of W1: this weakness concerns how the paper is written. For example, the abstract is the first part readers encounter. It should both persuade them to read further and make the overall work easy to understand. It should explain the research background, what problem remains, why it is a problem and needs to be addressed, what idea is proposed to address it, what results follow, and why that idea leads to improvements. The method and its results are reasonably apparent in the current abstract, but the other parts of this explanation are insufficient.
More specifically, the first sentence (lines 30–32) concludes the background discussion without adequately explaining what has prevented existing methods from addressing the problem or why resolving it matters. Lines 36–46 then largely describe results as better than the baselines or state numerical differences directly. They provide little deeper explanation of why these results were obtained or where the improvements would be particularly useful.
Listing all these numerical differences individually may be meaningful to the authors, but to readers, each becomes just another positive number in a long list. This takes up space and makes the paper harder to read. Readers could obtain these differences simply by looking at the tables without reading the surrounding text; the prose adds little information beyond what the tables already provide. What readers need is a deeper analysis that explains the results and supports their interpretation: where existing models fail, why they fail, how the proposed model improves on them, and which particular improvements lead to the reported outcomes. Reporting higher numbers demonstrates a performance difference, but does not by itself establish that explanation.
The evaluation on 34 real-world scenes can certainly be a strength. However, presenting a broad set of experimental results without sufficiently deep analysis is not enough. For example, the paper could explain that a particular dataset contains many surfaces with smoothly varying colors, examine whether an existing method struggles to represent those variations efficiently because each primitive has its own spatially constant color, and show how that limitation manifests in the reconstruction. It should then explain which aspect of Hexels addresses that limitation and provide targeted evidence that this accounts for the observed difference. This is the kind of analysis I am asking for, rather than simply stating that one method achieves a higher score than another.
I have seen the newly added ablation in Figure 6, and it is an improvement in this direction. Nevertheless, the ablation should compare against a broader range of methods and provide a more fine-grained explanation of the differences among them, with those observations connected to the analysis of the preceding experiments.
W1 did not identify the mathematical proof as a weakness. I included it in the Critical Strengths because the paper makes an effort to provide a mathematical basis for its design. That does not remove the concern raised in W2 about the scope of that justification. The paper uses tiling as a motivation and treats overlap in existing methods as a source of inefficiency. Yet, as also illustrated in the newly added Figure 5, the Hexels vary substantially in size and overlap with one another.
The result under a common local color-error ellipse addresses a restricted comparison of individual patches. It does not establish that hexagons are more efficient than other shapes in the actual representation, where primitive sizes, positions, and overlaps can vary and be jointly optimized. Thus, while I recognize the mathematical contribution under its stated conditions, I remain strongly unconvinced that it sufficiently justifies the advantage of hexagons over other structures in this setting.
Response to Review (Part 2)
W2. Why hexagons?
Our objective is to exploit the structure of natural scenes to improve efficiency at the primitive itself: locally planar geometry and smoothly varying appearance (§1, lines 70–87). Hexagonal support and first-order color jointly let one primitive represent a larger coherent region, while smaller Hexels capture boundaries and detail. This is the motivation explained in the introduction’s “Why a hexagon?” paragraph and developed mathematically in Appendix I.
The size and overlap freedom described in the review is already present in our comparisons. Each Hexel independently learns its position, orientation, and two tangent scales (§3, Eq. (1)); we impose neither equal-sized cells nor a fixed tessellation. Gaussian and triangle baselines also retain their native freedom to resize and overlap, and their growth/pruning policies are retained in the main matched-primitive experiment subject to the final population budget (Appendices C and E.3). Hexels nevertheless achieve better rendering quality and lower training VRAM among the compared native surface-aligned primitives under these budgets (Tables 2-3).
The mathematical argument also goes beyond plane filling. The honeycomb theorem motivates perimeter efficiency for equal-area planar partitions. Our own analysis connects appearance error to the region represented by one primitive: within the same local color-error ellipse, the largest affine hexagon covers twice the area of the largest affine triangle and about 1.299× that of the largest affine square (Appendix I.1–I.2). Translation, rotation, and anisotropic scaling are allowed and the affine-square comparison includes rectangles. The presence of rectangular structures alone therefore does not establish a better overall quality-efficiency trade-off for rectangular primitives.
We further ablate Hexels in two additional experiments. Section 4.4 crosses Gaussian/hexagonal support with constant/spatial RGB. Fixing normals and depth order approximates a local planar surface patch without coupled changes in reconstructed geometry and visibility. On the shaded target, gradient Hexels reach 37.07 dB versus 35.13 dB for gradient Gaussians, with 2.48 versus 10.47 blends per pixel. This causally ablates Hexels.
For 3D, we equip 2DGS and Triangle Splatting with the same V1 spatial color model and evaluate all nine Mip-NeRF360 scenes with exactly the same primitive count, no densification or pruning, and the same training-step budget and main hyperparameters. All three models use approximately 9 MB storage memory, retaining their native geometric parameterizations and renderers.
| Method | Peak VRAM (GiB) ↓ | PSNR ↑ | SSIM ↑ | LPIPS ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2DGS + V1 color | 4.95 | 23.73 | 0.6685 | 0.4521 |
| Triangle Splatting + V1 color | 0.9 | 18.70 | 0.4596 | 0.6253 |
| Hexels V1 | 0.9 | 24.84 | 0.7053 | 0.4104 |
Hexels achieve the best result on all three quality metrics, improving PSNR by 1.11 dB over 2DGS and 6.14 dB over Triangle Splatting. Their advantage therefore persists when both spatial appearance and primitive count are held fixed.
Triangle Splatting produces independent triangles; MeshSplatting adds connectivity, and both are already included in our comparisons (Appendix J). Hexels also directly export independent, differentiable surface cells retaining geometry and appearance (§4.3; Appendix H.1). Our practical objective is demonstrated by the complete on-device training and reconstruction/NVS workflow, which we will release as an open-source iPhone/iPad app (Appendix H.2). The case for Hexels therefore combines a structural motivation, mathematical bounds, controlled experiments, strong budgeted results, and a practical deployment-not simply an argument about tiling a plane.
Q1. Technical differences from Triangle Splatting
Hexels have a different primitive parameterization, support function, and spatial appearance. The contribution is a compact native surface primitive that jointly exploits local geometry and appearance to improve the quality-efficiency trade-off (§3, Eqs. (1)- (4); Appendix I).
Compared with the original Triangle Splatting formulation:
- Geometry: Hexels optimize a center, orientation, and two tangent scales defining an affine canonical hexagon, rather than three independent triangle vertices.
- Support and sharpness: Hexels evaluate a sigmoid boundary in perspective-correct local plane coordinates. Triangle Splatting uses a ReLU/power window constructed from projected triangle-edge distances. Hexel β controls the sigmoid boundary transition; Triangle’s learned exponent controls its triangular falloff (§3, Eqs. (2)–(3); Appendix B).
- Spatial appearance: Every Hexel variant contains the field c₀ + u gᵤ + v gᵥ, optionally augmented with view dependence. Original Triangle Splatting uses per-triangle SH appearance without this intrinsic spatial field (§3, Eq. (4); Appendix A.1).
W1. it is better because its numbers are higher
The paper already explains its objective and design rationale; we have further clarified these in the revised abstract, introduction, and related work. Our objective is to design a surface aligned general (2D and 3D) primitive which is efficient across the board (memory, VRAM, rendering speed) without sacrificing quality (NVS and surface reconstruction) especially when under constraints which come with edge device deployment. Under matched budgets, Hexels substantially outperforms the compared native surface-aligned primitives, as detailed below.
In Section 1 itself, we introduce our motivation (mentioned later in the paper as well) -
We are motivated by the idea that natural images and scenes are highly structured: large regions are often locally planar with smoothly varying appearance. An efficient surface primitive should therefore be able to exploit this underlying structure, wherever possible, and do so in a compact and self-contained manner.(§1, lines 70–87)We then explain how we go about solving this problem by mathematical analysis. To efficiently cover a plane, we need a tile-able shape which covers the plane with least overdraw and something which can represent the locally varying colors. None of these problems are trivial to solve. Appendix I.1 derives local approximation-error bounds for affine color. Appendix I.2 shows that, within the same local color-error ellipse, the largest affine hexagon covers twice the area of the largest affine triangle. Both are discussed and referenced in the main draft. In fact, both the coverage argument and the benefit of spatial color over larger regions are recognized in your Critical Strengths. We provide explicit local color-approximation and patch-area bounds supporting the joint design; the comparison with triangles is therefore mathematical as well as empirical.
Hexels are designed using such ideas - Section 3 gives the construction in Eqs. (1)-(4). Section 2 and Appendix J distinguish this objective from moving appearance into separate textures or neural fields, or relying on post-training compression. Although the matched-primitive experiments ablates the Hexel design as a whole per primitives compared to other surface aligned primitives, we have added Section 4.4 as a controlled planar shape/color ablation for further support our methodology. In fact, we even have a supplementary video, which explains the ideas briefly and even visualizes Hexel optimization.
The empirical comparisons test whether this theoretically motivated design delivers the intended quality–efficiency benefits. We evaluate 34 real-world NVS scenes-to our knowledge, the largest scene-count evaluation among all the compared methods (§4). At matched model memory, Hexels improves PSNR by 4.53-7.38 dB over 2DGS and 1.70-2.90 dB over Triangle Splatting, with lower training VRAM than both across all three benchmarks (Table 2). Together with the matched-primitive results (Table 3), these substantial margins support our state-of-the-art claim among the compared native surface-aligned primitives under matched budgets. These quality and efficiency margins support our hypothesis that exploiting local geometry and appearance improves primitive efficiency. Our justification combines design intuition, mathematical bounds, controlled ablations, and broad empirical evaluation.
The contributions also extend beyond benchmark scores. Hexels directly expose differentiable surface cells retaining geometry and spatial appearance, with O(1) work per primitive (§4.3; Appendix H.1). We will release a fully open-source iPhone/iPad app for the complete on-device workflow from images/videos through training to surface reconstruction and NVS; to our knowledge, this would be the first such release for a native surface-aligned primitive (Appendix H.2).
V1-V3 are already defined and evaluated separately: V1: spatial RGB; V2: spatial RGB + linear view dependence; V3: spatial RGB + SH (§3, lines 190–198; Appendix A.1; Tables 3 and 14–15). Descriptive labels can be added alongside this shorthand, if it helps reviewer keep better track. We chose these shorthands to reduce cognitive load.
Section 3.1 deliberately keeps the compact 2D formulation and evaluation together. Tanks and Temples is already spelled out in the abstract and introduction; we can explicitly pair it with T&T. Core Eqs. (1)-(4) are numbered; short expressions not subsequently cross-referenced were left unnumbered. These presentation details can be clarified without rewriting most sections.