- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents an approach for molecule generation from mass spectra that relies on the definition of a search space (states and actions) that guarantees chemical validity of the generated molecules.
Critical strengths
The approach is guaranteed to generate valid molecules, something that most alternative solutions cannot do.
Results show that the approach outperforms existing alternatives in a challenging benchmark, especially on top 10% de-novo structure identification.
Critical weaknesses
The work is presented as compiling science into generative models, hinting at a general approach that is valid across multiple scientific domains. However compilation in the paper is a principle rather than a technique, and the work specifically focuses on defining an instruction program for molecule generation from mass spectra. The contribution is thus overstated in the current form in my opinion.
The presentation is very much focused on the application task, and it is hard to follow for readers lacking domain expertise. There was no attempt at broadening the contribution or framing it in a way that simplifies as follow-up adaptation to other domains and tasks.
Questions for authors
You state that the exclusion criterion of very close structural neighbours was impossible due to computational cost. How does this affect the results? are results of different methods really comparable?