- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper predicts reaction steps through discrete electron moves. Each move preserves the total electron count. A local validity table controls when the model can stop. The method achieves accuracy close to Discrete FlowER and produces interpretable reaction arrows. Experiments cover several model sizes and distribution shifts.
Critical strengths
-
Each move preserves electrons by construction. The model does not need to learn this constraint from data. This directly addresses an important failure mode in reaction generation.
-
The method retains competitive accuracy while producing explicit reaction arrows. Comparisons across model sizes and distribution shifts support the usefulness of this design.
-
Fig. 2 is particularly helpful for understanding the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
-
The distinction from constrained autoregressive prediction is unclear. Eq. 13 trains next-move prediction on fixed action sequences. The paper should explain what the flow-matching formulation adds. This affects the assessment of its methodological novelty.
-
The added value of learning arrow sequences is not fully established. Tab. 3 evaluates agreement with expert arrows. However, it lacks a comparison with arrows reconstructed from the same reactant–product pairs using the paper’s decomposition method. This control is needed to show what the learned trajectories add beyond the reaction endpoints.
Questions for authors
-
How does Eq.13 differ from constrained autoregressive training on the same action sequences?
-
What is the validity rate before candidate replacement? Which validity conditions are guaranteed by the local table?
-
How often does deterministic factorization of the recorded endpoints recover the expert arrows in Tab. 3?
The new experiments resolve my concerns about fallbacks and the checker, and Table R16 is a useful addition. However, they also confirm that filtered Discrete FlowER matches AFM on accuracy and validity, and that arrow agreement follows from any correct product. The case for AFM now rests on efficiency and mechanism-level capabilities. That is a different contribution from the one the paper makes. The supporting evidence is preliminary: several results are partly guaranteed by construction or lack a chance baseline, and the evaluation-cost comparison depends on how evaluations are counted. I have raised my score slightly to reflect the resolved concerns, but I think the reframed contribution needs to be developed in the paper itself rather than in the rebuttal.