- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SYSURV, a non-parametric, differentiable framework for discovering interpretable subgroups with unusually high or low survival outcomes. Unlike traditional methods that rely on restrictive modeling assumptions or discretized features, SYSURV captures individual heterogeneity and generates human-readable subgroup rules.
Critical strengths
The paper tackles a practical problem in survival analysis by identifying interpretable subgroups with exceptional survival characteristics. The proposed SYSURV based measure is interesting, particularly its non-parametric and differentiable formulation. The evaluation across multiple datasets, including a real-world cancer case study, helps demonstrate its potential practical relevance.
Critical weaknesses
-
While the empirical results demonstrate improvements over existing methods, the paper provides limited theoretical justification for why SYSURV should outperform competing approaches. Further analysis of the underlying mechanisms would help strengthen the methodological contributions.
-
It is not entirely clear whether the main contribution is a novel subgroup discovery method or primarily a new measure for evaluating survival subgroups. The authors should better clarify the methodological novelty and distinguish the proposed approach from existing methods.
Questions for authors
-
Although the empirical results suggest possible improvements over existing methods, the paper lacks sufficient theoretical analysis explaining why the proposed approach should outperform competing baselines. Does the gain come from the newly propose measure, or this measure combined with typical survival analysis methods? Additional theoretical insights or analysis of the underlying mechanisms would strengthen the methodological contributions.
-
It is not entirely clear whether the main contribution is a new evaluation measure or a fundamentally new subgroup discovery method. The authors should better clarify the methodological novelty and distinguish SYSURV from existing approaches.
-
Could the authors clarify whether the figures presented in the paper are generated from real-world experimental results or are primarily illustrative examples?
We thank the reviewer for their feedback. A theoretical analysis of our objective and the logrank is included (Appx. J); we made it more explicit (Appx. J, Empirical Analysis, Table 2, Figures 9 and 10), complementing our theoretical guarantees in Appx. E. We address the questions below:
Theoretical and Empirical Justification. The performance advantage stems from two complementary methodological mechanisms:
Theoretical advantage under crossing curves and delayed tails (Appx. J, Appx. E): The logrank test evaluates signed differences (Ot−Et). Under crossing survival curves, positive and negative deviations cancel out (Z→0), blinding the test to strong survival divergence. In contrast, SySurv's objective measures individual pointwise absolute deviations ∣Si(t)−Spop(t)∣, which are strictly positive and cannot cancel (formally analyzed in Appx. J; see also theoretical recovery guarantees in Appx. E). In the newly added Appx. J (Empirical Analysis, Table 2, Figure 9), we empirically validate this in an exhaustive search space: under crossing survival curves, logrank objective search collapses into background noise due to cancellation, whereas SySurv's objective preserves monotonic rank alignment and reliably recovers the true subgroup. Under delayed tail separation (Figure 10), logrank similarly degrades because late-emerging divergence is diluted by aggregate statistics, while SySurv's individual-first measure consistently succeeds.
Continuous optimization over discretization: The pre-discretization ablation in Appx. K.3 (Table 11) shows that continuous interval optimization avoids quantization artifacts inherent to fixed binning. Furthermore, in Appx. K.3 (Table 14), subgroup retrieval scales directly with the predictive accuracy of the underlying survival estimator, as formally bounded by Prop. E.2.
In summary, SySurv’s measure restores sensitivity for crossing curves and delayed tail divergence where aggregate tests fail, while continuous optimization eliminates quantization and search bottlenecks faced by combinatorial methods. Both advances combined drive the empirical improvements.
Core Methodological Contribution. You are right that SySurv’s methodological contribution cannot be reduced to a singular difference over existing methods. SySurv's methodological contribution is an integrated subgroup discovery framework: the differentiable exceptionality measure, continuous interval optimization, and decoupled individual survival regression each fill a distinct purpose. The individual survival divergence measure itself, as well as the unified end-to-end differentiable pipeline, represents the main methodological contribution. We have clarified this in the revised manuscript (Section 1).
Figures. All figures for postoperative cancer, unemployment data, and HNSCC were discovered by SySurv on real-world datasets. We have updated figure captions throughout the manuscript to explicitly distinguish empirical findings from illustrative schematics:
Fig. 1: Real-world empirical survival curves discovered by SySurv on the postoperative cancer cohort (left) and unemployment benchmark data (right).
Fig. 2: Illustrative schematic depicting theoretical survival curve relationships.
Fig. 6: Real-world empirical Kaplan-Meier curves for subgroups discovered on the HNSCC cohorts.