- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents ES4Surv, an evidence-seeking multimodal large language model for whole-slide image survival prediction. Built upon WSI-LLaVA, the method first encodes global slide context and then uses decoder-generated queries to retrieve high-resolution local patches through query-conditioned adaptive grouping. The selected patches are reintroduced into the model for final survival prediction. Experiments on five TCGA cohorts show a macro DSS C-index of 0.738, and the method additionally provides a traceable record of the selected tissue groups and local patches.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed coarse-to-fine evidence-seeking design is well motivated by the diagnostic workflow of pathologists: it first establishes global slide context and then retrieves high-resolution local evidence for survival prediction.
-
The method records which tissue groups and local patches are selected for each prediction, making the evidence-acquisition process traceable and providing additional cues for assessing whether a prediction is trustworthy.
Critical weaknesses
-
The reported absolute gains are comparable to the across-fold standard deviations. Please report fold-wise paired results and appropriate paired statistical tests or confidence intervals to establish whether the improvements over WSI-LLaVA and strong non-LLM baselines are statistically reliable.
-
ES4Surv provides only modest gains over its WSI-LLaVA backbone (0.726 to 0.738) and strong non-LLM baselines (e.g., SlotSPE: 0.722), despite introducing a 7B MLLM and additional retrieval/decoding steps. Please provide inference-cost comparisons and further justify whether the added complexity is warranted.
-
ES4Surv builds upon the strong WSI-LLaVA baseline, but the proposed technical components do not convincingly demonstrate a statistically reliable improvement. In Table 2, slide-adaptive grouping alone yields a negligible gain over fixed grouping (0.724 vs. 0.722), and the full query-conditioned design improves the mean score to 0.738 without fold-wise paired results or significance tests. Thus, it remains unclear whether the proposed design yields a robust improvement beyond the strong baseline.
-
While the evidence-acquisition path is traceable, its pathological validity remains insufficiently validated. The paper shows which groups and patches are selected, but does not establish whether they correspond to clinically meaningful prognostic evidence. Expert evaluation, comparison with pathology annotations, or intervention-based analyses would strengthen the claim that the retrieved evidence is trustworthy.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.