- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the sensitivity of discrete-time survival models to the number of temporal intervals and proposes jointly optimizing temporal resolution and effect flexibility . The authors develop a temporal-basis parameterization with theoretical results on risk decomposition, minimax rates, and adaptive model selection. Experiments on synthetic and real-world survival datasets show improvements in prediction loss.
However, the paper has two major weaknesses: (1) limited methodological and theoretical novelty relative to established survival modeling and statistical learning literature, and (2) insufficient evidence of statistically robust and practically meaningful improvements over existing methods.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a useful perspective on distinguishing temporal discretization from the complexity of time-varying covariate effects. The unified (K M) formulation helps explain why increasing the number of time intervals can have different effects across survival model architectures.
Critical weaknesses
1. Limited methodological and theoretical novelty.
The central methodological idea is not novel. In particular, Perperoglou et al. (2006) [1] already represented time-varying covariate effects using temporal basis functions, yielding a \times coefficient matrix. The parameter corresponds directly to the proposed , as both specify the number of temporal basis functions used to represent covariate effects. Their work further investigated reduced-rank constraints on the coefficient matrix to obtain models with different levels of flexibility. Similarly, Tutz and Binder (2004) [2] had already introduced regularized basis expansions for time-varying effects in discrete-time survival models.
Moreover, controlling the complexity of time-varying effects through smoothing, regularization, or model selection has been extensively investigated. Kauermann (2005) [3] studied penalized spline smoothing for varying-coefficient survival models, Yan and Huang (2012) [4] investigated model selection between time-invariant and time-varying effects, and Perperoglou (2013) [5] further developed reduced-rank hazard regression with fixed and time-varying effects. Therefore, the proposed temporal-basis parameterization and the use of a complexity parameter have clear methodological precedents. The paper does not convincingly explain what is fundamentally new beyond adopting a DCT basis and jointly tuning the temporal resolution and effect dimension.
The theoretical novelty is also limited. The approximation–estimation trade-offs, minimax convergence analysis, and adaptive model-selection guarantees are based on well-established statistical principles. Closely related theoretical frameworks, including adaptive estimation and minimax analysis for conditional intensity models under anisotropic regularity, have already been developed by Comte et al. (2011) [6]. Although the exact model classes and risk functions differ, the paper does not clearly demonstrate which theoretical results go beyond existing statistical estimation and model-selection theory.
Overall, the paper appears to repackage established methodological ideas and statistical learning principles into a \times framework. The extensive theoretical analysis does not, by itself, establish a substantive methodological or theoretical advance.
References
[1] Perperoglou A, Cessie S, van Houwelingen H C. Reduced‐rank hazard regression for modelling non‐proportional hazards[J]. Statistics in Medicine, 2006, 25(16): 2831-2845.
[2] Tutz G, Binder H. Flexible modelling of discrete failure time including time‐varying smooth effects[J]. Statistics in Medicine, 2004, 23(15): 2445-2461.
[3] Kauermann G. Penalized spline smoothing in multivariable survival models with varying coefficients[J]. Computational statistics & data analysis, 2005, 49(1): 169-186.
[4] Yan J, Huang J. Model selection for Cox models with time-varying coefficients[J]. Biometrics, 2012, 68(2): 419-428.
[5] Perperoglou A. Reduced rank hazard regression with fixed and time‐varying effects of the covariates[J]. Biometrical journal, 2013, 55(1): 38-51.
[6] Comte F, Gaïffas S, Guilloux A. Adaptive estimation of the conditional intensity of marker-dependent counting processes[C]//Annales de l'IHP Probabilités et statistiques. 2011, 47(4): 1171-1196.
2. Insufficient evidence of statistically robust and practically meaningful improvements.
Although the paper reports improvements in continuous-time RC-NLL, the improvements in standard survival prediction metrics are generally very small. In Appendix Figure 10, 20 of the 24 dataset–head combinations exhibit absolute Harrell's C-index changes smaller than 0.005, with most improvements outside METABRIC being on the order of or smaller. Excluding METABRIC, the average C-index improvement is only approximately 0.00075. Similar patterns can be observed for integrated dynamic AUC and IBS.
More importantly, the paper does not report confidence intervals or statistical significance tests for these standard survival prediction metrics. Although Figure 9 provides descriptive fold-level intervals for RC-NLL, comparable uncertainty analyses are absent for C-index, AUC, and IBS. Consequently, it remains unclear whether these small improvements are statistically reliable or practically meaningful.
Furthermore, the primary comparison is against the unrestricted baseline. Since reducing temporal effect complexity naturally acts as a form of regularization, the observed improvements may largely reflect conventional bias–variance trade-offs rather than a distinct advantage of the proposed framework. The paper does not provide sufficiently strong comparisons against existing temporal smoothing or regularization approaches in the learned-representation experiments.
Overall, the experiments demonstrate that restricting model complexity can improve RC-NLL, but do not convincingly establish that introducing provides statistically robust, practically significant, or methodologically distinct benefits beyond standard regularization and hyperparameter tuning.
Questions for authors
Q1. Methodological and theoretical novelty relative to prior work.
Perperoglou et al. (2006) [1] already modeled time-varying covariate effects using temporal basis functions, where plays essentially the same role as the proposed . Similarly, Tutz and Binder (2004) [2] studied regularized basis expansions in discrete-time survival models, while subsequent work [3–5] explored temporal smoothing, model selection, and reduced-rank representations.
What is the fundamental methodological novelty of introducing , beyond adopting a DCT basis and jointly tuning and ?
Furthermore, approximation–estimation trade-offs, adaptive estimation, and minimax convergence analysis have been extensively studied in statistical learning and survival analysis, including related results in Comte et al. (2011) [6]. Which theoretical results in this paper are genuinely new, rather than applications or reformulations of established statistical principles? Can the authors explicitly distinguish their contributions from these prior results?
Q2. Statistical significance and practical relevance of the reported improvements.
Appendix Figure 10 shows that most improvements in standard survival prediction metrics are extremely small. Specifically, 20 of the 24 dataset–head combinations exhibit absolute Harrell's C-index changes below 0.005, with improvements outside METABRIC averaging approximately 0.00075. Moreover, confidence intervals or significance tests for C-index, time-dependent AUC, and IBS are not reported.
Can the authors provide uncertainty estimates or appropriate paired statistical analyses to demonstrate that these improvements are statistically reliable and practically meaningful?
More importantly, the primary comparison is against the unrestricted baseline. Since restricting naturally reduces model complexity, the observed gains may simply reflect conventional regularization and hyperparameter tuning. Although a spectral-smoothing comparator is included in the fixed-representation study, comparable strong baselines are missing from the learned-representation experiments.
Can the authors demonstrate that joint selection provides benefits beyond appropriately tuned temporal regularization, spline smoothing, or other established complexity-control techniques under comparable computational budgets?
Q3. Clarification of the theoretical derivation in Appendix D.4.
In Appendix D.4, Equation (56) derives the baseline-profiled information using a pointwise Schur complement, which appears to allow the baseline function to vary independently at each time point. However, the proposed model parameterizes the baseline using piecewise-constant interval coefficients.
Is the pointwise profiling operation equivalent to profiling the finite-dimensional interval-specific baseline parameters? If not, how does this distinction affect the information energy and the validity or interpretation of the information-supported mode criterion in Proposition 4?
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your thoughtful review and contribution to the discussion.
As the discussion period approaches its conclusion, I would like to kindly remind you to review the authors' rebuttal and engage in the discussion if you have not already done so.
In particular, it would be helpful if you could indicate whether the authors have adequately addressed your concerns and, if appropriate, reconsider your assessment and score.
Thank you again for your time and effort!