- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DialPFN predicts individual event-time distributions conditional on observed context data and a specified dependence assumption. It learns from simulated studies with complete target times and produces sensitivity curves by varying the assumption input without retraining. The implementation combines a quantile head with context bootstrap averaging. Validation includes synthetic prediction and coverage tests, real-data prediction, and sensitivity-stability evaluations. In synthetic experiments, supplying the generating dependence assumption improves prediction accuracy compared with assuming independence.
Critical strengths
-
A useful assumption-conditioned prediction task. Holding the context set and individual fixed while varying the dependence assumption provides individual sensitivity curves without repeated model fitting. This is a practically meaningful extension of survival PFNs.
-
Evidence that the model uses the assumption input effectively. Supplying the generating assumption improves prediction accuracy in simulations, including the reserved Frank-copula evaluation. These results support the basic feasibility of the approach.
Critical weaknesses
Critical Weaknesses
-
Limited novelty and insufficient empirical validation. Assumption-conditioned modeling and sensitivity analysis are well established, and the contribution appears mainly to extend these ideas to PFNs. Comparisons should extend beyond PFNs to dependency-aware neural methods, including HACSurv [1], which learns dependence structures, and KnownCopula [2], which uses a prespecified copula. Comparisons under comparable prediction targets and dependence information are needed to establish an accuracy or efficiency advantage.
-
Substantial writing and reproducibility concerns. Many sentences are awkward or difficult to follow, and unfamiliar terminology adds to the reading burden. In my view, several sections require substantial rewriting for the paper to meet the standard expected for acceptance. Reporting is also incomplete: training hardware, actual training time, and sensitivity-sweep runtime are missing, and no accessible code is provided. These omissions make the practical benefits and reproducibility difficult to assess.
[1] Xin Liu, Weijia Zhang, and Min-Ling Zhang. HACSurv: A Hierarchical Copula-Based Approach for Survival Analysis with Dependent Competing Risks. AISTATS, 2025.
[2] Ali Hossein Foomani Gharari, Michael Cooper, Russell Greiner, and Rahul G. Krishnan. Copula-Based Deep Survival Models for Dependent Censoring. UAI, 2023.
Questions for authors
-
Do you have comparisons with HACSurv and KnownCopula under comparable prediction targets and dependence information? Such results would materially affect my assessment of the empirical contribution.
-
What hardware and actual training time were required, and what is the total runtime for a sensitivity sweep including bootstrap averaging? Is an anonymous implementation or pretrained checkpoint available for verification?