acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

FrontierGS: Exploration-Driven Active Gaussian Reconstruction with Efficient Fisher-Based Planning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Active Gaussian reconstruction requires robots to explore unknown space while improving the reconstruction quality of observed surfaces. Existing methods may prioritize local reconstruction gains during viewpoint planning, potentially trapping robots in observed regions. Repeated Gaussian map optimization and viewpoint evaluation also require substantial computation. To address these problems, we present FrontierGS, an exploration-driven framework that organizes viewpoint planning around a main path toward unknown space and adopts Fisher information to estimate the geometric benefit of candidate viewpoints. For efficient estimation of reconstruction gains, we reuse the Fisher information computed from past observations, forming a persistent Fisher approximation that avoids recomputing historical information after map updates. To guide viewpoint selection, we accumulate the expected Fisher information of already selected viewpoints to predict which viewpoints near the main path can provide complementary reconstruction benefits. These predictions use previously computed Fisher information between map optimizations, which lead to accumulated prediction errors. We therefore introduce an adaptive refresh strategy that optimizes the map and recomputes candidate Fisher information. Experiments demonstrate that our method improves coverage and rendering quality in large scenes while reducing computational cost.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
3D Reconstruction, 3D Gaussian Splatting, Autonomous Exploration

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_hjK3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents FrontierGS, an active GS reconstruction method driven by exploration. It balances reconstruction with exploration, using frontier exploration as the main guidance path, select viewpoints with high reconstruction yield within the corridor along the path. It also reduces computational costs by incrementally accumulate the Fisher information from new observations, avoiding the need to recompute the Jacobians of historical observations whenever the map is updated. Experimental results demonstrate that FrontierGS significantly improves exploration coverage and novel-view rendering quality in large-scale indoor scenes, while simultaneously reducing cumulative runtime.

Critical strengths
  1. The presented Incremental Fisher Accumulation successfully reduces the cumulative runtime, making the method sound in practical uses.
  2. The experiments are well designed and covers lots of scenarios. The reported metrics obviously outperforms baseline methods.
  3. Different from updating GS using a fixed interval, this method uses Adaptive Refresh to update the map. The idea of linking computational resources with decision ensitivity is novel. 4, The main idea of the paper. which is to introduction frontier-based exploration method into action gs recontruction task. This addresses the issues in existing traditional methods, such as the tendency to get stuck in already-explored areas, redundant observations, and high computational overhead.
Critical weaknesses
  1. This paper uses Persistent Fisher to maintain estimates of Fisher information using an incremental update strategy. Although this reducing computing time to a certain extent, it also introduces cumulative error. Besides the comparison in Tab. 2, I hope the authors could also analysis the influence over time rather than only next step prediction results.
  2. The theoretical guarantee of Adaptive Refresh relies on assumptions that may not hold during online reconstruction. Also, the estimated error may be lower than the actual error. Besides the single-step consistency in Tab. 5, I hope the authors could also analyze how error underestimation and map changes affect planning and final reconstruction quality.
Questions for authors
  1. The Corridor Radius mentioned in the paper is fixed to 1m, how is this parameter decided? Is 1m compatible to different scenarios with diffrent scales?
  2. Are there any real-world experiment results? I wonder how can this method be adapted to different robot platforms with different mechanical structures and dynamics.
Reviewer_mSH5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents FrontierGS, a new framework for active 3d scene reconstruction. The method uses a frontier exploration strategy to guide candidate viewpoint sampling within a surrounding box, and applies beam search to balance reconstruction gain, exploration of unknown regions, and cost. This design aims to maintain exploration progress while selecting complementary reconstruction views. To reduce computation, FrontierGS reuses historical Fisher information, uses virtual updates for conditional view selection, and refreshes the map and candidate Fisher estimates when score drift may affect planning. Experiments show competitive performance.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear motivation. The paper focuses on planning a frontier-based trajectory to guarantee exploration progress, and supplements it with nearby observations for reconstruction. This is well-motivated to reconcile exploration and reconstruction objectives.
  2. Well-designed system. The exploration and reconstruction layers are decoupled. The corridor constraint preserves exploration progress while limiting detours.
  3. Thorough ablations. Beyond coverage and rendering quality, the paper reports a detailed runtime breakdown and evaluates planning consistency against full historical relinearization. These analyses support the computational benefits of the Fisher approximation and its ability to preserve information relevant to viewpoint selection.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty is limited. The main contribution lies in integrating these components with persistent Fisher reuse and adaptive refresh, rather than introducing a fundamentally new planning formulation.
  2. The efficiency evaluation is limited to InteriorGS. Adaptive refresh reduces runtime by approximately 45% relative to refreshing after every view, with most savings coming from reduced map optimization time. Compared with a fixed interval, it improves reconstruction quality at nearly identical runtime. Evaluating more datasets and fixed refresh intervals would be better.
  3. The Fisher approximation may become less reliable as the map evolves. Historical contributions are retained without relinearization, and Gaussian splitting uses a heuristic rule. Although the consistency results are encouraging, the stability analysis excludes Gaussian creation, splitting, and pruning. Its reliability under substantial map changes therefore remains insufficiently established.
Questions for authors

See the weakness part.

Reviewer_RSaKOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents FrontierGS, an approach for exploration that relies on an efficient incremental implementation of FisherRF and considers multi-step plans, instead of being limited to single-step Next-Best-View planning. As the name suggests, FrontierGS uses frontiers as long-term goals and information gain, via FisherRF, to determine intermediate goals. As is common in the exploration literature these days, the inputs are RGB-D and perfect camera poses are assumed to be known, the representation is via Gaussian splats and an occupancy map, and the output is an efficient trajectory that explores the scene. Experiments are performed on standard datasets for this task, specifically Replica and Matterport3D, as well as InteriorGS which is also relevant.

Critical strengths

The main concepts of the paper are interesting and go beyond the current splatting-based exploration literature. Specifically, the combination of frontiers and information-gain-based viewpoint selection for long and short-term planning is worth pursuing. The proposed approximation of the FisherRF criterion that reduces computational cost appears to be sound and effective. Table 4 shows that runtime is reduced substantially due to the approximation, while Table 2 shows that the loss of precision is small.

As mentioned above, the experiments are on datasets that meet the current literature standards. They are all simulated, which is acceptable due to the nature of the exploration problem. The baselines are from recent, highly relevant publications, and the proposed approach performs well. The ablation studies are also informative.

Critical weaknesses

The main weakness and the primary reason for my recommendation is that the technical descriptions suffer from major flaws. Undefined terms appear and disappear, while important steps of the algorithm are not described with sufficient detail and precision. As a result, the description does not enable a reasonable reproduction of the algorithm and the results, and raises concerns about the validity of the findings. If there was a small number of such errors, I would give the authors the benefit of the doubt, but this is not the case here. Below is a list of comments I wrote as I was reading the paper. I intended to list those in the “Questions for Authors” section, but they are just too many. (The list below is not exhaustive.)

Lines 164-165: “we use geometric Gauss–Newton information as a local proxy for reconstruction uncertainty.” Geometric Gauss-Newton is never defined.

Lines 166-167: “where ρg∈R3\rho_g \in R^3 denotes rotation coordinates in a fixed parameterization shared across map states.” There are many things I do not understand in this sentence.

What topology changes are referred to in Line 183? The term does not appear again.

The term “path anchors” or just “anchor” only appears in Line 202. What are the anchors, how are they selected? Similarly, “exploration views” are only mentioned in Line 273.

The first instance of “occupancy map” is in line 206. It has not been defined prior to that other than in the caption of Fig. 2.

In Eq. (8), what is DgeoD_{geo} and why is it set to 8?

In Line 364 “(Li et al., 2026a)” is cited as the source of completion. The term completion, however, does not appear in that paper.

Questions for authors

I do not think that my concerns can be addressed within the review process, but I would like to read a little more on the balance between frontier-based and information-gain-based exploration.

I also recommend the following two references that consider longer horizons than just the next viewpoint.

Y. Tao, D. Ong, V. Murali, I. Spasojevic, P. Chaudhari, and V. Kumar. “RT-GuIDE: Real-Time Gaussian splatting for Information-Driven Exploration. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters, 2025.

S. Li, A. Guédon, C. Boittiaux, S. Chen, and V. Lepetit. NextBestPath: Efficient 3D Mapping of Unseen Environments. ICLR, 2025.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.