acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

PIONEER: Panoramic Imagined Occupancy-guided Active Mapping for Efficient Aerial Exploration

Abstract

Active mapping seeks informative observations for efficient aerial exploration and reconstruction, yet perspective observations couple viewpoint utility to camera positions and orientations, increasing the cost of explicit search over candidate poses. Panoramic vision instead provide nearly complete angular coverage and enable position-centric planning. However, exploration in large environments still requires anticipating occluded geometry and allocating computation across candidate spatial trajectories. We present PIONEER, a panoramic active mapping framework for efficient large-scale aerial exploration. PIONEER integrates panoramic evidence with a pretrained occupancy prior to estimate cumulative coverage gain over future observation positions. A learned scheduler adapts beam-search width and depth to the mapping state, using predicted runtime and a prescribed planning budget to select search configurations. We also construct a metric-calibrated dataset from 3D assets derived from real-world scenes, providing UE5-compatible textured environments and paired perspective and panoramic observations for closed-loop evaluation. Experiments demonstrate that PIONEER improves coverage and reconstruction quality under matched exploration time budgets. Dynamic search allocation further reduces the time to reach a common coverage target relative to the evaluated fixed configuration.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Panoramic Vision, Active Planning, Aerial Exploration

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_AUccOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2(+1)
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents PIONEER, a panoramic active mapping framework for aerial exploration. The main idea is to exploit panoramic observations to reduce viewpoint planning which searching both position and orientation. It changes to position-only trajectory search. The method builds on a pretrained occupancy prior and Imagined Gaussians to estimate coverage gain in unseen regions, and uses beam search for multi-step trajectory planning. In addition, the paper introduces a learned dynamic beam-search scheduler that adapts beam width and search depth according to the current mapping state and a latency budget. The authors also construct a metric-calibrated simulation benchmark from existing large-scale 3D assets for panoramic aerial active mapping.

Critical strengths

The paper studies an interesting and practically relevant problem of large-scale aerial active mapping, and the use of panoramic sensing is a natural fit for this setting. The position-centric formulation is clean and reduces the search space by eliminating explicit orientation enumeration under full spherical sensing.

The empirical results are strong. Under the reported time-budget evaluation, PIONEER achieves large improvements in surface coverage and generally improves downstream reconstruction quality compared with the evaluated baselines. The experiments also cover several large-scale outdoor environments with different scene structures.

Critical weaknesses

My major concern is that the current experiments do not clearly isolate where the large performance gains come from. i.e. missing performane ablation.

First, much of the planning pipeline closely follows MAGICIAN, including occupancy prediction, Imagined Gaussians, novelty-based gain evaluation, and beam search. The main change is the use of panoramic sensing, which removes orientation search. Since PIONEER observes the full sphere at each location, the large improvements over perspective-based MAGICIAN may largely come from the stronger/better sensing setup rather than from a substantially new planning method. A controlled MAGICIAN + panorama baseline would be important.

Second, the Dynamic Beam Search contribution is not sufficiently ablated. The paper compares PIONEER-Fix and PIONEER-DBS mainly in terms of time to reach 50% coverage, but does not report the full mapping and reconstruction metrics for both variants.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide a controlled comparison against MAGICIAN with panoramic sensing, or an equivalent baseline with the same panoramic observations and position-centric action space? This would help determine how much of the reported gain comes from the sensing modality itself versus the proposed planning components.

  2. Can the authors report PIONEER-Fix vs. PIONEER-DBS on the main performance metrics, including AUC, final coverage, and reconstruction quality, rather than only time-to-50%-coverage? This is important for assessing the actual contribution of the dynamic beam-search scheduler.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer AUcc

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful reading and constructive, technically detailed suggestions. We appreciate your recognition of the problem's relevance, the position-centric formulation, and the empirical results. Your concern about isolating the sources of improvement is well taken. We have added controlled panoramic comparisons, full Fix–DBS performance metrics, and complementary timing analyses.

1. Controlled panoramic comparison

We added Pano-MAGICIAN, Pano-SCONE, and Pano-MACARONS using the same six-face panoramic RGB-D configuration as PIONEER: six co-located 1024 × 1024 faces with 90° × 90° fields of view. Section 5.1 (pp. 7–8) introduces these adaptations and the shared translation increments of 20 m horizontally and 5 m vertically. Computing resources and scene-specific computation budgets are matched.

New Table 2 (p. 9), analyzed in Section 5.2 (p. 8), reports averages over five starting positions. The HKUST results are reproduced below.

MethodAUC ↑Cover. (%) ↑SSIM ↑PSNR (dB) ↑LPIPS ↓Acc. (%) ↑
Pano-SCONE0.28357.1900.49812.9330.44792.070
Pano-MACARONS0.41963.6760.50513.8880.41295.562
Pano-MAGICIAN0.48482.4590.55316.3390.39398.660
PIONEER-Fix0.70189.2880.59516.6880.38199.142
PIONEER-DBS0.72090.5020.60416.9030.37899.300

These comparisons provide two levels of evidence. With panoramic sensing matched, Fix already improves HKUST AUC from 0.484 to 0.701 and coverage from 82.459% to 89.288% relative to Pano-MAGICIAN. Broader angular observations alone therefore cannot explain these gains. DBS further raises AUC to 0.720 and coverage to 90.502%. We assess its contribution through Fix versus DBS, rather than attributing the entire PIONEER–Pano-MAGICIAN gap to the scheduler.

Across four scenes, DBS exceeds Pano-MAGICIAN by 0.157–0.236 AUC and 4.10–11.78 coverage points. Figure 13 (Appendix A.2, p. 25) adds panoramic trajectory and reconstruction comparisons, showing more complete urban surfaces and fewer large spurious planar facets in Ninepin Group.

Panoramic sensing removes orientation choices but leaves spatial occlusion and search cost unresolved. PIONEER makes search width and depth depend on the mapping state and predicted runtime (Section 3.4, p. 6); the following ablation evaluates this allocation directly.

2. Full performance ablation of Fix and DBS

Following your suggestion, Table 2 now reports AUC, final coverage, SSIM, PSNR, LPIPS, and geometric accuracy for both variants under matched computation budgets. On HKUST, DBS improves all six metrics: AUC by 0.019, coverage by 1.214 percentage points, SSIM by 0.009, PSNR by 0.215 dB, LPIPS by a reduction of 0.003, and accuracy by 0.158 percentage points.

Across the four scenes, DBS improves AUC by 0.011–0.019 and improves SSIM, LPIPS, and geometric accuracy in every scene. We retain the exceptions: on Ninepin Group, Fix has higher final coverage (82.108% versus 81.352%) and PSNR (16.558 versus 16.350 dB), while DBS has higher AUC (0.525 versus 0.510). The evidence supports improved coverage accumulation and generally better reconstruction, rather than uniform improvement in every endpoint metric.

Section 5.3 adds two complementary comparisons:

  • Figure 5 (p. 9) reports computation time to 50% and 80% coverage, including Pano-MAGICIAN at 80%. DBS is faster than Fix at both targets across all 20 starting positions. It reaches 80% from every starting position and is faster than Pano-MAGICIAN wherever that baseline succeeds. The 50% target is retained for the perspective baseline because its attainable coverage is more limited.
  • Figure 6 (p. 10) compares eight identical mapping states, separating preprocessing, configuration selection, and search with command output. DBS reduces total latency by 23.9–44.1% in these cases, with selection overhead of 2.3–3.4%.

A fixed configuration commits the same width and depth throughout exploration despite changing search cost and coverage utility. DBS instead selects fewer alternatives with deeper look-ahead over open water, or retains the width with a shorter horizon near the Kennedy Town foreground tower. The paired timings demonstrate reduced computation at those states, while AUC and time-to-target results establish its benefit for coverage accumulation over complete runs.

Thank you for the detailed response and added experiments and results. Regarding my concerns,

  1. the new panoramic baselines address my concern regarding the source of gain.
  2. The added PIONEER-FIX v.s. PIONEER-DBS result shows the performance ablation for the dyanmic scheduler.

Therefore I will raise my score accordingly.

Dear Reviewer,

We sincerely thank you for your positive feedback and thoughtful consideration. We are pleased that our responses have addressed most of your concerns. Thank you again for your valuable time and constructive suggestions.

Best Regards,

The Authors

Reviewer_u3saOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents PIONEER, a panoramic active mapping framework. The author proves that panoramic view selection can be reduced to a position-centric formulation. For view planning, they introduce dynamic beam search, which uses a neural network to predict the planning latency and dynamically adjust the beam search configuration.

Critical strengths
  1. Better reconstruction quality on large-scale datasets than baseline methods.

  2. The idea of dynamic beam search is interesting. DBS reduces the computation latency in the efficiency study.

Critical weaknesses
  1. I am confused about the difference between this work and MAGICIAN. It seems that both works use the imagined Gaussian to predict coverage gain, and the difference is only that this work uses a panoramic camera, while MAGICIAN uses a perspective camera. Then the novelty of the work seems limited since the panoramic camera simplifies the problem by reducing the search space. The author could either explain the challenge of using a panoramic camera or explain how their method differs from MAGICIAN.

  2. For the baselines in Table I, do they use perspective views or panoramic views? If they use perspective views, then the comparison is unfair. Most panoramic cameras produce panoramic views by stitching multiple cameras. Given the same amount of time budget, the panoramic camera takes more views than perspective cameras.

Questions for authors
  1. I am still confused about why the rendered Gaussians provide novelty in Eq. 18 ? Moreover, I cannot find the definition of γ\gamma. It would be great if the authors could provide a complete definition of the symbols in the preliminary sections.

  2. It would be great to show a pie chart for the latency of each module and demonstrate how much time DBS could save.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer u3sa

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and constructive suggestions, and for recognizing the reconstruction results and the potential of DBS. We have strengthened the explanation, added matched panoramic baselines and timing analyses, and clarified the notation.

1. Insight beyond panoramic sensing

Full angular coverage removes orientation choices, but does not reveal geometry behind buildings or terrain. The remaining challenge is deciding which spatial trajectories to investigate and how much computation to spend before acquiring the next observation.

PIONEER makes search width KK and spatial look-ahead depth HH depend on the mapping state. In Section 3.4 (p. 6), runtime prediction identifies configurations that fit the budget, while the learned scheduler selects among them using coverage utility. Training compares configurations over a common window of executed motions independent of HH (Appendix A.1.5, pp. 18–20). A configuration is therefore favored for downstream coverage, not merely for searching deeper. This connects search effort to both its cost and its value for subsequent mapping.

2. Matched panoramic comparison

Table 1 uses the original perspective baselines. We agree that equal computation budgets alone do not control the sensing advantage. We added Pano-SCONE, Pano-MACARONS, and Pano-MAGICIAN using the same six-face panoramic RGB-D configuration as PIONEER (Section 5.1, pp. 7–8). Table 2 (p. 9) reports averages over five starting positions under matched computation budgets and per-run resources.

HKUST results from revised Table 2.

MethodAUC ↑Cover. (%) ↑SSIM ↑PSNR (dB) ↑LPIPS ↓Acc. (%) ↑
Pano-SCONE0.28357.1900.49812.9330.44792.070
Pano-MACARONS0.41963.6760.50513.8880.41295.562
Pano-MAGICIAN0.48482.4590.55316.3390.39398.660
PIONEER-Fix0.70189.2880.59516.6880.38199.142
PIONEER-DBS0.72090.5020.60416.9030.37899.300

Against Pano-MAGICIAN, DBS gains 0.236 AUC and 8.043 coverage points on HKUST. Across four scenes, coverage gains are 4.10–11.78 points. Both PIONEER variants outperform the panoramic baselines on all reported metrics. Figure 13 (Appendix A.2, p. 25) adds panoramic reconstruction comparisons. These results show that panoramic observations alone do not reproduce PIONEER's performance; Fix versus DBS separately assesses adaptive allocation.

3. Novelty rendering and γ\gamma

Here, novelty means geometry not yet observed. Each Gaussian starts with γt,j=0\gamma_{t,j}=0 for observed geometry and γt,j=1\gamma_{t,j}=1 for unobserved predicted geometry. Equation 18 renders this scalar instead of RGB:

Inovp(u;γ)=∑jTjp(u)ajp(u)γj.I_{\mathrm{nov}}^{\mathbf{p}}(u;\gamma)=\sum_j T_j^{\mathbf{p}}(u)a_j^{\mathbf{p}}(u)\gamma_j.

Here, p\mathbf{p} is the candidate position, uu a pixel, ajp(u)a_j^{\mathbf{p}}(u) combines opacity and projected footprint, and Tjp(u)T_j^{\mathbf{p}}(u) accounts for occlusion. Observed surfaces contribute zero novelty but retain opacity, so they still occlude unseen geometry. Equation 19 aggregates this visibility-weighted signal. Equation 20 clears novelty after hypothetical observation to prevent repeated coverage credit within a trajectory.

We now define γt\gamma_t in Section 3.1 (p. 4), with Gaussian attributes, rendering symbols, and branch updates specified in Appendix A.1.2, Eqs. 17–20 (pp. 15–16).

4. Pie charts and DBS savings

New Figure 6 (Section 5.3, p. 10) compares Fix and DBS at eight identical mapping states, each paired with its panoramic observation. It separates preprocessing, configuration selection, and search with command output, following Appendix A.1.4 (p. 18). Both absolute latency and component proportions are shown.

DBS reduces total latency by 23.9–44.1% in these cases, with selection overhead of 2.3–3.4%. Over open water, it changes (K,H)(K,H) from (8,6)(8,6) to (3,8)(3,8) and latency from 10.19 to 7.70 s: fewer alternatives with deeper look-ahead. Near the Kennedy Town foreground tower, it selects (8,3)(8,3) and reduces latency from 9.41 to 5.81 s: unchanged width with a shorter horizon. These contrasting choices demonstrate state-dependent allocation.

Updated Figure 5 (p. 9) shows lower computation time than Fix at both 50% and 80% coverage for all 20 starting positions. Table 2 also shows higher AUC than Fix in every scene. Thus, the savings support coverage accumulation over complete runs: under a finite budget, computation spent on current search competes with subsequent observations and map updates.

Dear author, thank you for your reply!

The response addresses part of my concern. I still have one question after reading your new table.

For the AUC metric, PIONEER-Fix gets 0.701, and Pano-MAGICIAN gets 0.484. PIONEER-Fix uses a fixed beam configuration (Line 400). Pano-MAGICIAN uses a panoramic camera and also beam search (Line 376). Could you explain why they have such a difference, even though they use the same beam planner, and PIONEER and MAGICIAN use similar methods to predict coverage gain?

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Official Comment by Reviewer u3sa

Dear Reviewer u3sa,

Thank you for the constructive follow-up! And also thanks for acknowledging that the additional results address part of your concerns.

The key distinction is that Pano-MAGICIAN uses panoramic RGB-D observations while retaining MAGICIAN's original orientation-selection procedure (corrected the our previous description in former response). PIONEER-Fix instead searches over trajectories of observation positions and evaluates the full-spherical coverage gain at each position (Section 3.3, pp. 5–6). “Fix” means that its beam width and depth remain constant; it still uses PIONEER's position-centric formulation. Although both methods employ beam search and similar coverage-gain prediction, they differ in the planning variables and candidate-processing procedure.

Under the full-spherical sensing assumptions in Eq. 5, the ideal observation gain is independent of orientation. PIONEER exploits this property by removing orientation selection from the information search. This distinction matters because Table 2 evaluates coverage within a common computation budget: AUC is calculated from the coverage–time curve. Reducing planning work can leave more time for subsequent observations and map updates, improving coverage accumulation even with a similar occupancy predictor. On HKUST, PIONEER-Fix increases AUC from 0.484 to 0.701 (+0.217), while final coverage increases from 82.459% to 89.288%. The AUC difference captures the accumulated coverage advantage throughout the time window, beyond the endpoint difference. Figure 5 (Section 5.3, p. 9) additionally compares computation time to a common 80% coverage target.

The Pano-MAGICIAN–PIONEER-Fix comparison therefore controls the sensing configuration while evaluating different planning formulations. The 0.217 AUC difference reflects the performance of these planning pipelines under matched sensing. The Fix–DBS comparison separately assesses adaptive computation allocation within the position-centric planner: on HKUST, DBS further raises AUC from 0.701 to 0.720. Thus, position-centric planning is already present in Fix, while DBS provides an additional benefit by adapting search width and depth. We will clarify the retained orientation-selection procedure in Section 5.1 and make this interpretation explicit in Section 5.2.

Thank you again for helping us explain the sources of improvement more clearly. Please let us know if you have any further questions or suggestions, we greatly value your feedback, which helps us refine and strengthen our work.

Reviewer_N8s3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2(−1)
Presentation
3
Soundness
2(−1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents PIONEER, an aerial active mapping system for outdoor 3D scene reconstruction based on panoramic RGB-D perception. The system constructs an ego-centric spherical occupancy grid that decouples spatial translation from yaw rotation through spherical rotational invariance, and employs a dynamic beam search guided by upper-quantile latency predictions to adapt the search width and depth online. Empirical evaluations in complex outdoor Unreal Engine environments demonstrate notable improvements over existing narrow-FoV baselines in trajectory length, volumetric coverage, and neural reconstruction quality.

Critical strengths
  • The paper effectively exploits the yaw-rotation invariance of full-panoramic sensing, decomposing six-degree-of-freedom trajectory generation into positional beam search followed by orientation assignment.
  • The proposed dynamic beam search incorporates an upper-quantile execution-latency predictor that modulates beam width and depth according to observed ray-casting costs.
Critical weaknesses
  • All baselines use conventional forward-facing narrow-FoV perspective cameras, while the proposed method alone uses a panoramic depth sensor. No panoramic-camera baseline is included. Because a single cubemap frame covers far more solid angle than a narrow-FoV camera, the experiments cannot disentangle whether performance gains come from the dynamic beam search algorithm itself or simply from the physical advantage of panoramic sensing.
  • The empirical validation relies exclusively on idealized Unreal Engine 5 simulations and lacks physical UAV deployment. The system depends on sensing assumptions that do not hold in real outdoor aerial robotics.
Questions for authors
  • How do the baseline methods such as MAGICIAN and MACARONS perform when provided with the exact same 6-face cubemap RGB-D observations per step as PIONEER?
  • Whether the Unreal Engine 5 closed-loop evaluation operated in strict lockstep with real-world wall-clock time, or if the simulation paused while ray-casting and network inference completed?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer N8s3

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful reading, constructive suggestions, and positive recommendation. We appreciate your recognition of the position-centric formulation and latency-aware search. Your comments address directions we have continued to investigate since submission and have helped strengthen our evaluation.

1. Panoramic baselines and the source of the gains

We agree that matching computation budgets alone does not isolate sensing from planning. We have added Pano-SCONE, Pano-MACARONS, and Pano-MAGICIAN using the same six-face panoramic RGB-D configuration as PIONEER: six co-located 1024 × 1024 faces, each with a 90° × 90° field of view. Section 5.1 (pp. 7–8) introduces these adaptations; Table 2 (p. 9) reports results averaged over five starting positions under matched computation budgets and per-run GPU resources.

HKUST results from revised Table 2.

MethodAUC ↑Cover. (%) ↑SSIM ↑PSNR (dB) ↑LPIPS ↓Acc. (%) ↑
Pano-SCONE0.28357.1900.49812.9330.44792.070
Pano-MACARONS0.41963.6760.50513.8880.41295.562
Pano-MAGICIAN0.48482.4590.55316.3390.39398.660
PIONEER-Fix0.70189.2880.59516.6880.38199.142
PIONEER-DBS0.72090.5020.60416.9030.37899.300

Against Pano-MAGICIAN, PIONEER-DBS gains 0.236 AUC and 8.043 coverage percentage points on HKUST. Across all four scenes, its gains are 0.157–0.236 AUC and 4.10–11.78 coverage points. The advantage therefore remains with matched panoramic sensing. Figure 13 (Appendix A.2, p. 25) adds panoramic reconstruction comparisons showing more complete urban surfaces and fewer large spurious planar facets in Ninepin Group.

The Fix–DBS comparison separately assesses the scheduler: DBS improves AUC in all four scenes. Figure 5 (Section 5.3, p. 9) shows lower computation time than Fix at both 50% and 80% coverage across all 20 starting positions. Figure 6 (p. 10) compares identical mapping states and shows 23.9–44.1% lower planning latency in the eight displayed cases. Together, these experiments separate the matched-sensing advantage from the additional benefit of adaptive search allocation.

2. Physical deployment and sensing assumptions

We agree that physical validation is important. Section 5.1 (p. 7) now explicitly states our use of known poses and simulator-provided depth. Our current results establish performance in controlled simulation; physical UAV validation remains future work.

We are preparing the hardware platform and designing sim-to-real experiments on a UAV equipped with a panoramic camera, including evaluation of depth and pose errors. Section 6 (p. 10) discusses panoramic depth estimation as a route toward RGB-based exploration and reduced reliance on directly measured depth.

3. Simulation clock and timing

The simulator is paused during planning: the UAV pose and scene state remain fixed while ray-casting and network inference complete, and the selected motion is executed afterward. Our results therefore concern measured computation time, rather than a demonstrated real-time sensing–planning–flight loop.

Appendix A.1.4 (p. 18) defines planning latency from receiving the panoramic observation to producing the next motion command. It includes preprocessing, scheduler execution, beam search, and command preparation. GPU work is synchronized at timing boundaries to include its computation; physical flight and image capture are excluded.

Section 5.1 (p. 7) and Appendix A.2 (pp. 20–21) clarify the computation-budget protocol and scene-wise limits. Figure 5 explicitly reports “Computation time.” Validating the complete physical loop is part of our planned deployment.

Dear Authors,

Thank you for the detailed response, which addresses part of my previous concerns. However, I have a crucial follow-up regarding the methodological scope of this work:

The authors confirmed that once orientation handling is aligned, Pano-MAGICIAN and PIONEER-Fix are "technically same" with equivalent performance. This implies that the spatial mapping and trajectory search pipeline introduces no distinct methodology beyond MAGICIAN. Could the authors explicitly clarify whether the sole original algorithmic contribution of this paper is strictly confined to the Dynamic Beam Search (DBS) scheduler? If so, how do the authors justify the methodological significance required for acceptance? As shown in Table 2, DBS provides only a marginal gain in AUC and 1.2% in coverage on HKUST, while underperforming the fixed configuration (PIONEER-Fix) in both final coverage and PSNR on Ninepin Group.

Dear Reviewer N8s3,

Thank you for your careful follow-up and for encouraging us to clarify the methodological scope of our work. Our algorithmic contributions comprise the position-centric planning formulation and the latency-aware DBS scheduler. Position-centric planning improves coverage and reconstruction quality over Pano-MAGICIAN’s joint position and orientation search, while DBS primarily improves exploration efficiency through adaptive computation allocation.

Our earlier statement about technical equivalence refers to Pano-MAGICIAN after adopting the same fixed orientation setting as PIONEER-Fix. Pano-MAGICIAN retains MAGICIAN's orientation selection procedure, with the cubemap rotating with candidate poses and evaluate coverage gain under full-spherical sensing. In contrast, PIONEER explicitly uses the full spherical gain invariance to formulate information search over observation positions. And evaluates these positions with a canonical rendering orientation (Section 3.3, Eq. 5; Appendix A.1.3). This removes redundant orientation decisions and keeps angular sampling consistent. And this design makes the coverage gain different, changes the resulting beam search and planning decisions, ultimately leading to substantially different exploration trajectories. The methodological insight is to use the sensing symmetry to determine the planning variables and direct search computation toward spatial trajectories. Once this design choice is also applied to Pano-MAGICIAN, its performance approaches PIONEER-Fix as shown in Table. 2. This result clarifies the role of the position-centric formulation and the source of the original gap.

DBS addresses the further question of how much spatial search to perform at each decision. It combines the mapping state with an upper-quantile runtime predictor to select beam width and depth under a planning-latency budget (Section 3.4). The scheduler is trained using coverage utility over a common rollout horizon, allowing configurations with different search depths to be compared consistently. Its purpose is to balance the benefit of additional look-ahead against the computation that delays subsequent observations and map updates. The efficiency experiments directly evaluate this benefit. In Section 5.3, Figure 5 shows that DBS reduces computation time to both 50% and 80% coverage relative to PIONEER-Fix across all 20 starting configurations in the four scenes. Figure 6 compares the methods from the same mapping states and shows total per-decision latency reductions of 23.9%–44.1% across the illustrated states, including configuration-selection overhead. It also illustrates distinct allocations of search effort: in the open-water example, DBS changes (K,H) from (8,6) to (3,8), retaining deeper look-ahead with fewer spatial alternatives; in the dark-tower example, it selects (8,3), preserving width with a shorter horizon. These results demonstrate how the scheduler adapts the structure and cost of search to the current state.

We agree that the additional final-quality gains on Ninepin Group exhibits a tradeoff. On Ninepin, DBS reduces final coverage from 82.108% to 81.352% and PSNR from 16.558 to 16.350 dB, while improving AUC from 0.510 to 0.525, as well as SSIM and LPIPS. It also reaches the common coverage targets faster in Figure 5. Across all four scenes, DBS improves AUC. We therefore interpret its contribution as improved exploration efficiency with competitive final mapping and reconstruction quality.

Finally, the dataset contribution in Section 4 provides metric-calibrated outdoor environments, paired panoramic and perspective observations. We believe that it is suitable for many spatial reasoning and reconstruction research in large scale scenarios. Together, the formulation, learned allocation of planning computation, and dataset support our study of efficient panoramic aerial mapping at large scale. We believe the methodological significance lies in connecting these design choices and demonstrating their effects through controlled comparisons.

Thank you again for helping us make this contribution and its empirical scope clearer.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.