- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OUR-GS, an online Gaussian Splatting framework for UAV reconstruction that improves rendering quality by addressing cross-frame depth inconsistencies, unbalanced Gaussian allocation, and inaccurate position updates in distant regions.
Critical strengths
Strong empirical improvements over recent online Gaussian mapping methods across diverse UAV datasets.
Critical weaknesses
The paper claims to improve geometric consistency, and all 3 proposed modules are closely related to geometry: MDR aims to improve cross-frame depth consistency, BGME balances Gaussian allocation across different depth ranges, and TRDU improves Gaussian position updates, especially for distant regions.
However, the paper lacks direct quantitative evaluation of geometric accuracy. The authors mainly rely on rendering quality metrics such as PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS, but improvements in these metrics do not necessarily mean more accurate 3D reconstruction. In particular, GS can achieve better rendering quality by adjusting opacity, scale, and appearance without necessarily recovering the correct underlying geometry.
More importantly, some previous baselines, such as MODP, have already evaluated depth or geometric accuracy in their original papers. I think the authors should include similar evaluations to better support their claims about improved geometric consistency.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide quantitative evaluations of geometric accuracy, such as depth errors or 3D reconstruction errors, especially since some existing baselines, such as MODP, have already considered geometric evaluation? This would help clarify whether the improvements actually come from more accurate geometry rather than better appearance optimization.
Response to Reviewer E7zY
We are grateful for the reviewer's thoughtful feedback and helpful suggestion to evaluate geometric accuracy. We have revised the manuscript accordingly, with updates highlighted in blue.
W1: The paper claims to ... However, the paper lacks direct quantitative evaluation of geometric accuracy ...
A: Please refer to the answer for Q1.
Q1: Could the authors provide quantitative evaluations of geometric accuracy, such as depth errors or 3D reconstruction errors ...
A: Thank you for your valuable comment. We have conducted additional evaluations of geometric accuracy, including (1) geometric evaluations of baseline comparisons, and (2) geometric evaluations of component ablations. Since ground-truth geometry is typically unavailable for real-world high-altitude UAV imagery, we evaluate geometric reconstruction in the synthetic scene from HorizonGS (Sec. 4.1, Datasets), which provides the reference depth and point cloud.
For depth evaluation, we compare rendered depth maps against reference depth using AbsRel, RMSE, and Acc.@1.25 (indicating the percentage of valid pixels for which the ratio of rendered depth to ground-truth depth lies between 1/1.25 and 1.25). For 3D reconstruction evaluation, we back-project rendered depths to form a point cloud and compare it with the reference point cloud using Chamfer Distance (CD) and the F1 score with a threshold of 0.05.
(1) Geometric evaluations of baseline comparisons. Results are shown in the table below.
Compared with the strong baseline MODP, the results reported in the table show that OUR-GS improves AbsRel from 0.038 to 0.030 and RMSE from 0.216 to 0.204. It also reduces CD from 0.141 to 0.131 and increases F1 from 0.748 to 0.760. These geometric evaluations show that, in addition to the gains in rendering quality reported in the paper (Sec. 4.2, Table 1, Fig. 3), OUR-GS also achieves higher geometric reconstruction accuracy than prior online reconstruction methods.
(2) Geometric evaluations of component ablations. Results are shown in the table below.
As shown in the table, removing MDR, BGME's balanced sampling, or TRDU reduces geometric reconstruction accuracy. These performance drops verify the contributions of our proposed components to geometric reconstruction: MDR reassesses depth estimates (Sec. 3.1), BGME preserves representational capacity across different depth ranges (Sec. 3.2), and TRDU enables more effective position refinement within the limited online optimization budget (Sec. 3.3).
In the revised manuscript, we introduce these geometric evaluations in Sec. 4.2 (Lines 421-424) and Appendix A.1 (Tables 7 and 8).