- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies periodic trajectories recorded after a long common delay or over a fixed physical-time window. Frequency differences produce increasing phase differences. The authors derive error bounds for predictors with limited parameter sensitivity and test a representation that learns the aligned waveform and period separately.
Critical strengths
-
Theorem 1 relates the error floor to orbit variance and predictor sensitivity. Theorem 2 identifies the product of window length and frequency gap as a local scale for OOD error. The proofs in Appendices A–B support these conditional results. This adds understanding beyond the established use of phase alignment and time warping.
-
The experiments separate alignment from period normalization and use five ODE training seeds. Appendix F.3 increases the grid size with the window and supplies spectral headroom. These controls help attribute the observed failures to the representation rather than a simple resolution limitation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Table 2 may not evaluate the reconstructed physical-time predictor. Section 5.3 uses U_hat(phi_hat + t/T_hat). Appendix G, p.26, lines 1378–1383, instead uses U_hat(phi_hat + tau_j) against the reference at T(p) times tau_j. T_hat is absent. As written, this measures cycle shape with true-period normalization. Separate period error does not show the total trajectory error. Table 1 also uses different time coordinates, and Table 2 lacks OOD reconstruction at common physical times.
-
The connection between the bounds and trained FNOs remains conditional. The assumption L_lambda = o(lambda) is not enforced or checked. The observed error floors are consistent with the theory, but do not establish that the trained predictors satisfy its assumptions. This affects how strongly the experiments support the proposed explanation.
Questions for authors
-
Does Appendix G match the evaluation code? Using the existing predictors, please report reconstruction with T_hat at common physical times for IID and period-OOD samples, over one cycle and several cycles.
-
Are the FNO experiments intended as illustrations of the conditional bounds, or as evidence that their assumptions hold? Please clarify the claim; a sensitivity check on the existing checkpoints could help.
Response to Reviewer jARy
Dear Reviewer jARy,
Thank you for your valuable review, especially your careful observations about the reconstruction evaluation and the conditional experimental validation.
We address your weaknesses and corresponding questions together below.
Weakness 1 and Question 1: Physical-time reconstruction
We have rerun the reconstruction evaluation using the predicted period explicitly. For each validation parameter sample, we integrate past burn-in and select a snapshot at a random post-burn-in time. We then generate the reference trajectory over one or five true periods by integrating from this snapshot. Using the existing waveform FNO and period MLP, we predict the waveform and period, estimate the initial phase by matching the snapshot, and reconstruct
x(t)=U(ϕ+t/T(p);p).
The reconstruction MSE compares this prediction with the reference at matching physical times, so it includes the effect of period prediction error.
Section 5.3 and Table 2 report the IID and period-OOD results. Appendix J provides the evaluation procedure and detailed per-seed results. We reproduce Table 2 below; entries are mean ± standard deviation across five training seeds.
Period relative MSE is the sample mean of (T−T)2/T2.
Over five true periods, IID reconstruction errors remain small, while OOD errors increase substantially. Period prediction errors can accumulate into phase drift during reconstruction. Improving long-horizon reconstruction is outside the scope of this work.
Weakness 2 and Question 2: The assumption Lλ=o(λ)
We have added empirical Lipschitz estimates for both FM1 and FM2 in Section 4.1, with experimental details and visualization in Appendix G. For each final FNO checkpoint, we estimate the largest singular value of the parameter Jacobian at sampled validation points and take the maximum as Lλ. Both sweeps show a decreasing ratio Lλ/λ, consistent with the expected trend.
In FM1, the ratio decreases from 1.17 to 0.0115 for Goodwin as c increases from 102 to 104, and from 1.77 to 0.00322 for Gold95 as c increases from 102 to 105. In FM2, over a 64-fold increase in W, it decreases from 1.81 to 0.38 for Goodwin and from 1.52 to 0.23 for Gold95.
The ratio drops more in FM1, where we sweep a much wider range. Our ability to examine FM2 over a wider range is limited by computational cost: increasing W requires proportionally more output grid points to maintain temporal resolution.