- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes APA, a lightweight module for addressing phase drift in multivariate time series forecasting. It applies a complex-valued affine transformation to Fourier coefficients to induce adaptive phase responses, followed by an inverse Fourier transform and temporal gating mechanism that reweights a learnable periodic template.
Critical strengths
1.This formulation is computationally economical and provides a clear mathematical basis for the proposed mechanism.
2.The experiment is thorough.
Critical weaknesses
1.The central claim concerns correcting phase drift, but Equation (5) characterizes the phase response induced by an affine transformation rather than explicitly estimating the discrepancy between historical and target phases.
2.Figures 3–5 illustrate improved representations and forecasting behavior, but they do not directly quantify how accurately the method recovers or corrects known phase offsets.
3.The gated periodic representation rather than the original historical observations raises a concrete concern about the model's ability to distinguish series with identical periodic structure but different absolute levels.
Questions for authors
See critical weakness.
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. The RevIN clarification resolves my concern about absolute levels, and the quantitative phase evaluations substantially strengthen the empirical evidence.
My remaining reservation concerns the connection between the proposed mechanism and the central phase-correction interpretation. The derivation explains how the multiplicative spectral term responds to the observed phase, but the explanation of how the full affine transformation and subsequent template gating correct the phase mismatch remains largely heuristic. The improved forecast alignment supports the method’s effectiveness, but does not fully resolve this mechanistic concern.
I recognize the lightweight design, the extensive evaluation, and the substantial effort made in the rebuttal. However, because the phase-correction interpretation is central to the paper’s contribution, the remaining gap between the mechanism and its justification keeps my assessment slightly below the acceptance threshold. I therefore maintain my weak rejection recommendation
Response to Reviewer m5UP
We thank the reviewer for the constructive review and for recognizing the economical formulation, its clear mathematical basis, and the thoroughness of our experiments. We address the three weaknesses below; all revisions are in blue.
W1. Eq. (5) describes a phase response rather than an explicit phase estimate
We agree, and this is by design: APA does not explicitly estimate the discrepancy between the historical and target phases (Sec. 3.3). Instead, two references are coupled so that their product compensates it. The template P(t), read from the cyclic index s(t) (Eq. 8), gives the nominal phase, i.e., where the window should lie on the cycle. The gate gives the observed phase: in the time domain, the multiplicative part of Eq. (4) equals Re(wn)xn−Im(wn)H(xn), with H the Hilbert transform, so for a dominant component acos(ωτ+φ(t)) it is approximately ∣wn∣acos(ωτ+φ(t)+argwn), and the gate peaks follow φ(t) (Sec. 3.3, A.14). Hence, H=G⊙P reads the template at positions selected by the observed phase, which corrects the offset between the nominal and the observed phase without estimating it. Eq. (5) explains why the response depends on the window, whereas this coupling explains how the drift is corrected. Avoiding an explicit estimate keeps the gate at four real parameters per variate and avoids committing to a single offset when several periodic components are present. W2 verifies that this implicit correction recovers known phase offsets, measured on the forecasts against the phase of the target.
W2. Quantifying the correction of known phase offsets
Beyond Figs. 3–5, the revision adds quantitative evaluations against known phases (new Sec. 4.5, A.8–A.11):
W3. Distinguishing series with the same periodic structure but different levels
The level is not discarded but handled outside the gate. Following common practice, APA uses reversible instance normalization (RevIN; Kim et al., 2022), as now stated in App. A.2: each input window is normalized by its own mean and standard deviation before APA, and the forecast is de-normalized with the same statistics. APA thus models the normalized periodic structure, while the level of each window is restored exactly at the output, so two series with identical periodic structure but different levels receive forecasts that differ exactly by their levels. This division is consistent with the design of the gate: a level only changes the DC term of the spectrum, which adds the same constant to every position of R(t), and the softmax is invariant to such a constant. The prediction therefore combines three complementary sources: the level and scale of the window through the normalization statistics, its phase through G(t), and the periodic shape learned over the dataset through the template.
We hope these clarifications address the reviewer's concerns, and we are happy to discuss any further questions.