- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PaCo, a phase-aware framework for long-term time series forecasting. It combines circular phase features with an amplitude-based indicator to construct spectral phase coordinates. These coordinates modulate temporal patch representations and guide interactions between variables. Experiments on public benchmarks and an industrial wastewater dataset show strong forecasting performance with a moderate parameter count and relatively low reported computational cost.
Critical strengths
S1. PaCo achieves strong forecasting results on multiple datasets, with particularly good results on Exchange and the industrial WWTA dataset.
S2. The model obtains these results with a moderate number of parameters and relatively low reported computational cost.
S3. The experiments cover recent forecasting baselines, component ablations, parameter sensitivity, and efficiency comparisons.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The presentation is difficult to follow. The introduction discusses shifts across observation windows, but the transition to patch-level modulation and cross-variable interaction does not make clear which alignment variation each module addresses. Figure 1 illustrates sensitivity to coefficient perturbations rather than the temporal misalignment problem itself. A concrete example would make the motivation and structure easier to understand.
W2. The FFT is computed on patches of only 16 time steps. When the relevant periods are longer than a patch, spectral leakage and boundary effects may make the extracted phase sensitive to the window position. The paper acknowledges boundary effects, but does not examine phase reliability or forecasting performance across patch lengths. This leaves the suitability of such short patches insufficiently justified.
W3. Affine modulation changes feature scales and offsets, but this alone does not establish that the learned coordinates track temporal alignment. Figure 3 probes constructed descriptors rather than actual shifted input sequences. More direct evidence is needed to distinguish alignment-aware representations from general spectral conditioning.
W4. The amplitude-based indicator is motivated by equal-magnitude coefficient perturbations, but its relation to phase reliability under realistic noise remains unclear. Since amplitude is already provided to the encoder, comparisons with alternative amplitude normalizations would help justify this particular indicator.
W5. The ablations remove evidence, phase direction, and phase-guided context, but do not isolate the contribution of SPRL itself. A version without the affine modulation, together with a capacity-matched comparison using conventional Fourier features, would better identify the source of the improvement.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors illustrate the intended alignment variation on real input windows and show how the learned coordinates and forecasting errors respond to controlled temporal shifts?
2.How do phase stability and forecasting accuracy change with patch length, particularly when a patch covers less than one period of the underlying pattern?
3.Could the authors separately remove SPRL and compare the proposed coordinates with conventional Fourier features under the same model capacity? An alternative amplitude normalization would also help assess the evidence indicator.