- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies CATE estimation from observational data, where two problems appear together: confounders make the treated and control groups differ, and the two groups' covariate distributions are shifted. The proposed method, CSOT, first runs causal discovery to recover a DAG and the structural equations, takes the residuals of these equations as structure-conditioned individual deviations, concatenates them with the covariates, and encodes into a representation . It then builds the transport cost from two parts: the representation distance, and a residual distance where each covariate is weighted by a multi-hop structural influence computed from and normalized to unit average. Entropic OT between the treated and control empirical distributions gives the balancing loss, and the total objective is just the factual loss plus the OT loss. The paper proves a balancing error bound, a PEHE bound in terms of the structure-guided Wasserstein discrepancy, and a finite-sample version. Experiments are on IHDP, ACIC 2016 and a self-constructed synthetic benchmark, and CSOT reports the best within-sample on IHDP (0.552) and ACIC (1.277).
Critical strengths
- Combining causal structure with OT is a reasonable idea. OT-based CATE methods do generally ignore the dependence structure among covariates, and structure-based methods generally ignore the distribution shift, so using multi-hop influence weights to shape the transport cost is a natural direction.
- The three theorems form a complete chain: a balancing error bound, a PEHE bound, and a finite-sample bound. The mathematics is correct under the stated assumptions and is consistent with the classical CFR-Wass framework.
Critical weaknesses
- The theory is agnostic about the causal structure. The balancing bound holds for any cost function, so no theorem says that the structure-guided cost is better than the Euclidean one; what actually supports the method is the experiments, and the experimental controls are not clean enough for that. In particular, there is no random-graph or constant-weight control, which would show whether the gain comes from the structure itself or just from having some weighted cost, and no ablation that swaps the structure-guided cost for CFR-Pro's proximity cost while holding the backbone fixed.
- Under a linear SEM the residual is a linear transformation of the covariates. The structural equations are fitted by linear ridge regression, so and contains exactly the same information as ; the encoder could learn this transformation on its own. The claim that the residuals carry individual information that is otherwise unavailable therefore does not hold at the level of the implementation, and it would be worth either using a nonlinear or arguing explicitly that the benefit is an inductive bias rather than new information.
Questions for authors
- What is the name "SROT-CFR" in Appendix C.1 means.
- How does CSOT behave when the true structure is nonlinear? The synthetic DGP already contains nonlinear/interaction terms, so please report a recovered-graph-quality diagnostic (e.g. SHD to the true DAG) and a DAG-misspecification sensitivity study, to show the linear discovery is good enough.
2 comments
Dear Reviewer 7ouu,
Thank you for your comments. We would welcome your feedback on the added experimental controls and clarification of structural residuals. If our responses have addressed your concerns, we would greatly appreciate your support for our paper during the reviewer–AC discussion.
Sincerely,
The authors
Weakness 1. Causal structure in the theory and random-graph, constant-weight, and fixed-backbone cost controls.
Answer:
1. The causal structure enters Theorem 1 through the cost
Cij2=∥z1,i−z0,j∥22+λe∑k=1dsk(e1,ik−e0,jk)2.
The estimated graph determines both the structural residuals and their two-hop weights sk, influencing cross-group alignment. When the squared prediction losses satisfy the condition of Theorem 1, W(C,P1,P0) bounds their cross-group differences, connecting this structure-guided alignment to treatment effect estimation error.
2. On synthetic data (α=γ=1, ten data seeds), CSOT uses DirectLiNGAM. For the random-graph control, we randomly order the covariates and sample 32 forward edges, matching the true DAG's edge count and ensuring acyclicity. We refit the residuals and recompute sk using each random graph.
Graph-based weights reduce mean error by 5.2% relative to constant weights. CSOT also maintains comparable prediction accuracy under the random-graph control, suggesting robustness to graph misspecification in this setting.
3. We also replace the structure-guided cost with our implementation of CFR-Pro's proximity cost, keeping the backbone fixed, on ACIC experiment 1.
With the backbone fixed, the structure-guided cost achieves 4.3% lower test error than CFR-Pro's proximity cost. This controlled comparison supports the contribution of our cost design to improved treatment effect estimation in this experiment.
Weakness 2. Structural residuals as an inductive bias rather than additional information.
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for this observation. We agree that, once the linear structural equations are fitted, e is determined by x. As described in Section 4.1, the individual information captured by a structural residual refers to the variation in a covariate that is unexplained by its estimated parents. Explicitly incorporating these residuals into the encoder input and transport cost emphasizes such individual variations, helping prevent them from being overlooked during representation learning and cross-group alignment. This introduces a structure-aware inductive bias.
Q1: What is the name "SROT-CFR" in Appendix C.1 means.
Answer:
We apologize for this oversight. The name “SROT-CFR” in Appendix C.1 is incorrect and should read “CSOT”. We will correct it and check the manuscript for consistent method naming throughout.
Question 2. Nonlinear structures, graph-recovery diagnostics, and DAG-misspecification sensitivity.
Answer:
We thank the reviewer for this question.
1. Nonlinearity and graph quality.
We evaluate CSOT with DirectLiNGAM on synthetic data with α=1 under different nonlinearity strengths γ. As shown in Table 9, CSOT achieves mean test errors of 0.1240 and 0.1230 at γ=1 and 2, respectively, compared with 0.1247 under linear covariate mechanisms (γ=0). The table also reports the SHD to the true DAG.
Although SHD increases from 21.5 at γ=0 to 24.3 at γ=2, CSOT maintains a comparable mean prediction error (0.1247 versus 0.1230). These results support the effectiveness of CSOT with linear discovery under the nonlinear causal structures tested here.
2. Graph misspecification.
We compare the true graph, the estimated graph, and perturbed graphs on synthetic data; the results are shown in the table below.
The true graph achieves the lowest mean error, while the estimated and perturbed graphs retain comparable prediction performance. Even at 40% perturbation, the mean error remains close to the true-graph result (0.1180 versus 0.1174), supporting the robustness of CSOT to the graph misspecifications tested here.